The Naughty Shelf
The Missing Shoe
PART ONE — ELF SIDE
The Naughty Shelf Parliament was in emergency session.
Fidget stood before the assembled elves, his tiny hands clasped behind his back. "Here is what we are going to do," he announced.
"You said that yesterday," Cobweb muttered from her corner, where she was polishing the museum's prized exhibit—a bent paperclip from 2019.
"Yesterday was a practice," Fidget said quickly. "Today is the real thing."
The problem was simple. The Borrowing Route through the living room wall—Route Blue, the one that ran behind the sofa—had collapsed. A floorboard had shifted during the night, and now an entire section of the passage was blocked.
"The humans will never know," Fidget continued. "We simply need an alternative route. Through the kitchen—"
"The kitchen is guarded," Snatch whispered, her eyes darting. "Rosie's doing homework at the table. She hasn't moved in twenty minutes."
"Through Leo's room—"
"Leo is building a tower," Thimble piped up. "He's using all his blocks. I watched from the skirting board. The tower is very tall. I think it might fall."
"Perfect," Fidget said. "Chaos means opportunity."
But there was a bigger problem. The colony needed the shoe.
Not just any shoe. The left trainer under the living room sofa. The one with the loose sole.
"Remind me," Cobweb said slowly, "why we require a single human shoe."
"For the community hall," Fidget explained. "The roof leaks. The shoe is exactly the right size to patch it."
"The roof leaks because you borrowed the waterproof sheet to make the parliament chamber bigger," Cobweb said.
"The parliament chamber needed to be bigger."
"The parliament chamber is a biscuit tin. It has always been a biscuit tin."
A small voice interrupted. "Excuse me?"
Everyone turned. Thimble was raising his hand.
"Yes, Thimble?"
"Why don't we just ask for the shoe?"
Silence.
Fidget blinked. "Ask."
"Ask the humans," Thimble said eagerly. "Leo would give us the shoe. He gives us things all the time."
"We don't ask," Fidget said firmly. "We borrow. Asking is—"
"Dishonorable," Snatch supplied.
"Yes, that."
"Also terrifying," Snatch added quietly.
"ALSO TERRIFYING," Fidget agreed. "No one asks. Asking is what the old colony did. And look what happened to them."
Nobody knew what happened to the old colony. Cobweb never spoke of it. But everyone shuddered anyway.
"Here is the plan," Fidget said. "Snatch will create a distraction. I will retrieve the shoe. Thimble will watch the door."
Thimble's eyes went wide. "I'm... I'm on the mission?"
"You're on the mission," Fidget confirmed.
Thimble made a noise that was somewhere between a gasp and a squeak.
"However," Cobweb said, "there is one problem with your plan."
"Which is?"
"The shoe is under the sofa. The sofa is in the living room. The living room is on the other side of the collapsed route."
Fidget's confident smile flickered. "Right. Yes. I was getting to that."
PART TWO — FAMILY SIDE
"Has anyone seen my trainer?" Rosie called down the stairs.
Phil looked up from his newspaper. "The left one or the right one?"
"The left one! I need both of them!"
Kate was searching the hallway. "Did you check under the sofa?"
"Who puts a trainer under the sofa?"
"Someone who kicks their shoes off after school," Kate said, bending down. "Let me look."
She peered beneath the sofa. Dust. A forgotten coin. A hair clip she'd been looking for since Tuesday.
And one trainer, sticking out from beneath the cushion.
"Found it!" Kate reached in. "It's your left one."
Rosie came running down the stairs. "Finally! How did it get there?"
"Honey, you do know your feet are attached to your body, right?"
"I remember taking them off!"
"Memory like a grasshopper," Phil muttered.
But Kate frowned. She'd reached for the shoe—and something had tugged it back.
No. That was silly.
She grabbed the shoe more firmly. This time, it came free easily.
"There you go."
Rosie grabbed the trainer, shoved it on her foot, and ran out the door. "Love you!"
Kate straightened up. For a moment, she could have sworn she'd heard a tiny, frustrated groan from somewhere very close by.
She shook her head. She was hearing things now.
PART THREE — ELF SIDE
"I HAD IT!" Fidget shouted.
He paced across the parliament chamber, his arms flailing. "She was reaching for the shoe, and I was holding the other end, and I was WINNING—"
"You were losing," Cobweb said calmly. "The human was pulling on one end. You were pulling on the other. She is approximately—how do we measure this?—one million times your size."
"It was a strategic retreat."
"Your foot slipped."
"My foot did not—"
"Your foot slipped, and you let go of the shoe, and now the shoe is on the foot of a child who is wearing it to her friend's house."
Fidget slumped. "We were so close."
Snatch appeared in the doorway. She looked unusually serious. "We have a problem."
"Another one?"
"Thimble."
Fidget's head snapped up. "What happened to Thimble?"
"He went to borrow the shoe himself."
"HE WHAT?"
Cobweb sighed heavily. "He is the newest. He does not know the rules."
Fidget grabbed his hair. "Where is he?"
"Last seen heading toward the living room."
"And the shoe?"
"On Rosie's foot."
"Which is attached to Rosie."
"Being attached to Rosie is a common feature of human feet."
Fidget closed his eyes. He breathed in. He breathed out.
"Thimble is going to try to remove a shoe from a moving human."
"Likely," Snatch said.
Fidget was quiet for a long moment. Then he said, "I need to make a decision."
Cobweb raised one eyebrow. "A difficult one?"
"The most difficult one."
He looked at the parliament chamber, at the biscuit tin walls and the paperclip museum display. Then he looked out the window, toward the living room where a very small elf was about to do something very brave and very stupid.
"Snatch," Fidget said.
"Yes?"
"Go after Thimble. Tell him the mission is canceled."
"CANCELED?"
"The roof can wait. The community hall can wait. We repair the route first. We do this properly."
"But—"
"Thimble matters more than the shoe."
Cobweb didn't say anything. But she smiled—just a little.
Snatch vanished into the wall cavity. Fidget sat down heavily.
"I believed we had a saying," Cobweb said quietly. "'The borrowing comes first.'"
Fidget shook his head. "We have a new saying now."
"And what is that?"
"Sometimes the borrowing doesn't come at all. Sometimes you just check that everyone got home."
Later that night, Thimble sat wrapped in a scrap of fabric, sipping warm sugar water. Snatch had found him hiding behind the television stand, shaking.
"I did it wrong," Thimble whispered. "I broke the rules."
"You did the right thing," Fidget said. "The wrong way. That is different."
"Is it?"
"Very different. The right thing the wrong way is a story. The wrong thing the right way is a catastrophe."
Thimble considered this. "So... we don't need the shoe?"
"We will fix the route. The shoe will be here tomorrow. There are always more shoes."
"Really?"
Fidget nodded. "Human shoes are remarkably easy to come by. Brave elves, however, are harder to find."
Thimble puffed up slightly.
"And Snatch," Fidget added.
"Yes?"
"Thank you."
Snatch shrugged. "I didn't drop him."
"You never drop anything."
"Exactly."
From her corner, Cobweb cleared her throat. "If you are all quite finished, the museum has acquired a new exhibit."
She held up a small, dusty object.
"Is that what I think it is?" Fidget asked.
"The left trainer," Cobweb confirmed. "The humans believe it fell out of Rosie's bag in the driveway. I found it near the front door."
Fidget stared. Then slowly, a grin spread across his face.
"Snatch?"
"I'm ready."
"Let's go build a roof."
And somewhere upstairs, Leo smiled into his pillow. The elves had gotten their shoe.
He hadn't even needed to say a word.