The Message in the Bottle
Islas True Thing
The Thing She Noticed
Isla sat on the rocks with her bottle between her knees. The wind pulled at her hair and the sea threw itself against the shore, grey and restless.
She had written her letter to Marco twice already. The first version had been about her grandfather's new hat. The second had been about the tide pools. Both were true, but neither was the true thing.
"Isla!" her grandfather called from the garden wall. "The sea won't wait all day!"
"The sea can wait," Isla muttered. But she knew he was right. The bottle had to go in before the tide turned.
She looked at her letter. She had written:
Dear Marco,
The sea is grey today. Not sad grey. Just grey. Like a blanket that's been washed too many times.
I have been thinking about something.
When I put a letter in the bottle, I think about you reading it. But sometimes, in the middle of the night, I wonder—
She stopped. She had been working on that sentence for three days.
The sea crashed. The sea waited.
Isla took a deep breath and wrote the true thing.
The True Thing
Dear Marco,
The sea is grey today. Not sad grey. Just grey. Like a blanket that's been washed too many times.
I have been thinking about something.
When I put a letter in the bottle, I think about you reading it. But sometimes, in the middle of the night, I wonder if the other end of the ocean is as real as my end.
I know you are real. I do. But my end of the ocean is the only end I have ever seen. When I throw the bottle in, it goes out and out and out, and I have to believe there is an in on the other side.
You write to me. I get your letters. So I know you are there.
But sometimes I wonder anyway.
That is the true thing I put in every letter. Even the ones about seagulls.
Your friend,
Isla
She read it once. Twice. Three times.
Her cheeks felt hot, even in the cold wind.
She folded the letter carefully and slid it into the bottle. She pushed the cork in with her thumb. She walked to the water's edge and threw the bottle as far as she could.
It landed with a small splash. The sea took it.
The Waiting
The waiting was the hardest part. It always was.
Isla checked the shore every day after school. She walked the beach on Saturday. She looked in all the places bottles liked to land—the rock pools, the seaweed nests, the place where the tide left things it didn't want anymore.
Nothing.
"It takes time," her grandfather said. "The sea doesn't rush."
"The sea is too slow," Isla said.
"The sea is exactly as fast as it needs to be," her grandfather said. "That's what the sea is for."
Isla thought about her true thing. It was in the bottle, bobbing on the water. Somewhere out there, her wondering was floating toward Marco.
She wondered if he would think it was silly.
She wondered if he would think she didn't believe in him.
She wondered if she had sent the wrong thing.
On the fourth day, she wrote a new letter to explain the first letter. Then she wrote a letter to explain that letter. Then she threw both of them in the sea and sat on the rocks and watched the waves.
The sea kept its secrets.
The Answer
The bottle arrived on a Tuesday. Isla wasn't even looking for it. She was collecting driftwood for her grandfather when she saw it—a green bottle, half buried in sand, with a cork she recognized.
Marco's cork. The one he always used. The one he said came from his grandmother's best jam.
Her hands shook as she pulled it out. The letter inside was rolled tight, the way Marco rolled them. The paper was warm, even after the long crossing. Or maybe that was her hands.
She unrolled it.
His handwriting was big and loopy and rushed, like he had been in a hurry to get the words out.
Dear Isla,
I read your letter three times. Then four. Then I took it to my grandma and read it to her, and she said I should read it again, so I did.
Here is what I think:
I think about this all the time.
Not the same way you do. I don't wonder if you're real. I know you're real because your letters are very real. They are real like the sea is real. You can't see the whole sea, but you know it's there because you've seen one wave. And you know there are more waves. And you know they are going somewhere.
Your letters are my waves, Isla. They keep coming. I keep catching them.
So yes. Your end of the ocean is real. My end is real. The sea in between is real, too. Sometimes I think the sea in between is the most real part, because it carries us to each other.
Your letters are very real.
That's all I wanted to say.
Your friend,
Marco
P.S. I still think seagulls are better than other birds. But you are wrong and I am right.
P.P.S. My grandma says hello.
Isla read the letter once. Then twice. Then she read the part about the waves again.
"Your letters are very real."
She said it out loud. The wind took it.
She said it again, quieter.
The sea was grey and green and moving, and somewhere on the other side of it, Marco was real. And her letters were real. And the sea between them was real, too.
Isla folded the letter carefully and put it in her pocket, next to her heart.
She sat on the rocks for a long time, watching the waves come in.
She didn't feel like she was waiting anymore.