The Message in the Bottle
What Isla Writes Back
The Longest Letter
Isla sat at her desk with a piece of paper in front of her.
She had waited all week for this moment. The bottle had arrived on Tuesday—a Tuesday!—with Marco's answer inside. She had read it twelve times already. She had memorized every word.
"You asked if anyone was out there. I'm out here."
Now she had to write back.
Isla picked up her pencil. She wrote:
Dear Marco,
Then she stopped.
What do you say to someone who found your bottle after two years? Someone who lives on the other side of the ocean? Someone who is also eight years old and also likes seagulls?
Isla wrote:
Thank you for finding my bottle. I have sent many bottles. You are the first person to write back.
She read it. She crossed out "many bottles." It sounded like she was complaining.
She wrote:
I have sent some bottles.
She crossed that out too.
Isla's grandfather came to the door. "How's the letter going?"
"It's hard," said Isla.
Her grandfather nodded. He was a fisherman. He knew about hard things. "The sea doesn't rush," he said. "The letter can take time too."
Fourteen Times
Isla wrote the letter fourteen times.
The first version was too short. The second version was too long. The third version had a drawing of her house, but she didn't like the way the roof looked, so she started over.
The fourth version said:
My grandfather is a fisherman. He taught me to throw bottles in the sea. He says the sea carries things to the right place.
That was good. She kept that.
The fifth version said:
What does your island look like? What color is your sea? Do you have a dog?
She added three more questions. Then she took them out. She didn't want to ask too much.
The seventh version had a drawing of a seagull. She liked the seagull. She kept the seagull.
The ninth version was the one where she almost told him about her mum's job at the bakery, but she decided that was for another letter.
The eleventh version made her laugh because she accidentally wrote "I am eight years old and so is the sea" and it sounded like the sea was eight years old.
The thirteenth version was almost right. But something was missing.
The True Thing
Isla's grandfather found her sitting on the rocks, watching the waves.
"What's wrong?" he asked.
"The letter isn't done," said Isla. "It needs one true thing. Every letter should have one true thing."
Her grandfather sat down beside her. The sea was grey today, with white caps on the waves. The wind was strong.
"What's the true thing you want to say?" he asked.
Isla thought about it.
She thought about how she had been sending bottles since she was six. How she had wondered if anyone was out there. How sometimes, late at night, she wondered if she was sending them into nothing.
"I want to tell him that I didn't know if anyone was out there," said Isla. "I kept sending bottles anyway. But I didn't really believe."
Her grandfather was quiet for a moment.
"That is a true thing," he said.
"Do you think it's okay to tell a stranger that?"
"He's not a stranger," said her grandfather. "He found your bottle. He wrote back. That makes him something."
"What does it make him?"
Her grandfather smiled. "A friend you haven't met yet."
The Fourteenth Time
Isla went back to her desk.
She wrote the letter one more time. The fourteenth time.
This is what she wrote:
Dear Marco,
Thank you for finding my bottle. You are the first person to write back.
My grandfather is a fisherman. He taught me to throw bottles in the sea. He says the sea carries things to the right place.
I want to tell you one true thing: I didn't know if anyone was out there. I kept sending bottles anyway. But I didn't really believe anyone would answer.
What does your island look like? What color is your sea?
From Isla
P.S. I drew a seagull. I hope you like seagulls.
Isla read it one more time. Her heart was beating fast. The true thing was in there now, right in the middle, like a smooth stone in her pocket.
She folded the letter carefully. She put it in the bottle. She walked down to the water.
Waiting
The sea was different today. Not grey and rough like this morning—quieter, softer, with small waves that barely reached her boots.
Isla stood at the edge of the water.
She thought about Marco on his island, somewhere across the ocean. She didn't know what his island looked like. She didn't know what color his sea was. But she knew he was out there.
She threw the bottle as far as she could.
It landed with a small splash. It bobbed for a moment. Then it began to float away.
"Go," Isla whispered. "Find him."
She watched until she couldn't see the bottle anymore.
The sea carried it away, slowly, like it had its own plans.
Isla walked home. Her grandfather was mending nets on the porch.
"Did you send it?" he asked.
"I sent it," said Isla.
"Good," he said. "Now you wait."
Isla sat down beside him. The wind was picking up. The sea was getting grey again.
"How long will it take?" she asked.
"However long it takes," said her grandfather. "The sea doesn't rush. But it always carries things to the right place."
Isla looked at the water. Somewhere out there, her letter was floating. Somewhere out there, Marco was waiting for it, even if he didn't know it yet.
She had sent fourteen drafts. She had told him one true thing. She had thrown the bottle into the sea.
Now all she could do was wait.
And the sea, grey and green and full of secrets, carried her words across the water.