← Library

Clancys Cove

What Otto Can Do

The morning light came into the cove like a slow yellow tide. Clancy sat at the edge of the Big Pool, watching the water warm around him. Something was different. Something had changed.

In the corner near the Kelp Curtain, where the rocks made a small sandy hollow, Otto was showing off.

Otto was a young decorator crab, new to the cove. He had arrived in Book 25, small and shy, wearing a collection of seaweed scraps on his back. But Otto could do something no one else in the cove could do. He could change color. He could change shape.

Right now, he was pretending to be a rock. A gray, lumpy, completely boring rock. Then he shifted, and suddenly he looked like a piece of sand. Then like a shell. Then like a piece of driftwood.

"Otto! Do the rock again!" Pepper squealed. She was bouncing in her new shell—a little too big, but she had decided it was definitely the one. "Do the sand! Do the red one! Do the one where you look like Clancy!"

Otto wobbled. The Clancy impression was not very good. He looked like a crab-shaped rock with confused eyes.

"Again! Again!" Pepper clapped her little claws together.

Clancy watched. Otto was tired. His colors were getting muddy. His rock shape was less rock-like than it had been five minutes ago.

"Otto!" Pepper called. "Do the one where you look like a fish! Can you look like a fish?"

"I don't think I can look like a fish," Otto said quietly. His shell had settled into a flat, grayish color. Not rock gray. Not sand gray. Just tired gray.

"You can do anything with those colors!" Pepper said. "Clancy, look! He can be anything!"

Clancy walked slowly across the sand. He took his time. He always took his time.

"He can be anything," Clancy agreed. "He can be anything, but he is not a toy."

Pepper blinked. "What?"

"Otto has been changing shapes since the sun came up," Clancy said. "Look at him."

Otto's colors were dull. His spines were drooping. He looked like a crab who had been everything and now was nothing.

"But it's so good!" Pepper said. "I've never seen a crab do that! I want to see all the things he can do!"

"You want to see all the things he can do," Clancy said slowly. "But Otto is not a thing. He is a crab. And his colors are not for showing off. They are for his life."

Just then, Splash floated in from the Kelp Curtain. She was wrapped in kelp, as usual, and holding a sea urchin in her paws.

"Oh!" Splash said. "I heard Pepper from three rocks away. What's happening?"

"Otto can change color!" Pepper said. "He can look like anything! Show her, Otto! Do the rock again!"

Otto tried. He really did. But his colors barely shifted. He looked like a slightly different shade of tired.

Splash looked at Otto. Then she looked at Clancy. Then she looked at Pepper.

"He can do anything with those colors," Pepper said. "But he won't do them anymore."

"He does them when he needs to," Clancy said.

"But it's so good," Pepper said. "When he's just sitting there, being a normal crab—that's not using his skill at all!"

Clancy's eyes were very still. "That's why he saves it."

Splash nodded. "Out in the kelp, there are fish who change color to hide. They don't do it for fun. They do it to stay alive. Every time they change, it costs them something. Energy. Focus. Strength."

Otto looked up. "That's it exactly. When I change colors, it takes everything I have. I can do it a few times. Then I'm used up."

Pepper stopped bouncing. She looked at Otto. Really looked at him.

"You're tired," she said.

"Very tired," Otto said.

"But you kept doing it anyway," Pepper said.

Otto nodded. "You wanted to see. I didn't want to disappoint you."

Pepper was quiet. It was a strange sound—silence from Pepper. Even Splash looked surprised.

Clancy spoke. "A skill used constantly loses its power. When Otto changes colors all day, he has nothing left for the moments that matter. The moment when a big fish comes looking for dinner. The moment when he needs to disappear."

Pepper looked down at her own shell. It was too big. She had chosen it for the size, because it looked impressive. But it was heavy and awkward.

"I didn't think about that," Pepper said. "I just thought it was wonderful."

"It is wonderful," Clancy said. "That's why it needs to be used wisely."

Otto's colors began to return—just a little. A hint of rock gray, a touch of sand brown. He looked less tired.

"Well," Pepper said. "I'm going to go reorganize my shell garden. By myself. Quietly." She paused. "Otto, when you're not tired anymore, maybe you could show me one thing. Just one. But not until you're ready."

Otto smiled. It was a small crab smile, but it was real.

"I'd like that," he said.

Clancy watched Pepper scuttle off to the Shell Garden. Then he walked slowly to the east end of the cove, under the overhang, and carved into the slate.


CLANCY'S COVE LOG:

"USE YOUR STRENGTHS WHEN THEY COUNT. USING THEM ALL THE TIME WEARS THEM DOWN."


That evening, Nori spoke. Just one sentence:

"The best colors are the ones you never see," she said.

And in the cove, everything was quiet. The way it should be. The way it needed to be.