What Comes Out the End
What Felix Would Have Charged
June sat on the tall stool in Uncle Felix's workshop, her yellow notebook open on her lap. She was drawing a picture of the unscrambler — the big machine on Line 2 that spun bottles around until they stood up straight.
"Uncle Felix," she said. "How much do you think the manufacturer would charge for what you did?"
Felix looked up from his workbench. He was cleaning a small metal part with a rag. "What do you mean?"
June tapped her pencil. "You made the unscrambler do way more bottles. You added the second ramp inside. You added the air jets that push wrong-way bottles out early. If the machine company sold a machine that could do that, it would cost a lot of money, right?"
Felix set the part down. "I suppose it would."
"So," June said, "if the manufacturer could have hired you and gotten the information — how much is it worth?"
Felix smiled. He pulled his Output Log off the shelf and opened it to a new page.
"Let's find out," he said.
They walked out to Line 2. The unscrambler was humming. Bottles tumbled in, rolled down the ramps, and stood up straight on the conveyor. Pop. Pop. Pop. Each one landed exactly where it should.
June pulled out her stopwatch. She counted for one minute.
"One hundred and twenty bottles," she said. "That's the after number."
"Good," said Felix. "And what was the before number?"
June flipped back in her notebook. "Fifty bottles per minute. That was before you added the second ramp and the air jets."
Felix nodded. "So we went from fifty to one hundred twenty. That's seventy more bottles every minute. How many minutes does the line run?"
June calculated. "Eight hours a day. That's four hundred eighty minutes. Times seventy..."
"Take your time," Felix said.
June wrote it down. "Thirty-three thousand six hundred more bottles per day."
"And how many days a year does Line 2 run?"
"Two hundred fifty," June said. She multiplied. "Eight million four hundred thousand more bottles per year."
She looked up. Her eyes were wide.
Felix leaned against the machine. "Now. A machine that could do that — what would the manufacturer charge for it?"
June knew about machines. She'd been visiting Felix for years. "A new machine costs a lot. Maybe... a hundred thousand dollars?"
"If they could even build it," Felix said. "Their expert said the machine would never do more than eighty bottles a minute. So they couldn't sell you that machine. They couldn't build it."
"So what you did — the information — it's worth more than a hundred thousand dollars," June said slowly. She wrote the number in her notebook. "You could have charged them for it. If they hired you, you could have told them how you did it."
Felix was quiet for a moment. Then he reached into his coverall pocket and pulled out his Output Log. He opened it and pointed to his own handwriting.
"June," he said, "I've been keeping this log for thirty years."
She looked at the pages. Entry after entry. Machine after machine. Before numbers and after numbers. The variable he'd changed. The result.
"Look at the oldest ones," Felix said.
June flipped near the front. The paper was yellow and soft. The ink was faded.
"1988 — Conveyor jam. Ten years of stopping every hour. Fix: changed the belt tension and added a guide rail. Result: no jams for six months."
"1992 — Filler valve. Two valves stuck open. Fix: cleaned them, changed the spring. Result: zero waste."
"1997 — Labeler. Labels peeling. Fix: adjusted the glue temperature. Result: no more peeled labels."
June looked up. "These are small problems."
"Every one of them was a problem someone gave me," Felix said. "The manufacturer didn't give me those. The plant manager didn't give me those. The machine operator — Oliver — he told me about the conveyor jam. He'd been watching it for years. He just didn't know he could fix it."
Felix tapped the log. "Every entry is a problem I got to solve. I got paid in problems to solve. That's a good deal for me."
June thought about that. She looked at her own notebook — her "Kept Count." She'd been writing down numbers all summer. Bottles per minute. Rejected bottles per hour. Jams per shift.
She wrote a new entry at the bottom of her page:
What Felix would have charged for the unscrambler fix: $100,000 (maybe more).
What Felix got paid: the problem to solve.
His opinion: he got the better end.
She read it out loud. Then she added one more line.
I think he's right. The problem is the best part.
Felix smiled. "Now," he said. "There's a machine on Line 3 that's been dropping caps. I don't know why yet. You want to come count with me?"
June grabbed her stopwatch and hopped off the stool.
"The kept count is going up," she said.
"It always does," said Felix. "When you count what comes out the end."