← Library

The Message in the Bottle

Marcos Idea

The Letter That Started It

Dear Isla,

I have an idea. It's a big one. Maybe the biggest one yet.

What if we could find the exact middle of the ocean between us? The one point where a bottle from you and a bottle from me would meet. Not your ocean or my ocean. Our ocean. The middle place.

I've been thinking about it for three days. My grandmother says I've been staring at the sea too long. She says it's making me weird. I told her I was already weird before I started staring.

She laughed and gave me a biscuit.

So what do you think? Can we figure it out?

Your friend,

Marco

P.S. I drew a picture of what I think the middle looks like. It's mostly blue. With some waves. I'm not very good at drawing waves.

P.P.S. Do you think there are fish there? Like, actual fish just swimming around in the middle of nowhere, not knowing they're in the middle of anything?


Isla's Reply

Dear Marco,

I read your letter three times. Then I read it again.

I think it's a wonderful idea. I also think we can't actually do it.

I asked my grandfather. He laughed for a very long time. Then he said, "The sea doesn't do exact."

He told me that even the fishermen can't agree on where the middle is. The sea moves. The currents shift. The wind changes. One day the middle might be one place. The next day it might be somewhere else entirely.

Also, we don't know how fast the bottles travel. Remember Book 8? Sorry, I mean remember when we tried to figure out how long bottles take? One took eleven weeks. One took four days. The sea isn't a straight line. It's more like a very messy scribble that's always changing.

But here's what I think we can do.

We can imagine it.

I've been sitting on the rocks watching my sea. The grey-green water with the white caps. The gulls overhead (yes, I know, I like them, you don't, we've argued about this). And I've been trying to imagine the exact spot where the middle would be.

My grandfather says if I want to find the middle of anything, I should stop looking at the map and start looking at the feeling.

I don't know what that means yet.

But I'm going to try.

One true thing: I like that we have a middle. Even if we can't find it.

Your friend,

Isla

P.S. I think there are definitely fish there. Probably very confused fish who think they're in the middle of something important. They might be right.


The Middle of the Ocean

Dear Marco,

I tried to draw the middle of the ocean today.

It didn't go very well.

I drew a circle in the middle of the paper. Then I colored it blue. Then I drew waves around it. Then I realized I was just drawing the ocean. Which is the whole problem.

My grandfather came to look at my drawing. He said, "You're drawing water."

I said, "That's what the ocean is."

He said, "No. The ocean is what's between the water and the land and the sky and the feeling of being out there."

I don't know if that makes sense. But I think I know what he means.

He told me once that when he's out on the boat, far from shore, everything looks the same. Water in every direction. But he can still feel where he is. He can feel where home is behind him. He can feel where the open sea is ahead of him.

I wonder if the middle of the ocean between us is like that. Not a place you can point to. But a place you can feel.

I imagine it's a place where the water is bluer than mine but greener than yours. Where the weather is mixed up — some of my wind and some of your sun. Where the fish swim around not knowing they're in the middle of anything. Maybe they're the lucky ones.

Tonight I'm going to sit on the rocks and face the direction I think you're in. I'm going to pretend I can see all the way across the ocean to your island. And I'm going to imagine the middle point, right between us.

Maybe you could do the same on your side.

Your friend,

Isla

P.S. I think the fish probably know. I think everything in the sea knows exactly where it is. Maybe they're teaching us something.


Marco's Answer

Dear Isla,

I did it! I sat on the beach and faced the direction I think you're in!

My grandmother asked me what I was doing. I told her I was finding the middle of the ocean. She nodded like this was a completely normal thing to do. Then she said, "Don't forget sunscreen."

So I put on sunscreen. Then I sat very still and stared at the sea.

Here's what I noticed: the sea on my side is very bright. It sparkles. It's like someone threw glitter into it. My grandmother says it's just the sun, but I think the sea here is showing off.

I tried to imagine the middle. I closed my eyes. I thought about your grey-green water. I thought about my bright blue water. I wondered what color they'd be if you mixed them together.

I think it would be the color of hope. That sounds silly. But I mean it.

I also thought about the fish. The middle fish. The ones swimming around in that exact spot. I decided they're not confused at all. I decided they're the smartest fish in the ocean. Because they know the middle of something is important. Even if you can't point to it exactly.

Here's what I think, Isla:

Maybe the middle of the ocean isn't a place we can find. Maybe it's a place we make. Every time we write a letter, it travels from your shore to mine. Every time I read your letter, I'm meeting you in the middle. Every time you read mine, you're meeting me there too.

The middle is real. We're just standing in it without knowing it.

Is that too weird? My grandmother says I think too much. She says it's because I live on an island and there's nothing else to do. But I think she's secretly proud.

I'm going to keep imagining the middle. I'm going to imagine it as a place with a little white buoy. And on the buoy, there's a mailbox. And every time we send a bottle, it passes through that middle point, and the fish wave at it as it goes by.

Your friend,

Marco

P.S. My grandmother made me send you something. It's a shell. She says the sea carried it to our shore, and now the sea can carry it to yours. She says it's from the middle. She winks when she says it. I don't know if she's joking.

P.P.S. I don't think she's joking.


The True Thing

Dear Marco,

The shell arrived today. It's beautiful. It's the color of both our seas at once.

I held it up to my ear. I know people say you can hear the ocean in a shell. But this one had a different sound. It sounded like wind. And waves. And maybe, if I listened closely enough, like two people far away, writing letters to each other.

I put the shell on my windowsill. It's sitting between a rock from my shore and a drawing of your island.

My grandfather saw it. He picked it up. He held it for a long time.

"This is from the middle," he said.

I said, "That's what Marco's grandmother said."

He nodded. Then he gave it back to me.

"You found it," he said. "The middle. It's not on any map. But you found it."

Here's the true thing, Marco. I think you're right. I think the middle isn't a place you can find on a map. It's a place you find in the writing and the waiting and the reading and the wondering.

Every week, I throw a bottle into the sea. Every week, I wonder where it goes. Every week, I imagine it passing through that middle point, where the fish wave and the water is the color of hope.

And then I wait for your letter. And when it comes, I read it. And I know — I know — that we just met in the middle. We were standing there together, the whole time.

I can't figure out the exact middle of the ocean. I can't calculate where our bottles would meet. I can't draw it on a map or point to it from the rocks.

But I can imagine it.

And I think that's even better.

Your friend,

Isla

P.S. I'm sending you a rock from my shore. It's grey with a stripe of white through it, like a little wave frozen in time. My grandfather says it's been everywhere the sea has been. Now it can come to you.

P.P.S. Tell your grandmother thank you for the shell. Tell her I think she knows more about the middle than anyone.

P.P.P.S. The middle is real. I believe that now.