Shell by Shell
The Tin Can Test
Scout the hermit crab was having a problem.
Not a big problem. Not a scary problem. A squishy problem.
“I think,” he said, wiggling his orange-brown body inside his shell, “I think I’m growing again.”
Pip, the ghost shrimp, was napping. He was always napping. But at the word growing, his tiny, see-through body shot awake.
“What’s happening... oh no. OH NO. Not the squish! Not the squeeze!” Pip zipped around the inside of the shell like a panicked ping-pong ball. “We’ve done this before, Scout! We have to find a new shell! Again! Do you know how many shells we’ve lived in? Twenty-three! This is madness!”
“It’s not madness, Pip. It’s just… snug,” Scout sighed. He leaned back. Bump. He leaned forward. Bump. There was no room to stretch his eyestalks all the way out. “Snug is fine for a little while. But I think we need to start looking.”
So they did what they always did. They packed up their tiny belongings, a grain of sand Pip liked, a small pebble Scout thought was pretty, and they went exploring.
Today, they were near the old shipwreck. The wooden ribs of the boat rose above them like a whale's skeleton. The sand was littered with strange things. A glass bottle. A rubber boot. A rusty anchor.
And then Scout saw it.
A tin can.
It was round and silver, not too big, not too small. It was lying on its side, half-buried in the sand. And the opening? It was perfect. Smooth and round and just the right size.
“Pip,” Scout whispered. “Look.”
Pip looked. He squinted. “Looks like a metal trap.”
“It’s a tin can,” Scout said. “It’s from the humans. Mabel told me about them. They hold food.”
“Well, then, it’s a food trap.”
Scout ignored him. He shuffled closer. He poked a claw inside. The metal was cool and smooth. He wiggled inside.
Click-clack.
It fit.
“Whoa,” Scout breathed. He turned around. There was room to spin! Room to stretch all six legs! Room to poke his eyestalks out and look around without bumping anything! “Pip… it’s comfortable!”
Pip hopped in behind him. The can echoed with a clank-clank. Pip slid around on the shiny metal floor. “It’s cold,” he said. “And loud. And it smells like… old soup.”
“But it’s roomy!” Scout spun in a circle. “I can move! I can breathe!” He did a little happy wiggle. “I don’t have to worry about outgrowing this for a long, long time.”
Pip sat down. His little legs tapped on the metal. Tap-tap-tap. “So… what are you saying? Are we… staying here?”
Scout poked his head out of the can. The world shimmered in the sunlight. “Why not? It’s comfortable. It’s safe. I could live here forever.”
Pip was quiet for a moment. Then, in his smallest voice, he said, “It’s not a shell.”
“It’s better than a shell,” Scout said. “It’s a home that doesn’t pinch.”
“But it’s a can,” Pip said. “It’s a piece of trash.”
Scout frowned. “It’s a piece of home. Trash is just a place where the story hasn’t happened yet.”
Pip crawled out and sat on the sand in front of the can. He looked very small. “Doesn’t it bother you? That anyone can see it’s a can? Don’t you want something that looks… handsome? Something that looks like you?”
Scout looked down at the silver walls. “It doesn’t look like me,” he admitted. “But it fits me. And I feel good in it.”
“But what will the other creatures think?” Pip asked. “When they see you living in a soup can, won’t they laugh? Won’t they think you’re strange?”
“Maybe,” Scout said. “But I can stretch my legs.”
“But dignity, Scout! Dignity!”
Scout crawled out and stood next to Pip. They looked at each other. They were best friends. They always understood each other. Except for now. This time, they were completely lost.
“Pip,” Scout said slowly, “is dignity more important than comfort?”
Pip puffed out his tiny chest. “Yes! Dignity is what makes you… you! It’s how you carry yourself. It’s pride!”
“But my shell doesn’t make me proud, Pip,” Scout said. “How I feel inside does. And right now, I feel good. I feel comfortable. Doesn’t that make me more me?”
Pip opened his mouth. Then he closed it. Then he opened it again. “I don’t know,” he finally said.
Scout looked at the tin can. Then he looked at the old shell he had left on the sand. It was too tight. It would pinch. It would squeeze. But it was a shell.
“I don’t know either,” Scout said.
They sat together in the quiet. The water swirled gently above them.
Far away, a fish swam by, saw them, and stopped. “Nice can!” the fish called. “Very shiny!”
Scout and Pip blinked.
“You hear that?” Scout whispered.
“He didn’t laugh,” Pip whispered back.
“He thought it was nice.”
Pip tapped his feet on the sand. Tick-tick-tick. “Does that change anything?”
“I don’t think so,” Scout said.
“Me neither,” Pip said.
They climbed back into the tin can. It was cool and roomy and comfortable. Scout stretched all his legs. Pip slid around and found a cozy corner.
“Pip?” Scout said.
“Yes?”
“What if we try it for one day? And if it feels all right, we stay. And if we go back to looking for a shell, we do that too.”
Pip thought about it. “One day,” he said. “But I’m keeping my opinions ready.”
Scout smiled. He poked his head out into the blue water.
“It’ll be fine,” he said. “Probably. Maybe.”
He looked around at the tin can walls. He wiggled his toes.
“Let’s go.”
And they did.