The Feelings Engineers
The Relief That Isnt Relief Feeling
The Meeting
The Feelings Engineers met at Rosa's house on a Tuesday. The test was over. The science fair was done. The class play had ended last Friday, and Zoe had been the narrator.
"Congratulations," said Rosa, when Zoe walked in.
"Thanks," said Zoe. She sat down. She didn't say anything else.
"Are you happy it's over?" asked Ben.
"Yes," said Zoe. Then she paused. "I think."
"You think?" said Sam. "The test is over. The play is over. Shouldn't you be bouncing off the walls?"
Zoe looked down at her hands. "I thought I would feel relieved. But I don't feel relieved. I feel... nothing."
"Nothing?" asked Rosa.
"Not nothing," said Zoe. "It's more like..." She paused. "You know when you're holding something heavy for a long time, and then someone takes it from you? And for a moment you feel lighter. But then you realize your arms still feel like they're holding it? And also your arms feel weird because they have nothing to hold?"
Rosa nodded slowly. "Like your body hasn't caught up yet."
"YES," said Zoe. "That's it. The hard thing is over. I should feel relieved. But I just feel... empty."
Ben stood up. "I know that feeling." He grabbed the whiteboard from the corner. "I had it after my piano recital last year. I practiced for months. Months. And then it was over. And everyone said 'you must be so relieved!' and I said 'yes!' but actually I just sat in the car and stared out the window and felt like someone had sucked all the colors out of the world."
"Did you like the recital?" asked Rosa.
"Yes!" said Ben. "I loved it! That's the weird part! It went well! I did great! And I felt terrible!"
"Not terrible," said Zoe. "Not sad. Not bad. Just..."
"Empty," said Ben. "Flat. Like the feeling got used up."
Sam leaned forward. "So this is the 'relief that isn't relief' feeling."
"YES," said Zoe and Ben together.
Rosa wrote it down in the club notebook. "What do we call this?" she asked.
Zoe thought. "The Relief That Isn't Relief Feeling."
"That's a terrible name," said Sam.
"It's an accurate name," said Zoe.
"Accurate is better than pretty," said Ben. "Let's diagram it."
The Diagram
Zoe drew the diagram. She drew it carefully, the way she always did.
First, she drew a shape like a mountain. A big, spiky mountain, all sharp edges and dark coloring. She labeled it: THE HARD THING.
Then, she drew an arrow from the mountain pointing down to a flat, straight line. She labeled it: AFTER THE HARD THING IS OVER.
Underneath the flat line, she drew a big empty circle. It wasn't a happy circle or a sad circle. It was just... a circle. She labeled it: WHERE THE RELIEF WAS SUPPOSED TO BE.
"See?" she said, pointing at the empty circle. "This is where the relief should go. But it's empty. Because the hard thing took all our energy. And now we're just..."
"Empty," said Ben. He added a wavy line inside the circle. "Because it doesn't stay empty. It feels wobbly. Like I might feel sad, or relieved, or angry, or hungry, all at once."
"Do you feel hungry?" asked Sam.
Ben laughed. "Maybe. But that's not the point."
"The point is," said Zoe, "when a hard thing is over, everyone expects you to feel good. But sometimes you feel nothing. And then you feel bad about feeling nothing. And then you feel bad about feeling bad about feeling nothing."
"Feeling bad about feeling bad," said Rosa. "That's a whole other feeling."
"More feelings," said Sam. "Great."
Rosa looked at the diagram. "I've seen this in other people," she said slowly. "After big hard things. My friend Martina, after her audition. She got the part. She wanted the part. And she cried in the bathroom for twenty minutes. She said she didn't know why she was crying."
"Did anyone say anything helpful?" asked Zoe.
Rosa thought. "No. Everyone said 'you must be so happy!' And that made her feel wrong. Like she was feeling it wrong."
"We're not feeling it wrong," said Ben. "We're just feeling it differently."
Sam raised his hand. "Okay. I have the question I always have. What do you actually DO with it?"
What Actually Helps
The four of them sat in silence for a moment.
"I tried to make myself feel relieved," said Zoe. "I stood in my room and I was like, 'Be happy! The play is over! No more rehearsals!' And I just felt... nothing."
"Maybe nothing is what you need to feel," said Rosa.
"What does that mean?" asked Sam.
Rosa looked at the diagram. "When you've been holding something heavy, and someone takes it away, you don't just start dancing. You have to lower your arms first. You have to shake them out. You have to wait for your muscles to remember they're not holding anything."
"So the feeling of nothing is actually something?" said Zoe.
"I think so," said Rosa. "I think the empty feeling is your body and brain going 'okay, we don't have to be alerted anymore. We don't have to be ready. We can relax now.' And relaxing takes time."
"That doesn't fix the feeling," said Sam. "That just explains it."
"Maybe explaining it IS helpful," said Zoe. "Because if I know the empty feeling is my brain catching up, then I don't have to panic about not feeling relieved. I can just... wait."
"Waiting is hard," said Ben.
"Yep," said Sam.
They all nodded.
Then Sam said, "So what actually helps?"
"Talking about it," said Rosa. "Saying 'I feel weird because I don't feel relieved' instead of pretending I feel relieved."
"Resting," said Ben. "Not doing anything. Not trying to fix it. Just letting your arms hang for a while."
"Being with people who won't say 'you must be so relieved,'" said Zoe. "People who will say 'you seem weird' and let you be weird."
"A snack?" asked Sam.
Everyone laughed.
"Actually, yes," said Zoe. "A snack."
The Finding
Zoe went to the whiteboard and added a few final labels to the diagram.
THE EMPTY CIRCLE: Where relief was supposed to be. Not actually empty. It's full of "getting ready to feel again."
THE TRICK: Thinking you're doing the feeling wrong. You're not.
WHAT HELPS: Saying how you actually feel. Resting. Waiting. Snacks.
WHAT DOESN'T HELP: People saying "you must be so relieved!" and you saying "yes!" when you mean "no."
"The finding is," said Zoe, "that this feeling is very normal."
"Ugh," said Sam. "That's what everyone says. 'It's normal!' And then they go away and you still feel weird."
"That's true," said Rosa. "Just knowing it's normal doesn't make it GO AWAY."
"Right," said Zoe. "So the finding is different. The finding is: this feeling is normal AND it's not helpful to just be told it's normal. What's helpful is knowing it has a name. Knowing it makes sense. And knowing it will pass without you having to force it."
"You can't force it," said Ben. "You can't force relief any more than you can force sleep."
"I like that," said Rosa.
Sam looked at the diagram. "So what do we write in the notebook?"
Zoe picked up the marker and wrote four words at the bottom:
THIS IS THE AFTER. NOT THE END.
"What does that mean?" asked Ben.
"It means the feeling isn't over," said Zoe. "The hard thing is over, but the feeling of the hard thing is still happening. It's the after. It has its own shape. It's not the end of feeling. It's just a different part."
Ben smiled. "I like that. It gives the empty circle something to be."
Rosa got up and went to the kitchen. She came back with crackers and cheese and apple slices.
They ate. Nobody said "you must be so relieved." Nobody said "it's normal."
They just sat there, in the after, together.
And eventually, Zoe realized that the empty circle in her chest had started to fill. Not with relief, exactly. Not with happiness.
Just with crackers and cheese and friends.
And that was enough.