One Sock
The Bone Library
I am standing at the entrance to the Bone Library, and I am very excited.
"Look at this place, Penny!" I say, hopping forward. "All these bones! Arranged in... in..."
I trail off.
The bones are everywhere. Big bones. Small bones. Bones that look like twigs and bones that look like weapons. They are arranged in piles, in lines, in spirals, in patterns that loop around each other and then stop suddenly, like a sentence that forgot how to end.
"It's a mess," Penny says.
"It's not a mess!" I say. "It's organized. I can feel it. Biscuit knows exactly where everything is."
Biscuit is the Dog. He is enormous and friendly and does not notice me at all. But he carries me places, which is helpful. Right now, he is asleep on his bed, and we are standing on the edge of that bed, looking at what Biscuit has buried and retrieved.
I have never seen so many bones in my life.
"This is his collection," I say. "His library. Every bone he has ever loved, saved and sorted."
Penny looks at the nearest pile. It is a pile of small, knobbly bones, all pointing in different directions, like a map of somewhere that does not exist.
"Sorted how?" she asks.
I have no idea.
We start exploring.
The Bone Library is divided into sections. I know this because I can see it. There is a long bone leaning against a short bone. There is a round bone sitting inside the curve of a bigger bone. There is a bone with a bite mark on it resting on top of a bone without a bite mark.
"These are all chew toys," I say. "Not food bones. Chew toys. Biscuit separates them by type."
Penny looks at the bite-mark bone. Then at the no-bite-mark bone.
"Those are both chew toys," she says.
"Yes, but one is a successful chew toy and one is a failed chew toy," I say. "Biscuit knows the difference."
"How do you know that?"
I pause.
"I don't know," I admit. "But it makes sense. Look at how they're arranged!"
The successful chew toy is on top of a small mound of shredded fabric. The failed chew toy is on flat ground, slightly apart, like it was put in timeout.
"Interesting," Penny says. She does not sound like she means it.
We move deeper into the Library.
There is a section of bones arranged by size. Small bones to big bones, in a perfect line. This makes sense to me.
Then there is a section where the bones are arranged by color. Which is strange, because bones are mostly white. But some are yellower than others, and Biscuit has put all the yellow bones together.
"Biscuit sorted his bones by how yellow they are," I say. "That's incredible."
"Or they're all just yellow," Penny says.
"Nothing is 'just' anything, Penny," I say.
Penny makes a sound like a penny being dropped in frustration.
Then we find the section that does not make sense at all.
There is a bone. It is a good bone. It is round and smooth and has been chewed exactly enough.
And it is balanced on top of another bone, which is balanced on top of another bone, in a tower that reaches all the way up to the edge of the dog bed.
"That's not sorting," Penny says. "That's stacking."
"Stacking is sorting," I say. "It's sorting in a vertical direction."
"Biscuit built a tower out of bones."
"Yes," I say. "A library tower. To reach the books on the top shelf. Except the books are bones and the shelf is... more bones."
I look at the tower again.
It is a good tower. It wobbles slightly when Biscuit breathes.
"I don't understand this," Penny says.
I do not understand this either. But I feel like I should.
I walk around the tower. I look at it from all angles. I count the bones.
Sixteen bones, stacked in a pattern that is not quite regular but is definitely deliberate. The biggest bone is at the bottom. The smallest bones are in the middle, wedged together like they are holding hands. The top bone is curved, like a roof.
"It's a house," I say suddenly.
"What?"
"It's a house. Biscuit built a house out of bones. The big bone is the floor. The middle bones are the walls. The curved bone is the roof."
Penny looks at it.
"It's a house that no dog could fit inside," she says.
"It's not for Biscuit," I say. "It's for something smaller."
I look at the house. I look at the bone on the floor next to it. Then I look at the bone on the floor on the other side of it.
Two bones, one on each side of the house. Like guard posts. Or like doors.
"The house has two doors," I say. "One for coming in. One for going out."
"Why would a house made of bones have two doors?"
"Because Biscuit wants things to move through it," I say. "He wants the house to be part of the world, not separate from it."
Penny is quiet for a long moment.
"Left," she says, "you are making up meanings that are not there."
"Maybe," I say. "But maybe not. Look at the bones. Really look."
She looks.
The bones are arranged like a meeting place. The tower house in the middle. The two watcher bones at the sides. And behind them, a semi-circle of smaller bones, like an audience.
"It's a stage," I say. "Biscuit built a stage. For telling stories."
"A dog built a theater out of bones."
"Biscuit is a very artistic dog."
Penny does not agree. But she stops arguing.
We sit for a moment in the middle of the Bone Library, surrounded by Biscuit's collection. The bones catch the light from the window. They are white and yellow and warm. They are organized in a way that only Biscuit understands.
I do not understand it.
But I am starting to feel like I don't need to.
"Penny," I say, "I think I've been wrong about something."
"What?"
"The Bone Library isn't for me to understand," I say. "It's for Biscuit. It's his map. His memory. Every bone is a place he's been. Every bone is a story he's told."
"Then why are we here?"
I look at the bones. The towers. The lines. The patterns that almost make sense.
"We're here to learn that not everything needs to make sense to us," I say. "Some things just need to make sense to the person who made them."
Penny is quiet.
"You're going to say something nice now," I say.
"I was going to say that the bones look like a mess and a half," she says.
"But you were also going to say something nice."
She sighs.
"The house bone is nice," she says. "It's a good house shape."
"Thank you, Penny."
We sit a little longer.
Then I see it.
In the middle of the Library, between the tower house and the failed chew toy, there is a small clearing. And in the middle of the clearing, there is a single bone.
It is not a chew bone. It is not a food bone.
It is a sock bone.
I hop over to it.
It is not a sock. It is a bone shaped like a sock. Or maybe it is just a bone that Biscuit chewed into a strange shape. But it looks like a sock. A red-and-white-striped sock.
"Penny," I say.
"What?"
"Look at this."
She looks.
"That's a bone shaped like a sock," she says.
"It's a sign," I say.
"It's a coincidence."
"It's a sign," I say again. "Biscuit has seen a sock. Biscuit has chewed a sock. Biscuit knows where the socks go."
I pick up the sock-shaped bone. It is light. It is warm.
"This is my evidence," I say. "My clue. My breadcrumb."
Penny sighs. "You are going to follow a bone's advice."
"I am going to follow a bone's memory," I say.
And I hop forward, out of the Bone Library, clutching the sock-shaped bone in my stripes.
I am one step closer to Right.
And the Bone Library glows behind me, beautiful and strange, organized in a way only Biscuit understands.
I do not understand it.
But I love it.