← Library

The Feelings Engineers

The Performing-Fine Feeling

The Meeting Begins

The Feelings Engineers met at Rosa's house on a Tuesday. The snack was pretzels and apple slices, which Rosa's mom had arranged in a circle on a plate.

"Today's feeling," Zoe announced, "was suggested by Rosa."

Rosa was looking at the plate. "I don't remember suggesting one."

"You said, and I quote, 'There's a thing some people do where they say they're fine and they're not, and I hate it.'"

Ben nodded slowly. "Oh. That feeling."

Rosa kept looking at the pretzels. "It's not like I do it. I just notice other people doing it. It's everywhere. My dad does it. He says 'I'm fine' and then he goes in his room and stares at the wall."

"Where does it live in the body?" Zoe asked, pulling out the notebook.

"Somewhere near the throat," Rosa said. "Right where the 'I'm fine' comes out."


The Diagram

Zoe drew on the big paper. She drew a face with a smooth, blank expression. Then she drew a dashed line through the middle.

"Inside it," she said, "under the face, I'm drawing everything that's actually happening on the inside."

She filled the inside with scribbles. Different colors, going different directions. Arrows pointing nowhere.

"The outside," she said, labeling it, "is performing fine."

"The inside," she said, labeling it, "is not fine."

Ben leaned in. "That's the feeling. The gap between those two."

Rosa frowned. "When someone does it, you can see the gap. They're smiling but they're not smiling. They're saying 'fine' but it sounds... flat."

"Their voice is too even," Sam said. "Like it's been ironed."

Ben nodded. "When I do it..." He paused. "Wait. I do it."

"Everyone does it," Zoe said.

"No," Rosa said quietly. "I mean yes, everyone, but also..." She stopped. "I do it too."

The room got very quiet.


The Pause

The meeting paused.

Rosa was looking at her hands. "I didn't know I was doing it when I suggested this feeling. I thought I was just noticing it in other people." She took a breath. "But last week, when we had that big assembly and I was supposed to be happy because we got the award, I wasn't feeling anything, and I smiled anyway. I smiled so much my face hurt. And everyone said I looked so happy. And I said 'I'm fine' when someone asked."

She looked up. "I didn't know I was fine-ing."

"That's the thing about it," Ben said. "You don't know while you're doing it. You only notice later."

"Or when someone points it out," Sam said.

"I'm pointing it out," Rosa said. "To myself."

Zoe wrote in the notebook: The getting-caught-doing-it moment.

"I hate this feeling," Rosa said.

"We're not here to hate it," Zoe said. "We're here to understand it."

Sam asked the question. "What do you actually do with it?"


What You Do With It

"I have an idea," Ben said. "It's not a diagram, but it's what I think."

They waited.

"When I do it," Ben said, "it's like I'm doing a job. I'm being fine for someone else. To make them not worry. Or to get through the thing so I can be not-fine in private."

"Like a mask," Rosa said.

"Not a mask," Ben said. "A bridge. The outside is the part people can stand on. The inside is what I'm actually standing on. Sometimes I need the outside to be smooth even when the inside isn't."

"That's not the same as lying," Zoe said slowly. "It's... performing."

"It's knowing you can't be Not-Fine in the middle of the assembly," Ben said. "So you're Fine on the outside, and that's a real thing you're doing. It's a job."

Rosa looked at him. "But the job is exhausting."

"Yes," Ben said. "It's the exhausting-est job."

Zoe added to the diagram. She drew a hand on the outside face, holding a smile in place. And she drew a small flag on the inside that said: You can drop this later. I'm here.

"Is that true?" Rosa asked. "Can you drop it later?"

"I think that's what the club is for," Ben said. "This is the place where you can say 'I am not actually fine' and nobody fixes it. Nobody says 'what's wrong.' Nobody hands you a snack and says 'you'll feel better.'"

Rosa's mom walked in with more pretzels. "Everyone okay in here?"

"Rosa's not fine," Ben said.

"Okay," Rosa's mom said, and closed the door.

"The job is done," Rosa said. "I don't have to perform anymore." She looked at her friends, and her face got scrunchy, and it wasn't performing at all. It was the opposite of performing.

"That's the thing," she finally said. "That's what you do with it. You find the people you don't have to perform for." She sniffed. "You use it when you need it. And then you come here and you put it down."


The Feeling Named

Zoe wrote in the notebook:

The Performing-Fine Feeling:

  • Where it lives: in the throat, and in the smile muscles, and in the gap between what you show and what's real.

  • What causes it: needing to be okay for other people, or for a moment, before you can be not-okay alone.

  • What helps: knowing you're working a job. Knowing the job is temporary. Knowing there are people who will let you be not-fine.

  • What you do with it: you perform fine when you need to. And then you find someone safe and you STOP being fine, and that's the whole point.

Sam drew a tiny picture in the corner. It was a person holding a large "FINE" sign. On the other side of the page, the same person was lying on grass.

"What's that?" Ben asked.

"That's the after," Sam said. "After you put it down."

Rosa looked at the picture. "I want to do that now."

She lay down on the rug and looked at the ceiling.

"Okay," Ben said. And lay down next to her.

Zoe and Sam looked at each other, then lay down too.

They all looked at the ceiling.

"I'm not fine," Rosa said.

"We know," said Ben.

"I don't know why, exactly," she said. "It doesn't matter, though."

"Doesn't matter," Sam agreed.

Zoe thought about the diagram. She thought about the gap between the outside and the inside. She wondered if the gap could ever be completely closed. She decided it couldn't be, not for anyone. And that was okay. The gap was just a thing you noticed, named, and carried.

Rosa sighed a long sigh. It was the kind of sigh that got quieter at the end.

"I'm glad you're not fine," Ben said. "In a good way."

"I know what you mean," said Rosa.

The meeting ended. Zoe wrote one more line in the notebook, very small, at the bottom:

You can't diagram your way out. But a friend on either side helps.


The End