The Message in the Bottle
The Things They Know About Each Other
Isla's Idea
The wind was strong that Saturday. Isla sat on her favorite rock, the one shaped like a sleeping whale, and watched the grey sea roll and tumble. She had been thinking about Marco all week.
Not thinking about him exactly—more like thinking of him. The way he wrote his questions so fast they seemed to trip over each other. The way he described storms like they were old friends. The way he always asked about her grandfather.
She pulled out her notebook. Her pencil was sharp. The page was empty.
And then she had an idea.
Dear Marco,
I've been thinking about all the things I know about you. They're in my head, scattered around. I want to put them all in one place.
I'm going to make a list. Every single thing I know about you. Will you make one about me?
Then we can trade.
Yours,
Isla
She read it twice. She changed "every single thing" to "everything." Then she changed it back. Then she sent it.
The Lists
Marco's letter arrived three weeks later. It was thick. Very thick. Isla pulled the pages out of the bottle and her eyes went wide.
The paper was covered in his big, looping handwriting. Some words were so rushed they ran off the edges. There were arrows pointing to more words in the margins. There was a drawing of a seagull with a speech bubble saying "HELLO" for no reason.
At the end, one neat line:
Your turn.
Isla unrolled her own list. She had worked on it for days, checking and rechecking. She had counted the items. One hundred and forty-three.
She started reading Marco's list.
It began:
Things I Know About Isla:
-
She lives near the sea but says it's grey more often than blue.
-
She likes the grey days best (she said this once, I didn't forget).
-
She types her letters but her handwriting is small and neat when she writes by hand.
-
She edits everything at least three times.
-
She has a rock shaped like a sleeping whale.
-
She says the sea at 4pm is "the color of a tired mirror."
-
She laughs at my jokes even when they're not funny, but she says they ARE funny, which means she's funny too.
Isla smiled. She kept reading.
-
Her grandfather taught her to fish.
-
She doesn't like fishing but she likes being with him.
-
She has a mum who hums when she cooks.
-
She wrote a poem about seagulls once and it was short but good.
-
She is scared of the sea sometimes but loves it anyway.
Isla stopped. Number twelve. She hadn't told Marco that. Or had she? She couldn't remember. But he knew. Somehow, he knew.
She read the rest. He had written one hundred and fifty-two things. Nine more than hers.
At the bottom, he had added:
Also: she makes lists that are very complete, and I like that about her.
Isla sat on her sleeping whale rock, and she read her own list.
Things I Know About Marco:
-
He lives on an island so small you can see the whole shape of it from the highest hill.
-
His handwriting is very large because he writes fast.
-
He asks a lot of questions, sometimes five in one sentence.
-
He likes seagulls but doesn't trust them.
-
He has a boat model he built himself from broken bottle crates.
-
He says storms are "alive" and I thought he was being silly until he described one and I believed him.
-
His grandmother sends bread in bottles.
-
He tells jokes that are terrible and then laughs at them himself.
-
He was scared when his school was closing and didn't say so, but I could tell.
-
He is scared of the sea sometimes but loves it anyway.
Isla looked at number ten.
She hadn't planned that one either. But there it was. The same thing. On both lists.
The Same Incomplete
Isla wrote back slowly. She wanted to get it right.
Dear Marco,
We both wrote ten.
I didn't do that on purpose. But when I looked at my list, there it was. We are both scared of the sea sometimes and love it anyway.
I think our lists are longer than we thought they would be.
But also—here is the true thing, the one I put in every letter—I think our lists are incomplete in the same ways.
There are things I don't know about you. There are things you don't know about me. And I think—
She paused. The pencil hovered.
I think those things are the same kinds of things.
Like what it sounds like when we laugh for real.
Like what we do when we're sad and no one's watching.
Like what our hands look like when we're holding something we love.
I don't know those things about you. And you don't know those things about me.
But I think we will someday.
Your friend,
Isla
She folded the letter. She put it in a bottle. She walked to the water's edge where the grey sea licked the stones, and she threw it as far as she could.
The sea took it. The sea always took them.
She watched the bottle bob and disappear among the waves, and she thought about Marco, on his warm bright island, writing with his rushed handwriting. She thought about the list he would make someday, after they'd known each other longer. She thought about how lists can grow.
The wind picked up. The sea changed color—from grey to silver to something in between.
Isla smiled.
She thought about number eleven on their lists.
There will be more, she thought. There will always be more.
And she walked home to wait for the next bottle.