← Library

Dino School

The Sharing Problem

The Sharing Problem

It began with the purple crayon.

Not just any purple crayon. THE purple crayon. The good one. The one that glided across the stone like a river flowing. The one that made pictures look like they might walk right off the page.

There was exactly one of them.

"There's a whole box of crayons," said Miss Fern, adjusting her stone glasses. "Why is the purple one special?"

Nobody answered. Because everybody knew.

A small red-faced dinosaur stretches his claws toward a purple crayon lying just out of reach on a stone table, straining with effort.

Rex reached for the purple crayon with his tiny arm. It was SO close. His claws stretched. His face turned redder than usual. The crayon sat exactly one inch beyond his reach.

"I meant to do that," he said.

Stella was already writing a list. "Items Needed: Purple crayon. Amount: One. Requested by: Me. Reason: My volcano drawing requires precise shading."

Rex grumbled. "I saw it first."

"You saw it when I was holding it," said Stella. "That doesn't count."

"Does too."

Two young dinosaurs face each other nose to nose, one clutching the purple crayon, both frowning stubbornly in a bright classroom.

"Does not."

"Class," said Miss Fern. She said it softly. The class went quiet, because Miss Fern's soft voice was louder than any roar.

"The crayon is on the sharing table. What does sharing mean?"

"It means I get it when I need it," said Rex.

"It means taking turns," said Stella. "As per the schedule I have prepared."

She pulled out a paper covered in tiny writing. The class groaned. Even Miss Fern's wings twitched.

A small dinosaur holds up a long paper covered in tiny scribbles while classmates slump and groan around her, a teacher's wings twitching.

"The schedule says: Purple crayon, Rex from 9:00 to 9:15. Purple crayon, Stella from 9:15 to 9:30. Purple crayon, Boom from 9:30 to..."

"Wait," said Rex. "I only get fifteen minutes?"

"The schedule is fair," said Stella.

"Fair for whoever WROTE the schedule," muttered Rex.

From above, Boom's voice drifted down like clouds. "What's happening down there? Everyone looks like a small argument from up here."

Rex held up the purple crayon.

"Oh!" said Boom. "Is that a pencil?"

"It's a CRAYON, Boom."

"From up here, it looks like a pencil."

"It's the PURPLE crayon," said Rex. "The good one."

Boom's face lit up. "Oh! The one that matches the volcano smoke at sunset? I love that one. I want to draw the river from above."

A tall dinosaur leans down from above, eyes wide with delight, while a small red dinosaur holds up the purple crayon below.

"You can't," said Rex. "I'm using it."

"Not forever," said Stella. "Just until 9:15."

"For fifteen minutes?" Rex couldn't believe it. "That's not enough time to draw ANYTHING. Well. Maybe a very small pebble. With good shading."

"You could draw faster," said Stella.

"You could draw SMALLER," said Boom, helpfully.

Rex made a sound like a kettle about to whistle. "The purple crayon is SPECIAL. Special things should NOT be rushed!"

Miss Fern said nothing. She just watched. Because that's what she did.

The argument continued through morning work. Then through snack. Then through the volcano demonstration, which was supposed to be about rocks and ended up being about whose turn it was.

Three dinosaurs argue around a stone table scattered with drawings, a teacher watching calmly from the side, everyone looking frustrated.

"Fine," said Rex at last. "I'll SHARE. But only if everyone admits that I am being very generous."

"Thank you, dear Rex," said Miss Fern.

"She called me dear Rex," whispered Rex. "But also, she called me Stella last week."

"Miss Fern called me Stella too," said Stella. "I think. Or was that Rex?"

Nobody could remember.

Finally, they made a new schedule. Rex got the crayon from 9:00 to 9:07. Stella from 9:07 to 9:14. Boom from 9:14 to 9:21. Then back to Rex, but only for four minutes, because Stella calculated that the morning would run out.

"Four minutes?!" Rex's roar rattled the fern fronds. "That's not sharing! That's torture!"

"It's arithmetic," said Stella.

"Arithmetic is worse than torture."

But the schedule was made. The crayon was passed. And everyone was unhappy.

Rex drew a tiny pebble. It took him six minutes.

Stella drew a volcano. It took her five minutes, and she was NOT satisfied with the shading.

Boom drew a river from above. It took him exactly three minutes, because he couldn't see the crayon properly and coloured outside every line.

Three dinosaurs sit apart, each holding a half-finished drawing, scowling at their own work as the worn purple crayon rests between them.

"This is terrible," said Rex.

"Completely unsatisfactory," said Stella.

"Very small," said Boom.

Miss Fern looked at all three drawings. She looked at the purple crayon, now worn down to half its size. She smiled.

"Hm," she said. "It seems like nobody is happy."

"Right!" said Rex.

"Exactly correct!" said Stella.

"I wanted a better river," said Boom.

"Interesting," said Miss Fern. "So sharing the purple crayon made everyone miserable?"

"Yes!"

"Then it was probably the right thing to do."

The class stared.

"Because," said Miss Fern, "when everyone is a LITTLE bit unhappy, it usually means things are fair. If one person is very happy and everyone else is very sad, that's not sharing. But if everyone is a little bit disappointed? That means everyone got something."

Rex looked at his tiny pebble drawing. It was actually pretty good. "I used my time well," he admitted.

"I captured the shape of the volcano," said Stella. "Even if the shading is off."

"The river looks like it's travelling," said Boom. "All over the page. Very much everywhere."

They looked at the drawings together.

"Maybe we could colour one picture together," said Rex. "Using my pebble, and Stella's volcano, and Boom's river."

"One picture?" said Stella.

"With everyone unhappy about different parts?" said Boom.

"Exactly," said Rex.

Miss Fern nodded. "That sounds like a plan."

They coloured together. Rex did the ground. Stella did the sky. Boom did the river, which wandered crookedly across the whole page, and everyone agreed it was the most interesting river they'd ever seen.

Three dinosaurs lean over one big picture together, coloring a crooked river, a volcano, and a pebble, all smiling happily.

The purple crayon wore down to a little nub.

Nobody got what they wanted.

Everybody got something.

And that, Miss Fern said, was the best kind of day.