Ghost Patrol
The Argument About Pluto
Biscuit was having a lovely morning. The sun was warm. The garden smelled interesting. And a bacon sandwich was happening somewhere nearby. Probably at Barnaby’s house.
But then Biscuit noticed the cold patch.
It was a very specific cold patch, right by the garden fence. It felt like a small winter had decided to move in next to the daisies.
“Hello!” said Biscuit, trotting over. “Are you a ghost? I’m Biscuit. I run the Unfinished Business Bureau. You can tell me everything.”
Two ghosts appeared.
One was a tall gentleman in an old-fashioned suit with a tiny moustache. He looked very cross. The other was a smaller ghost in a funny shirt with a picture of Saturn on it. He looked even crosser.
“Kindly inform this man,” said the first ghost, pointing, “that Pluto is a planet. It was discovered in 1930. I was there. I was the one who named it. Well, I was at a party. But still.”
“Kindly inform him,” said the second ghost, “that Pluto is NOT a planet. It was reclassified in 2006. I was at the conference. I voted. It’s a dwarf planet. That’s just science.”
“Science!” snorted the first ghost. “I died in 1999. I never voted. Pluto was a planet when I left. That counts for something.”
“It counts for nothing!” shouted the second ghost. “I died in 2010. I know the truth!”
Biscuit sat down and scratched behind his ear. “Ooh,” he said. “This is a big one. Right! Let’s do the thing. Which one of you is supposed to move on?”
“I can’t move on,” said the 1920s ghost, “until you agree that Pluto is a planet.”
“And I can’t move on,” said the 2010 ghost, “until you agree my calendar was right.”
Biscuit looked at the first ghost. Then he looked at the second ghost. Then he sighed a wonderfully doggy sigh. “I’m very good at finding lost socks,” he said. “But this might be harder.”
He tried to listen. He really did.
“—and it has moons!” said the first ghost.
“—and it has a weird orbit!” said the second ghost.
“—and it’s GOT A HEART SHAPE ON IT!” shouted the first ghost, stamping his foot.
Biscuit’s ears went up. “Wait,” he said. “It has a heart?”
“Yes,” said both ghosts, surprised.
“A big pale heart,” said the 2010 ghost, a little softer. “We only found that out later.”
Biscuit wagged his tail. “Well, that’s nice,” he said. “I like hearts. But the problem is—you’re both right, aren’t you?”
The ghosts stared at him.
“You’re right,” he said to the first ghost. “Pluto was a planet for almost seventy-six years. You grew up with it. You loved it. That can’t be wrong.”
Then he turned to the second ghost. “And you’re right too. Science learnt more. Sometimes we find out new things, and we have to change our minds. That can’t be wrong either.”
“But—but—” said the first ghost.
“It can’t be both,” said the second ghost.
“Why not?” said Biscuit. “I’m a dog who talks to ghosts. I know lots of things that are both at once.”
He sniffed the air. There was definitely a bacon sandwich cooling off somewhere. He resisted the urge to go and find it. This was important.
“You’re both stuck,” he said, “because you think the other one has to be wrong for you to be right. But Pluto doesn’t care. Pluto is just up there, being round and heart-shaped, not bothered at all.”
The ghosts were quiet.
“It’s still small,” said the 2010 ghost, weakly.
“It’s still lovely,” said the 1920s ghost. And then, very quietly, he added: “I did love it. It was my favourite. The little one at the edge.”
The 2010 ghost looked at him. “Mine too,” he said. “That’s why I get so cross. It feels like I’ve lost it.”
Biscuit wagged his tail harder. “Oh! That’s it! That’s the important bit! You both loved it. You both still love it. You just show it differently.”
The 1920s ghost looked at the 2010 ghost. The 2010 ghost looked at the 1920s ghost.
“I… suppose,” said the first ghost, “that you aren’t entirely a fool.”
“I suppose,” said the second ghost, “that you aren’t entirely wrong.”
“That’s the thing!” shouted Biscuit, bouncing in circles. “You did the thing! You said the words!”
And then the most wonderful thing happened. Both ghosts began to glow.
“I say,” said the 1920s ghost.
“Oh dear,” said the 2010 ghost.
“Goodbye!” barked Biscuit, so happy his tail was spinning. “Go and see Pluto! It’s still there! It’s still small! It’s still lovely!”
The first ghost made a small, happy sound, like a telescope lens clicking into place.
The second ghost made a soft, warm hum, like a spaceship powering down gently.
“Thank you, Biscuit,” they said together.
And then they faded out, both of them at once, like two stars shining away into the morning.
“Ah,” said Biscuit, sitting down. “That was a good one.”
Just then, Duchess strolled past the fence. She paused. Looked at the cold patch. Looked at Biscuit.
“Pluto,” she said, “is a dog. From the 1930s. You know that, right?”
Biscuit blinked. “What?”
Duchess flicked her tail and strolled off.
Biscuit stared at the empty air.
“Wait—there’s a dog called Pluto?”