Fix It or Replace It
What the Come-Along Taught Me
The mountain road was dust and gravel and switchbacks. Leo bounced in the passenger seat of Uncle Magnus’s truck, his Fix Log open on his lap.
“We’re almost there,” Uncle Magnus said. “Vera says the big haul truck won’t start.”
“What’s wrong with it?” Leo asked.
“That’s the question, isn’t it?” Uncle Magnus smiled. “We don’t know yet. We have to go look.”
The haul truck sat at the end of the road like a sleeping giant. Vera met them by the front bumper, her clipboard in her hand.
“It was bringing ore down the mountain,” she said. “Then—clunk. No drive. No forward, no reverse. The transmission won’t engage.”
Uncle Magnus nodded. He walked around the truck. He opened the hood. He crawled underneath. Leo crawled underneath too, dragging his Fix Log in the dirt.
“See that?” Uncle Magnus pointed to a piece of metal near the driveshaft. It was cracked clean through. “That’s the clutch linkage yoke. It connects the pedal to the clutch. When it broke, the clutch can’t disengage. The truck can’t move.”
“So we replace it,” Leo said. “Easy.”
Uncle Magnus shook his head. “The part is two days away. Maybe three. There’s no parts supplier up here, Leo. We’re on our own.”
Vera leaned down. “Three days? We have ore coming down this road tomorrow. We can’t wait three days.”
Leo looked at the broken yoke. “Then what do we do?”
Uncle Magnus stood up and brushed the dust off his knees. He walked to his truck and opened the tool box. He pulled out a long, metal handle with a crank on one end and a hook on the other.
“This is a come-along,” he said. “It’s a hand winch. You crank it, and the cable pulls.”
Leo looked at it. “That’s for pulling things. Not for a clutch.”
“Correct,” Uncle Magnus said. “But here’s the question we always have to ask: What does this job actually need? Not what’s the standard fix. Not what do I wish I had. What does this job, in these conditions, for this timeframe, actually need?”
Leo thought about it. “It needs the truck to move. Down the mountain. To the shop.”
“Right,” Uncle Magnus said. “And what does the broken yoke do?”
“It connects the pedal to the clutch.”
“So the pedal can’t move the clutch. But what if we don’t need the pedal?”
Leo’s eyes went wide. “What do you mean?”
Uncle Magnus lay down under the truck again. He pointed to the clutch arm. “I can hook the come-along to this arm. I can use the winch to pull it when it needs to be pulled. I can control the clutch with my hand from inside the cab.”
“Wait,” Leo said. “You’re going to drive the truck with a come-along?”
“I’m going to drive it out with a come-along,” Uncle Magnus said. “It won’t be perfect. I’ll have to crank and release, crank and release. It’ll be slow. It’ll be clumsy. But it will get the truck down the mountain to the shop where they can put in the real part.”
Vera looked at the truck. Then she looked at the come-along. “Will it hold?”
“For this trip? Yes,” Uncle Magnus said. “Is it the right fix for the long term? No. This is a temporary fix, and we need to be honest with ourselves about that. It’s a bridge. It’s not the destination.”
Leo wrote in his Fix Log: Heavy truck, broken clutch yoke. Needed: get it moving to drive out. Used: come-along as temporary control. Temporary: yes, noted in logbook. Permanent fix: part ordered, installed at shop.
Uncle Magnus climbed into the cab. He rigged the come-along through the window. Leo watched as his uncle cranked the handle. The clutch arm moved. The truck lurched forward.
Crank. Release. Crank. Release.
The truck rolled slowly down the mountain road, Leo following in the pickup truck. The come-along wasn’t the right tool. It wasn’t the permanent solution. But it was fit for purpose. It did what the job needed, right then, in that moment.
When they reached the bottom, the shop mechanic came out. “Whoa,” he said. “A come-along?”
“It knew it was temporary,” Leo said proudly. “That’s why it worked.”
The mechanic laughed. “I’ll order the right part. It’ll be here tomorrow.”
On the drive home, Leo opened his Fix Log to a new page. “What did the come-along teach me?” he asked.
Uncle Magnus thought for a moment. “That the question is always: what does this job actually need? Not what’s the standard fix. Not what do I wish I had. What does this job, in these conditions, for this timeframe, actually need? Answer that question honestly, and the rest follows.”
Leo wrote it down: The question is always: what does this job need?
Then he added: A temporary fix that knows it’s temporary is honest. A temporary fix that pretends it’s permanent is a problem.