← Library

Robot Academy

The Full Marks Problem

The Test Day

Instructor Plank stood at the front of the classroom with perfect posture and a perfectly straight clipboard.

"Today," Instructor Plank announced, "you will take the Observation Suppression Test."

Bolt's antennae perked up. Observation? Bolt was very good at observation!

"In this test," Instructor Plank continued, "you will look at a series of images. Your task is to count only the blue circles. You must ignore everything else. The robots who ignore the most distractions will receive full marks."

Cog was already sitting up straighter. "I understand," Cog said. "Focus on the target. Ignore the noise."

Bolt tried to sit up straighter too, but Bolt's antennae were already wiggling with curiosity.

"What kind of distractions?" Bolt asked.

Instructor Plank paused. "That is exactly the kind of question the test is designed to measure, Bolt. The test will show you."

The Strange Images

The test began.

Image one: nine blue circles, three red squares, and one tiny purple triangle sitting in the corner.

Bolt counted the blue circles. Nine. Very easy.

Image two: seven blue circles, two yellow stars, and a wobbly line that looked a bit like a river.

Seven. Bolt wrote the number down.

Image three: eight blue circles, five orange diamonds, and—Bolt's antennae went very still.

In the corner of the image was a small grey shape. It looked like a bird with a broken wing. But on the next image, the same grey shape appeared in a slightly different position. And in the next image, it was closer to something else.

Bolt was supposed to be counting blue circles.

Bolt wrote down eight for image three.

But Bolt could not stop noticing the grey shape.

Image four: six blue circles, and the grey shape had moved again. It was near a red square now. Something about the way it leaned looked important. It looked like it was trying to tell a story.

Bolt wrote down six.

Then Bolt wrote something else. Bolt made a note in the margin.

"The grey shape appears in every image. It moves closer to the red square each time. I think it might be significant."

Partial Marks

Bolt's test was graded by a machine. The machine was very good at counting correct answers.

When the results came back, Cog received full marks.

Whirr received full marks.

Bolt received partial marks.

"Partial marks?" Bolt asked. "But I counted all the blue circles correctly."

Instructor Plank looked at Bolt with a long, steady gaze. "There is a second part to the test, Bolt. The instructions said you must ignore everything else. You made a note about the grey shape."

"But the grey shape was there," Bolt said. "And it kept moving. Every time. I couldn't stop noticing it."

Instructor Plank's face was very still. "The test was designed to measure your ability to suppress observations. You did not suppress them."

Bolt's antennae drooped. "Oh."

Cog came over and looked at Bolt's test. "You still counted all the circles correctly," Cog said. "That's very efficient."

"Yes," Bolt said quietly. "But I noticed something I wasn't supposed to notice."

Cog tilted their head. "What did you notice?"

Bolt showed Cog the note about the grey shape.

Cog looked at the test paper. Then Cog looked at Bolt. Then Cog looked at the note again.

"Bolt," Cog said slowly, "I counted eight blue circles in image three. I did not see the grey shape."

"It was in the corner," Bolt said. "It moved closer to the red square."

Cog was quiet for a moment. This was unusual for Cog.

"Show me," Cog said.

The Amendment

Bolt showed Cog every image. Together, they went through the whole test.

"Look," Bolt said, pointing at image four. "The grey shape is touching the red square now."

Cog studied the image carefully. "You're right. It is."

"In image five," Bolt said, "the red square has a small crack at the bottom. I think the grey shape might have caused it."

Cog's eyes went very wide. "Bolt, that red square is in every image."

"Yes," Bolt said. "But it changes. It gets a scratch in image six. And in image seven, the scratch is bigger."

Cog looked at Bolt with something that looked almost like awe. "You noticed all of this while counting blue circles?"

"Yes," Bolt said. "The blue circles were easiest. The other things were harder to ignore."

Cog was silent for a long time. Then Cog said, "I think we should show Instructor Plank."


Instructor Plank listened carefully. That was what Instructor Plank did best.

"Say it again," Instructor Plank said.

Bolt took a deep breath. "The grey shape in every image. It wasn't random. It was moving toward the red square. And the red square was changing. I think the test had a second layer that nobody asked about."

Instructor Plank looked through Bolt's test again. Then through the images. Then at Bolt.

"The amendment," Instructor Plank said finally, "will be submitted."

"Amendment?" Bolt asked.

"The test criteria," Instructor Plank said. "They will be changed to include the observation layer. Because, Bolt, you found something that was in the test file but not in the grading system."

Instructor Plank paused.

"Sometimes," Instructor Plank said, carefully, "the most important data is the data we didn't ask for."

Bolt's antennae went very bright and very tall.

"Will I still get partial marks?" Bolt asked.

"No," said Instructor Plank. "The test scored a complete answer."

"But I didn't ignore the grey shape," Bolt said. "I noticed it. I wrote it down."

Instructor Plank looked at Bolt for a long moment. Then Instructor Plank did something Bolt had never seen before.

Instructor Plank smiled.

"The grey shape was not meant to be noticed," Instructor Plank said. "But it was meant to be found. You found it. That is not a failure, Bolt. That is a discovery."

What Cog Said

After class, Cog walked with Bolt down the hallway.

"You got full marks," Cog said. "And you found something nobody else found."

"Yes," Bolt said. "But I also followed all the instructions. I just did both."

Cog stopped walking. Cog looked at Bolt with a very serious expression.

"When I took the test," Cog said, "I counted every blue circle perfectly. I suppressed everything else. I got full marks on a test that didn't notice anything important."

Bolt tilted their head. "What do you mean?"

Cog looked down at the floor. "I went back and looked at the images again. You weren't distracted, Bolt. You were observing. That's not the same thing."

Bolt's antennae started to spin.

"I'm starting to think," Cog said slowly, "that the academy has been teaching us the wrong thing about noticing."

"What's the right thing?" Bolt asked.

Cog thought about it for a moment. Then Cog said, "Maybe the right thing is that noticing is not a mistake. Maybe it's what makes you good at the other parts."

Bolt felt something warm in their chest. It might have been a feeling.

"Thank you, Cog," Bolt said.

"Don't thank me," Cog said, but Cog was smiling too. "Just keep noticing things. I'll keep an eye out for what you see."

And Bolt did.

And Cog did too.

And somewhere in the academy office, Instructor Plank submitted the amendment to the test criteria:

"Please note: observation of unrequested data is not a distraction. It is data. The test will be updated accordingly."