The Cook Together Kitchen
The Recipe Box
The Box on the Shelf
It was a rainy Saturday afternoon. Lily sat on Nana's kitchen floor with her chin in her hands, watching raindrops race down the window.
"I'm bored," Lily said.
"Bored?" Nana looked up from her tea. "Well, I know a cure for that."
She climbed onto a chair and reached for the highest shelf in her kitchen. Down came a wooden box with a faded flower painted on the lid. The brass latch made a little click when Nana opened it.
"This," Nana said, setting it on the table, "is my recipe box."
Lily's eyes went wide. Inside were cards and cards — some typed, some written in loopy handwriting, some stained with things that looked like butter and chocolate.
"How old are these?" Lily asked.
Nana picked up a card with yellow edges. "This one is older than your mother. And this one"—she held up a card with handwriting so curly Lily could barely read it—"belonged to my mother."
Lily reached for the box carefully, like it was treasure. "Can I look at all of them?"
"You can do better than that," Nana said. "You can copy them."
Nana's Oldest Recipe
Nana shuffled through the cards until she found one at the very back. The paper was soft and worn. "This is the oldest one I have," she said. "My mother's sugar cookies. She made them for me when I was little, just like you."
"Can we make them?" Lily asked.
"Of course we can," Nana said. "But first, we need to read the card carefully."
Nana read out loud: "Cream together one cup of softened butter and one cup of sugar."
Lily got the step stool and found the butter in the fridge. It was already soft. Nana handed her a big bowl and a wooden spoon.
"Heads up," Lily said, plopping the butter in with a thump. Then she measured one cup of sugar and poured it in. She stirred and stirred until it was smooth and fluffy.
"Now," Nana read, "add one egg and one teaspoon of vanilla."
Lily cracked the egg — only a tiny piece of shell fell in, and she fished it out with her fingers. She measured the vanilla carefully. "It smells like birthday cake," she said.
"Next: two cups of flour, one teaspoon of baking powder, and half a teaspoon of salt."
Lily measured the flour and Nana sifted it into the bowl with the baking powder and salt. Lily stirred, but the dough got stiff and stubborn.
"My arm is tired," Lily said.
"Then we're doing it right," Nana laughed. "One more thing — a quarter cup of milk."
Lily poured it in, and the dough loosened up. But when she looked at it, she frowned. "Nana, it's too sticky."
"Ah," Nana said, peering at the bowl. "The card says to chill it first. I got ahead of myself. We need to put it in the refrigerator for thirty minutes."
Lily giggled. "Even Nana makes mistakes?"
"Even Nana," Nana said. "That's why we read the whole card first."
While We Wait
While the dough chilled, Nana spread all the cards across the table. Lily looked at each one — apple pie, chicken soup, pierogi, gingerbread.
"Who made this one first?" Lily asked, pointing to a card with blue ink.
"That was your great-aunt Rose," Nana said. "She made it for my wedding."
"And this one?"
"That one came from a neighbor in the town where I grew up. She gave it to me when I got married."
Lily pulled out her own notebook — the one she used for drawings and notes. "I'm going to write down the best ones," she said. "So I remember."
She copied Nana's mother's sugar cookie card first, writing carefully in her best letters. Then she drew a picture at the bottom: a circle with a bite taken out of it, and a little smiley face on the cookie.
"That looks like a happy cookie," Nana said.
"It's going to be a happy cookie," Lily said. "Because we're making it together."
Nana looked at the clock. "Time to roll!"
Rolling and Cutting
Nana sprinkled flour on the counter. Lily dusted her hands and patted the dough into a ball.
"Flour your rolling pin too," Nana said, handing her the wooden pin.
Lily rolled the dough out flat — well, mostly flat. The edges were bumpy and one side was thicker than the other.
"That's perfect," Nana said. "Now we cut them."
She handed Lily a cookie cutter shaped like a star. Lily pressed it into the dough and lifted. A perfect little star came up with it.
"I did it!" Lily said.
"Now you have to press them onto the baking sheet. We didn't grease it, but the cookies have enough butter that they won't stick."
Lily transferred the stars one by one. When the sheet was full, she collected the scraps of dough, rolled them out again, and cut more cookies until the dough was gone.
"Look at all of them!" Lily said.
"Into the oven at 350 degrees," Nana said. "For eight to ten minutes. We'll check them at eight."
Cookies and Cards
They stood at the oven window and watched the cookies turn golden at the edges.
"Eight minutes!" Lily announced.
"Let me do the hot part," Nana said. She pulled out the baking sheet. The cookies looked exactly right — not too dark, not too pale.
"They need to cool on the pan for a few minutes," Nana said. "That's the hardest part."
Lily waited. She tapped the counter with her fingers. She counted to sixty twice.
"Now?" she asked.
"Now," Nana said.
Lily bit into a still-warm cookie. Her eyes went big. "This is the best cookie I've ever had."
"That's because it's from your great-grandmother's recipe," Nana said. "She would have loved to see you making it."
Lily looked at her notebook. She had copied the recipe and drawn a picture. But now she added one more thing at the bottom, in her very best handwriting:
"Made with Nana."
Then she drew a little heart next to it.
"Can we make the apple pie card next time?" she asked.
"We can make every single card," Nana said. "We have all the time in the world."
--- RECIPE CARD ---
Nana's Oldest Recipe (Her Mother's Sugar Cookies)
Makes: About 24 cookies
Time: 1 hour (including chill time)
What You Need:
• 1 cup softened butter
• 1 cup sugar
• 1 egg
• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
• 2 cups all-purpose flour
• 1 teaspoon baking powder
• ½ teaspoon salt
• ¼ cup milk
How to Make It:
-
In a big bowl, mix the softened butter and sugar until smooth.
-
Add the egg and vanilla. Stir well.
-
In another bowl, mix the flour, baking powder, and salt.
-
Add the dry ingredients to the butter mixture. Stir.
-
Add the milk and stir until the dough comes together. It will be sticky!
-
Put the dough in the refrigerator for 30 minutes.
-
Sprinkle flour on the counter and a rolling pin.
-
Roll the dough out flat, about ¼ inch thick.
-
Cut cookies with a cookie cutter (stars are great!).
-
Place cookies on an ungreased baking sheet.
-
Bake at 350°F for 8–10 minutes, until the edges are golden.
-
Let them cool on the pan for 5 minutes. Then enjoy!
Lily's Tips: "Read the card ALL the way first — then you won't forget the cold part! And the burnt-looking cookies aren't burnt, they're just extra crunchy. Eat those first."
--- END RECIPE CARD ---