← Library

Clancys Cove

The Disappearing Hermit Crabs

Clancy noticed it first.

He was sitting at the edge of the Big Pool, watching the afternoon light ripple across the sand, when he realized something was missing. The young hermit crabs—the three little ones who usually scuttled along the north face, chasing bubbles and trading shells with Pepper—were gone.

Clancy watched for a long moment. The cove was quiet where they usually were. He counted the rocks where they played. Empty. He counted again. Still empty.

What changed? he thought.


Pepper zoomed up, her new shell clicking against the stones. "Clancy! Did you see? They're GONE! All three of them! I've looked everywhere—well, not everywhere, but almost everywhere—and they're not there! They just moved! For no reason!"

Clancy turned his slow eyes toward her. "They didn't move for no reason, Pepper."

"Then WHY?"

"I'm thinking," said Clancy.

But Pepper was already gone, skittering across the cove toward the Kelp Curtain, her shell wobbling.


Pepper found the three little crabs near the south edge of the cove, where the water from the open ocean seeped through the rocks. They were huddled together in a small warm pool, looking comfortable and sleepy.

"WHAT ARE YOU DOING OVER HERE?!" Pepper demanded. "Everyone was worried! Well, I was worried. Clancy was watching."

The smallest crab blinked at her. "We just... moved."

"Why?! The Shell Garden is WAY better! I have shells there! Good shells! Shells you could USE!"

The crabs looked at each other.

"We don't know," said the middle one. "It just felt right here."

Pepper's shell wobbled as she thought. "That doesn't make any sense!"


Back at the Big Pool, Clancy was slowly walking toward the north face. He checked the temperature of the water with his claw. Then he walked to the south edge, where Pepper was gesturing wildly at the young crabs.

"Clancy! They don't even KNOW why they moved!"

"Good," said Clancy.

"GOOD?!"

"That means they paid attention to something they didn't understand yet." He reached into the warm pool and touched the water with his claw. Then he touched the water at the north face. Then he sat very still.

"The water is warmer here," he said. "In the afternoon."

Pepper touched the water too. Then she touched it at the north face. Her eyes went wide. "It IS warmer! But it's the same tide! Same sun! Same everything!"

"Not the same everything," said Clancy. "The rocks are different. The south rocks are dark. The north rocks are light. In the afternoon, the sun heats the dark rocks. The warm rocks warm the water."

The three little crabs looked at each other. "OH!" said the smallest. "We didn't know that's why! We just felt warmer and it felt good!"


Splash floated up to the edge of the cove, wrapping herself in kelp. "I heard there was an emergency! Something about missing crabs? Did they get washed out? Did a bird get them? Should I be worried?"

"They moved," said Pepper. "For no reason!"

"There's a reason," said Clancy.

"What is it?" asked Pepper.

"The warm water."

Splash blinked. "Oh! That's a good reason. I move to warm water all the time. The kelp beds on the south side are much warmer in the afternoon. Everybody knows that."

Pepper stared at her. "HOW COME EVERYONE KNEW ABOUT THIS EXCEPT ME?"

"You weren't paying attention to the water," said Clancy. "You were paying attention to the crabs."


The three little crabs decided to stay in the warm pool. It wasn't a problem—they were still in the cove, just at the south edge. The older crabs agreed it was a good spot for them. The young ones seemed happier. More energy. Better color.

Pepper thought about this for a long time. "So when something moves," she said slowly, "I should figure out why. Before I decide it's wrong."

"Yes," said Clancy.

"That means I don't have to fix everything right away?"

Clancy made a sound that might have been a chuckle. "You should still find things. Finding is your gift. Just don't decide something is broken until you know what changed."


Nori was quiet that evening, her purple tentacles waving in the gentle current. Clancy swam over to the Big Pool and waited. She spoke:

"The answer is already here. It always was."

Clancy nodded. "The water knew."

"The water always knows."


That night, under the overhang, Clancy carved into the Cove Log. The slate was still mostly empty, but the words were true:

EVERYTHING MOVES FOR A REASON. FIND THE REASON BEFORE YOU DECIDE IF IT'S WRONG.


The three little crabs stayed at the south edge for the rest of the summer. When the season changed and the sun didn't heat the dark rocks as much, they moved back to the north face. No one panicked that time.

Pepper had already figured it out.