← Library

The Cook Together Kitchen

Pops Potato Soup

The Famous Soup

Pop's potato soup was famous. Not famous in the whole world—famous in Lily's family. Everyone talked about it. Dad said it was the soup he grew up eating. Mom said it was the only thing Pop made that she'd wait in line for.

And Pop? Pop just shrugged and said, "It's soup. I put potatoes in it."

Today was the day. Pop was coming over, and Lily was ready with her notebook.

"I'm going to write it down this time," she said, opening to a fresh page. "Every single step. So we can make it forever."

Pop laughed. "Good luck with that. I don't know what half the steps are."

"That's okay," Lily said. "I'll figure it out."

The Peeling and Chopping

Pop set a big pot on the stove. "First, the potatoes."

He reached into the bag and picked out six medium potatoes. Lily counted them.

"Can I peel?" she asked.

"You can peel," Pop said. "But be careful with the peeler."

Lily peeled. It was one of her favorite jobs. The peel came off in long strips, and she tried to get one as long as her arm. She didn't quite make it.

"Good peeling," Pop said. "Now we chop. Can you chop?"

Lily nodded. Chop was the part where you got to use a knife. A real one, but not too sharp—Pop always called it "the kid knife."

"Cut them into cubes about this big," Pop said, holding up his thumb.

Lily chopped and chopped. The potatoes went into a big bowl of cold water.

"Wait," Lily said, writing in her notebook. "Potatoes go in water?"

"So they don't turn brown," Pop said. "And so we can rinse off the starch."

"Starch?" Lily wrote it down.

"The white stuff that makes soup cloudy," Pop said. "We're going to make this soup mostly clear. Clear-ish."

The Sizzle and the Simmer

Pop drained the potatoes and put them in the big pot. Then he poured in chicken broth—about four cups, until the potatoes were just covered.

"That's the soup part," he said. "The potato part is the potatoes."

Lily wrote: Potatoes in pot. Broth ON TOP.

"Now we turn on the heat," Pop said, lighting the burner. "And we wait."

While they waited, Lily got out the other ingredients Pop asked for: one onion, three cloves of garlic, butter, flour, milk, salt, white pepper, and cheddar cheese.

"This is a lot of stuff," she said.

"Mostly it's for the lazy part," Pop said.

Lily looked at him. "The what?"

"You'll see."

After the thermometer showed the soup was bubbling, Pop said, "Now the onion. Finely diced."

Lily diced the onion while Pop melted butter in a small pan. "About four tablespoons," he said.

"Four?" Lily wrote it down. "How many is that?"

"Half a stick," Pop said. "You can just cut it and count."

Lily counted four tablespoons and put them in the pan. They sizzled.

"In goes the onion," Pop said.

Lily stirred the onion in the butter while Pop minced the garlic.

"Finely minced," he said, and Lily wrote that down too.

"Garlic goes in now?" she asked.

"Not yet," Pop said. "Onion gets a head start. It's sweeter that way. Garlic needs less time—about a minute."

Lily stirred the onion until it was soft and golden. Then Pop said, "Now the garlic."

Lily added it. The kitchen smelled amazing.

"Wait," Lily said. "Weren't we going to do something with flour?"

Pop grinned. "That's the lazy part. Watch."

While the onions were cooking, Pop had been doing something else—using a fork, he'd mashed about a cup of the cooked potatoes in a small bowl with some of the broth.

"What's that?" Lily asked.

"That's the thickener," Pop said. "No flour needed. The potato is its own thickener."

"So we don't need the flour?" Lily asked.

Pop shrugged. "I already put it back in the cabinet."

Lily watched as Pop stirred the mashed potatoes back into the soup. The soup got thicker, almost instantly.

"See?" Pop said. "Lazy."

Lily wrote: NEXT TIME—skip flour entirely.

But then Pop looked at the soup and frowned. "Hmm. It's a little thin. We need something to make it creamy. Can you get the milk?"

Lily poured in about a cup of milk. Pop stirred.

"It's still a little thin," he said. "Hmm."

The Fix

"We need the flour after all," Pop said.

"But we put it back," Lily said.

"Putting things back is what I do," Pop said. "Getting them out again is what you do."

Lily got the flour. Pop measured out two tablespoons and put them in a small bowl with a little cold milk.

"Watch," he said. "You make a paste first, so it doesn't clump."

Lily watched the paste come together—smooth, no lumps. She wrote: Make paste before adding flour to hot soup.

Pop stirred the paste into the broth. Slowly, the soup thickened. It went from watery to creamy, right in front of Lily's eyes.

"Now," Pop said, "taste."

Lily blew on a spoonful and tasted. "It needs salt."

"Salt it," Pop said.

Lily shook in salt. Tasted again. "A little more."

"Good. That's exactly how you do it."

"What about white pepper?" Lily asked.

"White pepper is for heat without the black spots," Pop said. "Just a pinch."

Lily added a pinch. Then she tasted it again.

"It's good," she said. "But what about the cheese?"

Pop looked surprised. "You want cheese? I never add cheese."

"No?" Lily said. "But we got cheese out."

Pop laughed. "I was going to make grilled cheese for lunch. The cheese is for sandwiches, not soup."

Lily looked at the soup, then at the cheese, then at Pop.

"Could we?" she asked.

Pop thought. "I guess we could. But I've never done it."

"Me neither," Lily said.

They both looked at the soup.

"Let's try it," Pop said. "One handful."

Lily grated a handful of cheddar and sprinkled it in. Pop stirred, and the cheese melted into the soup.

"Huh," he said, tasting. "That's actually pretty good."

Lily wrote in her notebook: CHEESE makes it BETTER. Pop said so.

As Good As It Gets

They ladled the soup into two bowls. Pop put a grilled cheese sandwich next to each one—he'd been making them on the griddle the whole time, which Lily hadn't even noticed.

"Pop!" she said. "You were cooking two things?"

"I was cooking grilled cheese," he said. "You were cooking soup. Team effort."

Lily dipped her grilled cheese into the soup. It was the best thing she'd ever eaten. She said so.

"It's pretty good," Pop agreed.

Lily looked at her notebook. She'd written everything she could remember:

6 potatoes, peeled, chopped small

4 cups broth, boil potatoes in it

1 onion, soft in 4 T butter

3 garlic cloves, 1 minute

1 cup mashed potato to thicken (but it wasn't enough)

2 T flour + water paste (put right in)

1 cup milk

salt to taste

pinch white pepper

1 handful cheese (NEW)

"Did I miss anything?" she asked.

Pop looked at her notes. He squinted. He turned the notebook upside down, then right side up.

"Looks right to me," he said.

"Really?"

"Really. When you cook without a recipe, you make it up as you go. The recipe changes every time. But this time, you wrote it down. So now we have a Pop's Potato Soup."

"It's Lily's Version," she corrected him.

Pop smiled. "Lily's Version," he said. "That's even better."

He took a big spoonful. Then he nodded.

"Yep. That's as good as it gets."


RECIPE CARD

Pop's Potato Soup (Lily's Version)

Makes: 4 bowls

Time: 45 minutes

What You Need:

• 6 medium potatoes, peeled and chopped into bite-size cubes

• 4 cups chicken broth

• 4 tablespoons butter (half a stick)

• 1 onion, finely diced

• 3 cloves garlic, minced

• 2 tablespoons flour + 2 tablespoons cold water (mixed into a paste)

• 1 cup milk

• Salt, to taste

• A pinch of white pepper (or regular pepper)

• 1 handful shredded cheddar cheese (this is Lily's addition!)

How to Make It:

  1. Put the potatoes in a big pot and pour in the broth. Bring to a boil, then turn down and simmer until the potatoes are soft, about 20 minutes.

  2. While the potatoes cook, melt the butter in a small pan. Add the onion and cook until soft and golden, about 5 minutes. Add the garlic and cook for 1 more minute.

  3. When the potatoes are soft, scoop out about 1 cup of them with a little broth. Mash them with a fork, then stir them back into the soup. This makes it a little thicker.

  4. Stir the onions and garlic into the soup.

  5. Mix the flour and water into a paste, then stir it into the soup. The soup will get creamy.

  6. Pour in the milk and stir.

  7. Taste! Add salt until it tastes good. Add the pinch of pepper.

  8. Sprinkle in the cheese and stir until it melts.

  9. Serve with grilled cheese sandwiches for dipping.

Lily's Tips: The flour paste is important! Don't just dump the flour in, or you'll get lumps. And the cheese is my idea—you can leave it out, but it's better with it. Trust me.