← Library

Clancys Cove

What Splash Brought

Splash arrived backward, which was how she always arrived when she had big news. She floated on her back, kelp wrapped around her middle, a crab leg in one paw.

"CLANCY!" she called. "PEPPER! You have to hear what happened out there!"

Clancy emerged from under the overhang. Pepper shot out of a shell that was slightly too small, which she had recently decided was perfect.

"What? What is it?" Pepper scuttled in circles. "Is it a current change? A new predator? Did something wash in?"

"It's better than all that!" Splash spun in the water. "There's another tidepool. Two coves south. I saw it this morning."

Clancy said nothing. He settled onto a flat rock and watched.

"What kind of tidepool?" Pepper asked. "Bigger? Smaller?"

"Bigger," Splash said. "Much bigger. And deeper. And there's a whole field of mussels on one side. And the sun hits it all day long."

Pepper's eyes went wide. "All day long?"

"All day long," Splash confirmed. "And the shells—" She gestured with her free paw. "I've never seen so many empty shells. All shapes. All sizes."

Pepper turned to Clancy. "Did you hear that? A bigger pool! More shells! More sun!"

Clancy blinked slowly. "And what else?"

Splash tilted her head. "What else what?"

"What else is there?" Clancy asked. "You told us what it has. What else is it?"

Splash thought about this. "Well, it's different. The rocks are different. There's not as much kelp. And the current at the channel is stronger."

"Stronger!" Pepper said. "That's fine! I'm a fast swimmer!"

Clancy watched her for a long moment. Then he walked back under the overhang.

"Oh, come on!" Pepper called after him. "Aren't you even curious?"

"I'm thinking," Clancy said.

"While you think, I'm going to look!" Pepper grabbed her favorite shell—the one that was slightly too big—and hurried toward the channel.

"Wait—" Splash started.

But Pepper was already gone.


The cove felt quiet without Pepper. Clancy stayed under the overhang. The anemones swayed. Nori sat on her rock like she had for forty years, saying nothing.

Splash wrapped herself in more kelp. "Aren't you going to go after her?"

"No," said Clancy.

"She's going somewhere we haven't seen. Don't you want to know if she's safe?"

Clancy was quiet for a long time. Then he said, "She'll come back and tell us."

Splash huffed. "You're very calm for someone whose friend just left."

Clancy turned his eyes toward her. "The pool is two coves south. Pepper moves fast. She'll see it and come back. The question is what she'll see."


Hours passed. The water began to rise with the tide.

Then Pepper appeared at the channel, swimming fast. She tumbled into the cove, breathless.

"It's true!" she said. "Everything Splash said! The pool is bigger and deeper. The mussel field is huge. And the shells—Clancy, you should see the shells. There's a white shell with purple spots. I almost took it right then."

"Almost?" Splash floated closer. "You didn't bring it back?"

Pepper's excitement dimmed a little. "I couldn't find the right spot to put it. The pool—it's beautiful, but the rocks are arranged differently. I kept trying to find a place that felt like my shell garden, and I couldn't."

Clancy came out from under the overhang. "You were only there for hours."

"I know. But it felt strange. Like wearing a shell that's the wrong shape. It looks perfect, but it doesn't fit right."

Other creatures had gathered now. Ziggy the sculpin poked his head out. A few tiny shrimp gathered near Nori's rock.

"Is it true?" Ziggy asked. "Is the other pool really better?"

"Different," Pepper said. "It's better in some ways. Bigger. Sunnier. But—"

"Should we leave?" asked a small crab. "Should we move there?"

Everyone looked at Clancy.

Splash swam close to him. "Aren't you going to tell them to stay?"

"No," Clancy said.

Pepper blinked. "What? Clancy, everyone is asking. Shouldn't you tell them the cove is the best? Shouldn't you convince them to stay?"

Clancy was quiet. Then he said, "That depends on what you need."

"Clancy," Splash said, "you can't just let everyone leave!"

"I'm not letting anyone do anything," Clancy said. "I'm telling them to think."

He walked to the center of the cove, to the big pool, where Nori sat on her rock.

"Nori," he said. "What do you say?"

All the creatures gathered around. Nori was quiet for so long that the tide began to turn.

Finally, she said:

"The answer is already here."

Everyone waited. Nori said nothing else.

Clancy nodded. He turned to the creatures of the cove.

"The other pool is bigger," he said. "That is true. It has more sun. That is true. But we don't know what else it has. We don't know what its nights are like, or its winters, or its quiet hours."

Pepper nodded slowly.

"I stayed here because this pool fits me," Clancy said. "The overhang fits me. The quiet fits me. For a creature who needs what this pool has, this pool is the best pool. For a creature who needs something else, the other pool might be better."

"But what if they leave?" Pepper whispered. "What if everyone goes?"

"Then this pool is less crowded," Clancy said.

The creatures looked at each other.

Ziggy the sculpin thought about the strong current in the other pool. "I like the slow water here," he said. "I think I'll stay."

The small crab thought about the mussel field. "I like mussels," he said. "I think I'll go look."

And that was that. Some creatures went. Some stayed. The cove settled back into itself.

Splash watched from the kelp. "I thought you would be sad," she said to Clancy.

"Why?" Clancy asked.

"Because you watched some of them leave."

"Some of them," Clancy agreed. "Not all. Not most. And the ones who left were looking for something this pool doesn't have. They should be looking."

Splash was quiet a moment. Then she smiled. "You're very wise, Clancy."

"No," he said. "I just watch."

Pepper came to sit beside him. "I'm glad I came back," she said. "This pool fits me. I think I knew that when I couldn't find a place for that purple-spotted shell."

Clancy nodded. "A home is right when it fits. Not every pool fits every creature."


That night, when the cove was quiet, Clancy went under the overhang.

He carved into the slate with his claw:

A HOME IS RIGHT WHEN IT FITS. NOT EVERY POOL FITS EVERY CREATURE.

Then he set down his claw and watched the water rise.

The cove didn't lie. It just took a moment to understand.