Shell by Shell
The Abalone Problem
The tide pool was quiet that morning.
Scout emerged from his shell, the good one, the striped one, the one that had fit just right for almost a whole week, and stretched his legs. The sun was warm. The water was clear. Everything felt possible.
Then Scout saw it.
It was wedged between two rocks like a tiny moon that had fallen from the sky. It was enormous. It was beautiful. It was pink and silver and shimmered in the light like a thousand tiny rainbows all arguing over the same piece of ocean.
It was an abalone shell. The bottom of one, anyway. And it was completely flat.
“Pip,” Scout whispered. “Pip, wake up. Wake up, wake up, wake up.”
Pip’s tiny ghost-shrimp face appeared from inside Scout’s shell. His eyes were still half-closed. “What’s happening... oh no. OH NO. Is something chasing us? Is it a tuna? Is it three tunas?”
“No,” Scout said. “It’s better than tuna. It’s the most beautiful shell I’ve ever seen.”
Pip squinted. “That’s not a shell. That’s a plate.”
“It’s an abalone fragment,” Scout said. He had heard Mabel mention it once. “It’s big. It’s gorgeous. It’s mine.”
“It’s flat,” Pip said.
But Scout was already walking toward it, his claws clicking with excitement. He circled the giant shell fragment. Sunlight bounced off its pearly surface. It was bigger than any shell Scout had ever worn. Bigger than his old striped shell. Bigger than the cone shell he had once tried to borrow. Bigger than the moon shell with the crack in the back.
“This,” Scout announced, “is the future.”
Pip made a small worried sound.
“I’m going to live in it,” Scout said.
And he did. He climbed onto the flat surface, tucked his body in, and grabbed the edge with his back legs. Then he tried to pull his soft body against the shell.
He slid off.
“Okay,” Scout said. “Wrong angle.”
He tried again. He braced his legs, curled his tail, and squeezed. For one brief second, he thought he had it. Then he slid off the other side.
“Maybe you’re not supposed to live on it,” Pip said, now sitting on the sand, watching with his head tilted like a confused marble.
Scout ignored him. He flipped himself onto the abalone fragment and tried lying on his back, holding the shell over him like a roof.
He slid off.
He tried again.
He slid again.
Scout sat in the sand, breathing hard. The abalone fragment gleamed at him, beautiful and useless.
“It’s not working,” he admitted.
Pip nodded slowly. “It’s a plate, Scout.”
“But it’s so big,” Scout said. “And so pretty. And look how shiny. Maybe I just need the right technique.”
He tried one more time. He tucked his legs, leaned forward, and for a moment, a brilliant, impossible moment, he balanced perfectly on the flat shell, all his claws gripping the edge.
“Pip! PIP! LOOK AT, “
He slid off.
Behind them, someone laughed.
Coral was perched on a rock nearby, her spotted cone snail shell glossy and perfect. She had been watching for a while. Her eyes were bright. Her claws were folded.
“How long have you been there?” Scout asked.
“Long enough,” Coral said. “You know that’s not a shell, right?”
“Of course it’s a shell,” Scout said. “Mabel said, “
“It’s a fragment,” Coral said. “From a big shell. Big shells get broken sometimes. They turn into pretty plates. Not into homes.”
Scout looked at the abalone fragment again. It was still beautiful. It was still pink and silver and shimmering.
“But it’s so big,” he said quietly.
Coral nodded. She stepped down from her rock and walked over to him. She looked at the flat shell for a long, long moment.
“Big isn’t the same as right,” she said.
Scout felt his whole body sag. The hope drained out of him like water out of a broken cup.
“I’ve outgrown everything,” he said. “I grew out of the striped shell. I grew out of the moon shell. I grew out of the little pink one by the kelp. If a shell this big doesn’t work, what will?”
Coral was quiet. Then she said, “You’re asking the wrong question.”
Scout blinked. “What’s the right question?”
“The right question,” Coral said, “isn’t ‘what will fit?’ The right question is ‘what are you looking for?'”
Scout looked at her. Then he looked at the abalone fragment. Then he looked at Pip, who was dusting sand off his tiny ghost-shrimp self.
“I’m looking for a place where I fit,” Scout said.
“And how’s that working out?” Coral asked.
Scout opened his mouth. Closed it. Opened it again.
“Not great,” he admitted.
Coral nodded. She tapped the abalone fragment with one claw. “This isn’t a home. It’s a mirror.”
“A mirror?” Scout said.
“You see how big it is, and you think ‘big will fix it.’ But the shell was always just the outside part. You’re looking for the inside part.”
Scout had no idea what that meant. But Pip did.
“Oh,” Pip said softly. “Oh! That’s what I was trying to say. You don’t need a bigger shell. You need a shell that feels like… like coming home.”
The three of them sat on the sand next to the giant flat abalone fragment. The tide was coming in. The water lapped around their claws.
Scout looked at the big beautiful plate that wasn’t a shell. And for the first time, he didn’t feel sad about it. He felt silly.
“I slid off six times,” he said.
“Seven,” Pip said. “I counted.”
“I’m pretty sure it was five,” Coral said.
“There were witnesses,” Pip said. “The sea anemone saw everything. She’s not going to forget.”
Scout laughed. He couldn’t help it. He laughed until his whole body shook, and the tide pulled at his little crab legs, and Coral smiled, and Pip looked relieved.
“Okay,” Scout said. “Okay. Home isn’t flat plates or big shiny things. Home is… this.”
He looked at Coral. He looked at Pip. Pip was still dusting sand off his arms.
“Mostly this,” Scout said. “Pip, you’re getting sand in the shell.”
“Sorry,” Pip said. “That’s... that’s my face. That’s just my face.”
Scout laughed again. The abalone fragment sat in the sunlight, beautiful and flat and useless.
But Scout didn’t need it anymore.
“Come on,” he said. “There’s probably a real shell somewhere past the seagrass. And if we don’t find one, we’ll at least have an adventure.”
Pip sighed. “An adventure. Which means danger. Which means I’ll be asleep when it starts.”
“Probably,” Scout said. “It’ll be fine. Maybe. Let’s go.”
And they went.