← Library

The Message in the Bottle

What Marco Is Afraid Of

The Letter That Started It

Dear Isla,

You asked me what I'm afraid of. About meeting. You said you're afraid the real me won't match the letter me. That's a good fear. I understand that one.

But that's not what I'm afraid of.

I'm afraid of something else. Something I haven't written about before. Not to you, not to Grandmother, not to anyone.

I'm afraid of the sea.

Wait. Let me explain. I know that sounds silly. I live on an island. My uncle is a fisherman. I've been on boats since I could walk. I know the weather better than most adults. I've told you about storms like they're old friends.

So when I say I'm afraid of the sea, I mean something different.

I'm afraid of what the sea carries away.


Marco wrote this letter in one sitting, which was unusual for him. He usually writes in bursts, getting up to check the weather, eating something, coming back. But this time he sat at the table until it was done.

His grandmother saw him from the kitchen. She didn't say anything. She just put a glass of water beside his hand and went back to her cooking.


What Marco Means

Isla,

I'm going to try to write this so it makes sense. But I'm not sure it will. You're better at true things than I am. You have practice. I'm just learning.

Here's what I'm afraid of:

When I was five, my mother went out on a boat. Not a big boat. Just a small one, to check the nets. The weather was fine. Everyone said fine. She kissed my head and told me she'd be back for lunch.

She didn't come back for lunch.

They found the boat. They never found her. The sea took her and kept her. That's what the sea does sometimes. It takes things and doesn't give them back.

I've never told you this. I've told you about the weather and the island and the storms. I've told you about Grandmother's bread and Uncle's fishing stories. But I never told you that the sea already took someone from me.

I'm afraid that if I meet you, the sea will take you too.

Not because of the boat trip, even though that's what my head says. Because I'll finally have you in person. And I know the sea likes to take the things I love most.

I wrote this and I'm going to put it in the bottle now before I lose my nerve.

If this is too much, you don't have to write back about it. We can go back to weather reports and bad jokes. I won't mind.

I won't mind.

I promise I won't mind.

Marco


He sealed the bottle and held it for a long time. The sea was calm that day, which felt wrong. He wanted it to be storming. He wanted the weather to match how he felt.

But the sea doesn't do what you want. It does what it does. That's part of what he wrote to Isla.

He threw the bottle anyway.


Isla's Reply

Dear Marco,

I read your letter four times. Then I read it again.

I want to say the right thing. I'm not sure there is a right thing. So I'm just going to say what I know.

My grandfather says the sea doesn't take things out of cruelty. It's not a person. It doesn't have wishes. It's just water and weather and time. Things happen in it. People get lost in it. But it's not because the sea wanted them.

I don't know if that helps. I'm not sure it helped me when I thought about it. My grandfather is slower now than he was. I'm afraid of what's coming. I know what's coming. The sea isn't taking him, but something is. I think about that at night sometimes. I think about it a lot.

Here's what I know about meeting:

I'm still afraid too. You wrote that your fear is different from mine. But I think they're the same fear. We're both afraid that something will take the other away before we get to stand on the same shore.

The sea took your mother. I'm so sorry, Marco. I'm so sorry she never came back for lunch.

But the sea also brought me your bottle.

The sea carries things away, yes. But it also carries things to us. It carried your letters to me. It carried your jokes and your weather reports and your terrible drawings of your island. It carried the truth about your fear.

The sea gave you to me, Marco. That's also true.

I don't know if we'll ever meet. I hope we will. I hope it more than I've ever hoped anything.

And if we do meet, I'll stand on the shore with you. And we'll look at the sea together. And we'll know it's the same sea that took things and also gave us each other.

That's what I think about when I'm scared.

I'm keeping this letter separate from the others. It's the truest thing you've written.

You said you wouldn't mind if I didn't write back about it. But I did write back. Because you told me, and I wanted to hold it.

Yours,

Isla


Isla folded the letter carefully. Then she wrote one more line at the bottom, which she almost erased. But she left it.


The Last Line

At the bottom of Isla's letter, under her name, in smaller handwriting, she had written:

P.S. I think if we meet, the sea will be glad. It brought us together. It gets to see it happen.


She sealed the bottle and walked to the water's edge. The sea was grey that day, which was normal for her coast. But she saw it differently now. She saw it as the same water that touched Marco's island. The same water that had carried his words to her.

The bottle floated on the surface for a moment. Then it caught the current and moved away.

Isla watched until it was too small to see.

Then she went home and told her grandfather that she was learning new things about the sea.

He asked what things.

She said: "That it can carry things away and bring things back. And that sometimes you don't know which one is happening until it already has."

Her grandfather nodded. He had known this a long time.

He said: "And sometimes the same wave does both."


On his island, Marco waited. He didn't know Isla's answer was coming. He didn't know that his letter had already begun its journey across the water.

He just knew he had written the truest thing he'd ever written.

And that someone on the other side of the ocean would hold it carefully.

And that was something. That was a lot, actually.

That was the whole thing.

THE END