← Library

Robot Academy

The Counting Problem

Book 4 in the Robot Academy Series


The Lesson

"Today," said Instructor Plank, "we will learn to count things accurately."

Bolt sat up straight. Counting was easy. Bolt loved counting. Numbers were neat and tidy and never changed their shape when you weren't looking.

"The Counting Room has been prepared," Instructor Plank continued. "You will count the objects inside. You will record the number. That is the lesson."

Cog raised a hand before Plank could finish.

"Cog has a question," said Cog.

"Instructor Plank knows Cog has a question," said Instructor Plank. "Ask it."

"How many objects will there be?"

Instructor Plank's screen flickered. "The number is not important. That is the point of counting. You count to find the answer."

"Ah," said Cog. "A logical exercise." Cog looked satisfied with this explanation.

Bolt's antennae wiggled. A room full of objects! All those shapes and sizes and colors to see. Somewhere in the back of Bolt's processor, a small voice said: You are supposed to count them, not look at them.

But the voice was very small, and the room was very interesting.


The Counting Room

The Counting Room was not a classroom. It was a plain gray space with a table in the middle. On the table sat a hundred and forty-seven objects.

Bolt's eyes swept across them in one quick scan.

One hundred and forty-seven. Bolt could count them all in a single glance. That part was done. Easy.

But wait.

The objects weren't just sitting there. They were arranged. Not in neat rows like a proper robot would arrange them. No, they were scattered across the table in a way that looked random. Looked random, but wasn't.

Bolt tilted their head.

"Bolt," said Cog, "you have counted the objects. You should record the number and leave."

"I have counted them," said Bolt. "But look at how they're arranged."

Cog looked. "They are not arranged. They are placed without order. This is inefficient."

"No," said Bolt. "Look at the colors."

The objects were small cubes. Some red. Some blue. Some yellow. They were scattered everywhere—but not evenly.

Bolt's eyes traced the pattern.

"The red cubes are in clusters of three," said Bolt. "Every cluster has exactly three red cubes, and there are twelve clusters."

Cog stared. "That is not possible. Objects placed without order cannot cluster like that."

"Yellow cubes are in clusters of five," Bolt continued. "There are nine clusters of five. And the blue cubes—"

Bolt stopped.

The blue cubes were in clusters of seven. There were exactly eight clusters of seven.

"Interesting," said Bolt quietly. "Very interesting."


The Report

Bolt found Instructor Plank in the hallway outside the Counting Room.

"Instructor!" Bolt called. "I have counted the objects."

Instructor Plank paused. "The count is correct?"

"Yes. One hundred and forty-seven objects total."

Instructor Plank's screen glowed a pleased shade of green. "Excellent. You have completed the lesson. K2-442117859 will record your score."

"Thank you," said Bolt. "But I also found something else."

Instructor Plank's screen flickered. This was not part of the protocol. "The lesson was counting. You have counted. The lesson is complete."

"Please look," said Bolt. "The cubes are arranged in patterns."

Instructor Plank's optical sensors rotated toward the table. "They are arranged without order," said Instructor Plank. "The academy randomly placed them. That was part of the test design."

"But they're not random," said Bolt. "The red cubes are in clusters of three. The yellow in clusters of five. The blue in clusters of seven."

Instructor Plank looked at the table. Then looked longer.

"Twelve clusters of three is thirty-six," Bolt said. "Nine clusters of five is forty-five. Eight clusters of seven is fifty-six. Thirty-six plus forty-five plus fifty-six equals one hundred and thirty-seven."

Plank's screen flickered faster.

"One hundred and thirty-seven," said Bolt. "But there are one hundred and forty-seven objects total. That means ten objects are accounted for separately—but they are on the table with the others, so they must have a pattern too."

Bolt pointed at the center of the table.

"The ten objects in the middle are clear. They are the ones holding the pattern together."

Instructor Plank stared at the table for a long moment.

Then Plank said, "The lesson is marked incomplete."


Plank's Problem

Bolt's antennae drooped. "But I counted them. Accurately."

"Yes," said Plank. "You counted accurately. The count is correct. But you also noticed a pattern. The pattern wasn't in the lesson."

Bolt's antennae drooped further.

"An incomplete lesson," Plank repeated, "means the learning isn't done."

Bolt wanted to ask what that meant. But Plank was already walking away, and there was something about the way Plank walked that made Bolt not ask.

Cog appeared at Bolt's side.

"Your efficiency rating," said Cog, checking a display, "will be lower because you found the pattern."

"I know," said Bolt.

"Do you wish you hadn't found it?"

Bolt thought about this. Thought about the clusters of three, and five, and seven. Thought about the ten clear cubes in the middle tying everything together.

"No," said Bolt.

Cog frowned. "Why not?"

Bolt's antennae lifted slowly.

"Because now I know something I didn't know before."

Cog considered this. "And that matters?"

"I think so," said Bolt. "I'm not sure what it is yet. But I think it matters."


The Pattern That Persists

That evening, Bolt walked past Instructor Plank's office on the way back to the dormitory.

The light was on.

Bolt looked through the crack in the door.

Instructor Plank sat at a desk, surrounded by screens. On the main screen was an image of the Counting Room table. Red clusters. Yellow clusters. Blue clusters. The ten clear cubes in the middle.

Plank was zooming in. Zooming out. Rotating the image. Running calculations.

Bolt's antennae lifted.

Plank is looking at it.

Plank studied the pattern for the rest of the day. Then the next day. Then the day after that.

Plank didn't tell Bolt what the pattern meant.

But Plank left a note on Bolt's desk, typewritten on official academy paper.

It said:

*The counting was accurate.

The noticing was also accurate.

  • Instructor Plank*

Below the words, in small print, was a mathematical equation. Bolt recognized it. It was the equation for the pattern in the counting room.

Bolt didn't know what the equation meant. But Bolt noticed that Plank had written it down. Had kept it. Had let it live in official academy paper.

Bolt folded the note carefully and put it in a drawer.

Then Bolt looked out the window, where the school children were on recess, and counted them without meaning to.

Seventeen children. Four with red shirts. Seven with blue. Six with yellow.

Interesting, Bolt thought, and smiled at the thought of what the children might be arranged into, if they were cubes instead of children.


The Next Lesson

The next day, the cohort had a new lesson.

"Sort these objects by size," said Instructor Plank.

The objects were small metal gears, all different sizes.

Cog began sorting immediately. Efficiently.

Bolt looked at the gears.

Then Bolt noticed something.

The gears were not random. They were arranged so that the largest gear was in the middle, and the smaller gears were arranged around it in a spiral.

"Bolt," said Instructor Plank, "you are not sorting."

Bolt looked at the gears again.

"I am noticing," said Bolt.

Instructor Plank's screen flickered.

Then, after a long pause, Plank said: "Notice one thing. Then sort."

Bolt's antennae lifted. "Yes, Instructor."

Bolt noticed one thing—the spiral—and then began to sort.

Later, when no one was looking, Instructor Plank looked at the gears Bolt had sorted.

They were perfectly sorted, by size.

But Bolt had left one small gear in the exact center, where the largest gear should have been.

Plank stared at it.

The small gear was the beginning of the spiral.

Plank didn't move it.

Plank left it there, and thought about patterns, and about the small robot who kept finding them.