The Substitute Planet
Bex Does Not Touch the Thing
The Briefing
Ms. Venn stood at the front of the Hopper with a picture of a very angry-looking moon. It was orange and yellow and covered in spots that looked like they were boiling.
"This is Io," Ms. Venn said. "It is the most volcanically active world in our entire solar system. Over four hundred volcanoes. Some erupt every single day."
Bex leaned forward. "Can we touch the volcanoes?"
"No," said Ms. Venn, very quickly.
"Can we touch the lava?"
"No."
"The rocks?"
"No."
"The ground?"
Ms. Venn paused. "The ground is technically touching, but—"
"Great!" Bex said.
Ms. Venn held up a finger. "Here is the briefing, and I want everyone to listen very carefully." She looked directly at Bex. "Do not touch anything on Io."
Bex nodded. "Got it."
"Do you really have it?" Zara asked, flipping open her journal. "Because last time we went to Mercury, you touched a thermal rock formation and it started doing something."
"That was different," Bex said. "That rock looked touchable."
"Everything on Io is going to look touchable," Ms. Venn said. "That's the challenge. The ground is covered in sulfur compounds. The surface is constantly being reshaped by volcanic activity. Touching things here isn't just dangerous—it's impossible to predict what might happen."
Otto raised his hand. "But what if—"
"Otto, we don't have time for what-ifs today. We have a very clear rule." Ms. Venn smiled her brightest smile. "Nobody touches anything. We observe. We collect data with our instruments. We leave Io exactly as we found it."
She checked her watch. "Suit up, everyone. We land in ten minutes."
The Landing
Io was loud.
Not loud like a school cafeteria. Loud like a thousand school cafeterias all shaking at once. The ground rumbled and groaned beneath their boots. In the distance, a plume of gas shot up from a volcano called Prometheus, spraying orange and yellow material high into the thin sky.
"Amazing!" Zara shouted over the noise, scribbling in her journal. "Io's gravity is about one-sixth of Earth's, so the volcanic plumes can reach really high!"
"The gravity feels weird," Otto said, hopping experimentally. He went higher than he expected. "Everything feels lighter."
"That's the gravity," said Ms. Venn. "Now everyone, spread out in pairs. Remember: observation only. We have twelve minutes before the Hopper's orbit window closes."
Bex stood very still.
This was unusual.
"Bex?" Ms. Venn asked. "Are you okay?"
"I'm not touching anything," Bex said. "I'm standing here with my hands at my sides. Look at me not touching things."
"That's... good," Ms. Venn said carefully. "That's exactly right."
Bex looked around. There were rocks everywhere. Beautiful, colorful rocks. Some were red. Some were yellow. Some were greenish-white from sulfur compounds. They were just sitting there. Being rocks. Being touchable.
"I can do this," Bex muttered to herself. "I can do this. I don't need to touch things."
She looked at a particularly interesting rock. It was pale yellow with streaks of orange, and it seemed to be steaming slightly.
"I definitely don't need to touch that rock," she said.
The rock made a small bubbling sound.
"That rock is probably very interesting to touch," Bex whispered. "But I'm not going to touch it. Because I am a person who doesn't touch things."
The Hard Part
Zara had found a perfect spot to document a volcanic vent. She was on her knees (which did count as touching, but she was wearing a suit and it was scientifically necessary) and sketching the eruption pattern in her journal.
"Notice the shape of the plume," she called out. "It's like an umbrella! The gas expands rapidly and—"
Bex wandered past. Her hands were shoved deep in her pockets.
"I'm not touching anything," she announced.
"That's great," Zara said. "Do you want to help me record the sulfur dioxide readings?"
"I would love to," Bex said. "But I'm not touching anything."
"You can touch the instruments—"
"No." Bex shook her head firmly. "Ms. Venn said don't touch anything. I'm not touching anything. Not even instruments. Especially not instruments."
She walked away, stepping very carefully over a crack in the ground. Which was good, because the crack was new and probably had lava in it. But she didn't know that, so she just avoided it because it looked like a thing that should not be touched.
Otto was examining a rock formation with his scanner. "Interesting," he said. "The surface is constantly changing. There are new deposits everywhere. If we came back tomorrow, this whole area would look completely different."
Bex stopped walking. She stared at Otto's scanner. It beeped happily in his hand.
"Can I hold the scanner?" she asked.
"You're not supposed to touch things," Otto reminded her.
"I know. But a scanner isn't a thing. It's a tool."
"A scanner is definitely a thing," Otto said.
Bex sighed. "You're right. I'm not touching anything."
The Not-Touching
Five minutes later, Bex had not touched anything.
She had walked around a lot. She had looked at things. She had even crouched down to look at a fascinating deposit of frozen sulfur dioxide that looked exactly like a snowflake made of yellow crystals.
But she hadn't touched it.
"Bex," Kwame said, appearing silently beside her. "You're doing good."
"I'm dying," Bex said. "Everything here is so touchable. Look at that rock. It's the perfect shape for touching. And that one—smooth. That one—rough. That one—I don't even know what it feels like, and I'll never know, because I'm not touching anything."
Kwame looked at her for a long moment.
"It will still be here," he said. "The rock. It'll still be Io next week. But you get to be the one who didn't touch it."
Bex stared at him. "That's... actually helpful."
Kwame nodded. Then he walked away.
Bex looked at the rock. The rock looked at Bex (metaphorically; it was a rock).
"I'm not going to touch you," Bex told it. "Because I want to be the one who didn't touch it."
The rock bubbled.
The Lesson
The Hopper's warning light blinked. Ms. Venn's voice came over the com: "Two minutes, everyone! Back to the ship!"
Bex turned to head back—and that's when she saw it.
A small piece of volcanic glass, perfectly smooth, glinting in the orange light of Io's surface. It was the most beautiful thing she had ever seen. And it was sitting right there. Right at her feet. Just begging to be touched.
Bex stopped.
Her hand twitched.
The glass glittered.
"Don't touch it," she whispered to herself. "Don't touch it. You're the one who doesn't touch things."
Behind her, the ground rumbled. A new crack opened up where she had been standing moments before. It snaked across the ground toward the sheet of glass—and the glass vanished into the crack, swallowed by the volcano's restless surface.
Bex blinked.
"That would have been bad to touch," she said quietly.
She ran back to the Hopper.
Inside the ship, everyone peeled off their suits. Ms. Venn marked something in her checklist.
"How did we do?" she asked.
Zara held up her journal, full of notes and sketches. Otto raised his scanner. Kwame pointed to the window, where Io was already shrinking behind them.
Bex raised her hand.
"Yes, Bex?" Ms. Venn asked.
"I didn't touch anything," Bex said. "The whole time. I didn't touch the rocks. I didn't touch the lava. I didn't touch the sulfur deposits. I didn't even touch the instruments, which maybe wasn't necessary, but I didn't."
Ms. Venn looked at her. A small smile crept across her face.
"That's very impressive, Bex," she said. "That was probably the hardest task we've had all year."
"I know," Bex said. "But I did it. I'm the one who didn't touch the thing."
She looked at her hands. They were very clean. No sulfur. No dust. No volcanic glass.
"I'm going to write about this in my journal," she said. "Today I proved that I can do the impossible."
Zara glanced over. "What will you call the entry?"
Bex grinned. "'The Day I Didn't Touch a Single Thing on Io, Which Was Harder Than Touching All the Things.'"
"That's a long title," Otto said.
"Worth it," said Bex.
The Hopper hummed happily and jumped to warp speed. Behind them, Io erupted again, sending another plume of sulfur into space, as if to say goodbye to the class that had visited—and had not touched a single thing.
The End