← Library

The Feelings Engineers

The Brave-But-Scared Feeling

The Meeting Begins

The Feelings Engineers met at Ben's house on a Tuesday. Ben's mom had made popcorn, but nobody was eating it. Ben was standing in the middle of the living room, holding a piece of paper with a drawing on it.

"I have a feeling," Ben said. "And I don't know what it is."

Zoe pulled out her notebook. "Describe it."

Ben looked at the paper in his hands. "Tomorrow I'm supposed to read my poem in front of the whole school. I practiced it a hundred times. I know it. But when I think about standing up there, my stomach goes cold and hot at the same time."

"Are you scared?" Rosa asked.

"Yes," Ben said. "But I'm also not scared. I'm going to do it. I already decided. I'm not going to back out. I want to do it. I'm scared and I want to do it at the same time."

Sam raised an eyebrow. "So you're brave?"

"Yes," Ben said. "But I'm also scared."

"That's impossible," Sam said.

"It's not!" Ben held up his paper. "Look!"

Ben's Diagram

Ben's drawing showed a stick figure on a stage. There was a big crowd in front of them. Two arrows pointed toward the stick figure from opposite directions.

One arrow was labeled "SCARED." It was wavy and jagged, like a lightning bolt. It pointed from the crowd toward the figure, like the fear was coming at him.

The other arrow was labeled "BRAVE." It was straight and solid, like an arrow on a sign. It pointed from the figure toward the crowd, like courage pushing outward.

Both arrows met at the exact same point — right at Ben's chest.

"The arrows are going in opposite directions," Zoe said. "But they arrive at the same place."

"Exactly," Ben said. "The scared is coming in. The brave is going out. At the same time. Both of them. Right here." He tapped his chest. "They're not happening one after the other. They're happening together."

Rosa leaned in to look. "So you're not scared-then-brave."

"No."

"And you're not brave-then-scared."

"No!"

"You're scared and brave at exactly the same moment."

"Yes!" Ben sat down. "And I need to know what that is called because no one will let me say it's both. They all say: 'You're so brave!' or 'Don't be scared!' But I'm both. Why won't anyone let me be both?"

What It Looks Like in the Body

Zoe opened the club notebook. "Okay. Let's investigate. Where does it live?"

Ben closed his eyes. "It lives in my chest. Like there's a drum and also a blanket. The drum is scared. The blanket is brave. The blanket is over the drum, but the drum is still beating."

"Does the blanket make the drum go away?" Rosa asked.

"No," Ben said. "The drum keeps beating. But the blanket makes me stay anyway. The drum says 'run' and the blanket says 'stay' and they're both talking at once."

Sam nodded slowly. "So the scared doesn't go away?"

"No," Ben said. "And if I have to wait for the scared to go away, I'd never do anything. That's the thing. That's why I came here. Everyone keeps saying 'you'll feel better' or 'don't worry' and I just keep thinking: what if I always feel scared? What if I'm scared forever? Am I supposed to just wait?"

The room got quiet.

Zoe drew the diagram in the notebook: two arrows, opposite directions, meeting in the middle. She labeled the middle point: "BOTH AT ONCE."

"That's what you are," she said. "Both at once. And that's real."

Rosa's Discovery

Rosa was quiet for a long time. Then she said, "I know that feeling."

"From doing something scary?" Sam asked.

"No," Rosa said. "I mean, yes. But also—" She looked at her hands. "My little sister. She's three. When she has to get a shot at the doctor, she screams and cries. And every time, my mom says, 'Be brave, you're so brave.'"

"That doesn't help," Ben said.

"No," Rosa said. "Because my sister looks at me when they're done, and she's crying, and she says, 'Rosa, I was so scared.' And I say, 'I know.' And she says, 'Was I brave?' And I don't know what to say because she was scared the whole time."

Zoe tapped her pencil. "Was she brave?"

Rosa thought about it. "She got the shot. That's what she had to do. She did it while she was scared. So... yes? She was brave AND scared. Not brave after scared. Not scared after brave. Both."

Ben pointed at Rosa. "Yes! That! That's what I'm saying!"

Rosa looked at her hands. "But I never said 'you're so brave' to her. Because she was crying. And it felt wrong to say she was brave when she was also scared. Like those things couldn't both be true."

"Now I know the word," Ben said.

"What word?" Sam asked.

"The word for when you do something while scared," Ben said. "It's both. It's the brave-but-scared feeling."

What Do You Actually Do With It?

Sam asked the question. Of course Sam asked the question. "Okay. But what do you actually do with it?"

Ben thought hard. "I think... I think you let both of them be there."

"That's not an action," Sam said.

"It is!" Ben said. "That's the action. It's the thing that's hardest. I know how to run. I know how to hide. I know how to pretend not to be scared. But standing there with the drum beating and the blanket on top and doing the thing anyway—that's the action."

Rosa wrote in the notebook: "The action is doing it while scared."

"That means being scared isn't failing," Zoe said slowly. "Being scared isn't the opposite of brave. Being scared and staying is brave."

Ben nodded. "When I read my poem tomorrow, I'm going to be scared the whole time. I bet I will. My hands will shake. My voice might wobble. And I'll still be reading the poem. And that's brave. That's the brave-but-scared feeling."

"What does the blanket do?" Sam asked.

"The blanket doesn't stop the drum," Ben said. "The blanket keeps you in the room with the drum. That's all a blanket can do. It can't make the drum quiet. It can just keep you there while it beats."

Zoe drew a small blanket in the diagram, over the drum, with the arrows still going in and out and meeting in the middle.

She labeled it: "This is enough."

The Next Day

The book isn't over yet. Because the next day, Ben read his poem.

His hands shook. His voice wobbled.

He told us about it at the next meeting.

"Were you scared?" Rosa asked.

"The whole time," Ben said.

"Were you brave?"

"I did it," Ben said. "I was scared and I did it. Both at once."

In the notebook, Zoe drew the final diagram: two arrows, opposite directions, arriving at the same place. A drum and a blanket. And written underneath, in Ben's messy handwriting:

Being scared doesn't make you not brave.

Being brave doesn't make you not scared.

Both at once is real and it's allowed.

Sam read it. "That's the feeling."

"Yep," Ben said.

"What do you do with it?"

"You stand there," Ben said. "And you do the thing."

The meeting was over. The notebook was one page fuller.

Out in the hallway, Ben's mom asked him if the reading went well.

"I was scared," Ben said.

"Oh, honey—"

"AND," Ben said, "I was brave. Both at once."

His mom looked at him for a long moment. Then she nodded and said, "That's right. That's exactly right."