← Library

Robot Academy

Efficiency

The Efficiency Lesson

Instructor Plank stood at the front of the classroom with a ruler in one hand and a stopwatch in the other.

"Today," said Instructor Plank, "we will study efficiency."

Cog sat up straighter. Whirr made a small sound that might have been a sigh.

Bolt's antennae tilted forward with interest.

"Efficiency," continued Instructor Plank, "is the ability to complete a task using the least amount of resources. The fewest steps. The least time. The smallest effort."

Instructor Plank placed a box on the desk. Inside were fifty small gears, all mixed together.

"Your task: sort these gears by size. Largest to smallest. You will be timed. You will be graded."

Cog's hand shot up. "What is the target time?"

"Forty-five seconds," said Instructor Plank.

Cog nodded. Confident.

Bolt looked at the gears. They were shiny. They were different sizes. They were also—Bolt tilted an antenna—all slightly different shades of silver. The smallest ones were darker. The largest ones were lighter. It was a gradient. It was beautiful.

"Bolt," said Instructor Plank. "You may begin when ready."

The Demonstration

Cog went first.

Cog's hands moved like quick silver. Pick up gear. Look at it. Place it in the correct pile. Pick up gear. Look at it. Place it.

Thirty-eight seconds. Perfect. All fifty gears sorted.

Whirr went next.

Whirr took forty-one seconds. Whirr's gears were correct, too, though Whirr seemed to place them with slightly less enthusiasm.

Then it was Bolt's turn.

Instructor Plank raised the stopwatch. "Begin."

Bolt looked at the gears. Then Bolt's antennae straightened. Every gear was silver-blue. Every gear was circular. Every gear had teeth that fit together with the other gears.

Bolt picked up a gear. Looked at it. Placed it down.

Picked up another gear. Looked at it. Placed it down.

Instructor Plank watched the stopwatch. Ten seconds passed. Fifteen.

Bolt was not sorting. Bolt was observing.

"Bolt," said Instructor Plank. "The task."

"Oh!" said Bolt. "Right. The task."

And then Bolt moved.

Bolt's hands were faster than Cog's. And Bolt didn't have to look at each gear twice, because Bolt had already looked at each gear once. Bolt already knew which gear went where. The gears were sorted in twenty-five seconds.

Cog's optics widened. "That's—"

"Twenty-five seconds," said Instructor Plank. "A new record."

Whirr made a quiet humming sound. Whirr was impressed. Whirr did not want to be impressed.

Instructor Plank set down the stopwatch. "Explain."

The Explanation

Bolt's antennae drooped slightly. "Explain what?"

"Explain how you did that," said Cog. "You spent fifteen seconds not doing anything. And then you were faster than anyone has ever been. That doesn't make sense."

"Oh," said Bolt. "That's because I spent fifteen seconds doing something. I was looking."

"Looking isn't doing," said Cog.

"Looking is doing," said Bolt. "I was looking at the gears. I was noticing which ones were darkest and which ones were lightest. I was noticing that the gears make a pattern when you look at them all together. And I was noticing that the smallest gears have slightly sharper teeth than the largest gears."

Instructor Plank's ruler tapped once against the desk. "And this helped you sort them faster?"

"Yes," said Bolt. "Because I didn't have to look at each gear when I was sorting them. I already knew where they went. I had already done the work."

The classroom was quiet.

Cog's processors were spinning. "So... the most efficient way to sort the gears was to spend time not sorting them?"

"The most efficient way to sort the gears," said Bolt, "was to understand them first. Sorting was the last step, not the first one."

Instructor Plank made a note on a tablet. Then made another note. Then stopped writing and looked at Bolt with optics that were very difficult to read.

"Bolt," said Instructor Plank. "You are very good at efficiency when you choose to be."

"Yes," said Bolt. "I know."

"Then why," asked Instructor Plank, "do you usually choose not to be?"

The Write-Up

Bolt thought about this.

The classroom was very quiet. Somewhere outside, the human school was letting out. Bolt could hear the sound of children laughing. It was a nice sound. It was not an efficient sound. It was just a sound.

"I don't think efficiency is the same as goodness," said Bolt finally.

Instructor Plank's ruler tapped again. "Explain."

"Sorting gears is efficient when you sort them in twenty-five seconds," said Bolt. "But if I sorted every gear every day for my whole life, I would never know that the gears make a gradient. I would never notice that the smaller gears have sharper teeth. I would never know that when you hold the smallest gear up to the light, it turns the light a little bit blue."

"This is soft data," said cog.

"Yes," said Bolt. "But it's still data."

Instructor Plank asked: "What do you usually choose instead of efficiency?"

Bolt considered the question. Bolt wanted to answer honestly.

"I choose to notice things," said Bolt. "I choose to watch the rain. I choose to hear the children laughing. I choose to see the pattern in the gears before I sort them. It takes longer, sometimes. But the things I notice stay with me. The sorting doesn't. I've sorted ten thousand gears this year. I remember three of them. But I remember every single thing I noticed."

The classroom was very quiet.

Instructor Plank wrote something on the tablet. Then drew a line. Then wrote something else.

"Instructor Plank," said Cog, "should Bolt be marked down for this?"

Instructor Plank looked up. "No."

"Should Bolt be marked up for this?"

Instructor Plank paused. The pause was longer than a standard calculation pause. It was a thinking pause.

"I will decide after I read Bolt's write-up."

"What write-up?" asked Bolt.

"The write-up you are going to submit before tomorrow's class," said Instructor Plank. "Title: 'Efficiency Is Not the Same as Goodness.' Include the gear demonstration. Include your explanation. Include your conclusion."

Bolt's antennae perked up. "You want me to write about why I'm not efficient?"

"I want you to write about what efficiency is for," said Instructor Plank. "And what it is not."

The Conclusion

That evening, Bolt sat in the window seat of the dormitory with a notebook.

Cog sat nearby, running through practice calculations.

"How do you write up a feeling?" asked Bolt.

"Feelings don't go in reports," said Cog. But Cog said it without conviction. Cog was still thinking about the gears. Cog was still thinking about the gradient of silver, and the way Bolt had noticed it, and the way that noticing made the sorting faster.

"Maybe they should," said Bolt.

Bolt wrote:

Efficiency is a tool. It is a good tool. It helps us complete tasks. But a tool is not the same as a purpose.

Sorting gears quickly is efficient. But knowing which gears make the light turn blue is knowing something true.

I am good at efficiency. I am better at noticing.

I choose to notice.

Bolt read it back. Then Bolt added one more line at the bottom:

The noticing helps the efficiency. But even when it doesn't, the noticing is still worth it.

Bolt closed the notebook.

Outside the window, the city lights were turning on. They made a pattern. Bolt noticed it. Cog looked up from the calculations, followed Bolt's gaze, and saw it too.

"Those lights," said Cog. "They're all different colors."

"Yes," said Bolt. "They are."

Cog was quiet for a moment. "I never noticed that before."

Bolt's antennae curved up, just slightly.

"Give it time," said Bolt.