← Library

The Naughty Shelf

Rosies List

PART ONE — ELF SIDE

The Naughty Shelf Parliament was in emergency session.

"That's the third notebook this week," Fidget announced, pacing across the biscuit tin lid that served as the parliament floor. "Rosie is writing everything down."

Snatch twitched by the door. "Everything?"

"Everything." Fidget held up a tiny piece of paper he'd borrowed from the bin. On it, in Rosie's careful seven-year-old handwriting:

Tuesday: Lost sock. Found under sofa. Under SOFA. We looked there.

"Under the sofa," Cobweb repeated slowly. "She's noticing that we returned it."

"Returned it badly," Snatch muttered. "I told you the drop-off point was wrong."

"The drop-off point was fine—"

"The drop-off point was the middle of the floor, Fidget. Even a human notices a sock in the middle of the floor."

Thimble raised his hand. "But why did we return the sock at all?"

"Because it was Leo's favorite," Cobweb said. "And we are not monsters."

"Oh." Thimble considered this. "But why was it Leo's favorite? It had a hole in—"

"Stop." Fidget held up his hand. "The point is: Rosie is tracking us. Two months of observations. She's been keeping a list."

Cobweb sighed deeply. "She has her grandmother's eyes. That woman saw me once. 1998. She never said a word, but she knew. She left out crumbs."

"We need to see the list," Fidget decided. "Thimble, you're smallest. Tonight, after lights out. Borrow it, bring it back, return it before morning."

Thimble's eyes went wide. "My first mission?"

"Your only mission," Snatch corrected. "Don't drop it."

"I've never dropped—"

"You've never carried anything." Snatch's eye twitched.

"I won't drop it," Thimble said solemnly.


PART TWO — FAMILY SIDE

"Rosie, it's time for bed," Dad called up the stairs.

"One minute!" Rosie was sitting cross-legged on her bed, surrounded by notebooks. She had been keeping track for two months now. Small things. Weird things.

She read through her latest list:

Things That Don't Make Sense:

  1. The TV remote batteries drained in one night. We replaced them. That's not normal.

  2. The cookie jar was full at dinner and half-full at breakfast. NOBODY ate cookies.

  3. Mum's missing earring. Found back in her jewellery box, but the clasp was twisted. She says she must have "done it herself."

  4. The hallway light flickers exactly when Dad walks past. Every time. He says it's "a wiring issue."

  5. Leo talks to the air. Not imaginary friends. The air. He tells me "they're busy today." He won't explain who "they" are.

  6. The toaster made toast this morning. We didn't plug it in.

Rosie frowned. She added one more line, hesitated, then wrote in small letters:

  1. Elves?

She stared at the word. It looked silly. She almost crossed it out.

But she didn't.


That night, while the house slept, a tiny shadow crept across Rosie's floor. Thimble moved like a whisper, climbed the mountain of her duvet, and reached the notebook.

He read the list.

His hands trembled.

He carefully—so carefully—carried the notebook back to the Naughty Shelf.


PART THREE — ELF SIDE

The parliament read the list in silence.

Fidget read it twice. Then a third time.

"She's good," he said quietly. "She's really good."

"The batteries," Snatch said. "I told you we were overdrawing the grid. The kitchen needs to share the load."

"The toaster," Cobweb said, shaking her head. "That was Bindle's fault. He was trying to warm the meeting hall."

Thimble raised his hand. "What does 'elves?' mean? Why the question mark?"

Nobody answered.

Fidget stared at the final word. "She doesn't want to believe it," he said slowly. "That's what the question mark means. She's seen everything, but she still can't quite—"

"She's seven," Cobweb interrupted. "She's been taught that we don't exist. It takes more than evidence to unlearn that."

"So we're safe?" Thimble asked.

Fidget looked at the notebook. On the cover, Rosie had drawn a tiny sun and a tiny moon, side by side. She'd written her name in careful letters, with a heart over the 'i'.

"She's not a threat," he said. "She's a witness. There's a difference."

Cobweb made a sound that might have been approval.

"Return the notebook," Fidget decided. "Exactly where we found it. And Thimble?"

"Yes?"

"You did well. You didn't drop anything."

Thimble's chest swelled. "I have never dropped anything."

Snatch opened her mouth.

"Don't," Fidget warned.


The Next Morning

Rosie woke up, checked her nightstand, and found her notebook exactly where she left it.

She opened it to the last page. Her list. All seven items.

She stared at number seven.

Elves?

She laughed at herself, just a little. Then she closed the notebook and put it in her drawer.

But she didn't cross it out.

And somewhere behind the skirting board, a tiny parliament gavel banged, and a very small voice said:

"We're going to need to be more careful."