← Library

Professor Plunks Impossible Lab

The Floating Fiasco

The Floating Fiasco
  1. The Impossible Boat

Professor Plunk burst through the lab door at 7:43 on Tuesday morning, which was exactly forty-three minutes before Otto usually arrived. She was carrying something large and grey and very heavy.

"OTTO!" she bellowed, even though she was the only one there. "OTTO, WHERE ARE YOU?"

Otto emerged from behind the coat rack, where he had been hanging his lab coat. "I'm right here, Professor. It's before eight o'clock."

"PERFECT!" Plunk slammed the grey object onto the workbench, where it landed with a clang that rattled the beakers. "Because we have an IMPOSSIBLE task today!"

Otto opened his notebook to a fresh page. He wrote at the top, very neatly:

Tuesday Morning. Professor Plunk has brought something to the lab. It might be a boat.

"What is it?" he asked.

Plunk threw her arms wide. "It's an IRON BOAT! And I'm going to prove that it will FLOAT!"

Otto looked at the iron boat. It was about the size of a bathtub, with high sides and a pointed front. It looked like it weighed as much as a small car.

"An iron boat," Otto said slowly. "Floating."

"FLOATING!" Plunk confirmed.

"Professor, iron sinks. Everyone knows that. You drop an iron nail in water, it goes straight to the bottom."

"AH!" Plunk pointed at him like he'd said something brilliant. "But does it? Does it really? Or does it just seem that way?"

Otto wrote in his notebook:

Prediction: The iron boat will sink. The professor says otherwise. I am concerned.

Plunk was already dragging a large glass tank across the lab floor. It was the size of a dining table, and Gloriana had to move her mop bucket three times to get out of the way.

"Gloriana! Fill this tank with water, please! The IMPOSSIBLE experiment requires an OCEAN!"

Gloriana looked at the tank. She looked at Plunk. She looked at the iron boat.

"Told her so," she said, and went to get the hose.


  1. Shape Matters

By the time the tank was full, Otto had drawn a diagram in his notebook. It showed an iron nail falling to the bottom of a lake, with a big question mark next to it.

"Now then!" Plunk rolled up her sleeves. "Let's discuss DENSITY!"

She grabbed a piece of chalk and sketched on the blackboard. "Density is how much stuff is packed into a space. Iron is very dense — its atoms are packed together tightly. Water is less dense — its atoms have more breathing room."

"Right," Otto said. "So iron sinks."

"Because of the SHAPE!" Plunk said happily.

Otto frowned. "Shape? But you just said density—"

"Density tells you whether a material CAN float," Plunk explained. "Shape tells you whether it WILL float. Watch this!"

She picked up a heavy iron weight from the shelf. It was a solid cube the size of Otto's fist. "This is an iron demonstration weight. What happens if I drop it in the tank?"

"It sinks," Otto said.

"EXACTLY! And this," Plunk held up a thin iron sheet the same size, "is the same amount of iron, flattened out. If I lay it flat on the water—"

She placed the sheet carefully on the surface. It shivered for a moment, then sank.

"Ah. Well, that's too flat," Plunk said. "But if I shape it like a bowl—"

She pressed the sheet into a shallow dish and placed it on the water. It floated, rocking gently.

Otto leaned closer. "It's floating! But it's the same iron!"

"YES!" Plunk was practically glowing. "Because the bowl shape pushes water out of the way — it DISPLACES water! And displaced water pushes back!"

Otto wrote furiously:

IMPORTANT: The bowl pushes water aside. The water pushes back. They push each other!

"Here's the secret," Plunk said, kneeling down so she was eye-level with the tank. "An object floats when it pushes aside water that weighs as much as the object. If the object weighs less than the water it pushes aside, it FLOATS. If it weighs more, it SINKS."

"So the bowl pushes aside enough water to match its weight," Otto said slowly. "But the solid cube pushes aside only a little water — its size! — and that water weighs less than the cube, so it sinks."

"YOU ARE A GENIUS," Plunk declared. "Now let's test the boat!"


  1. The Launch

They placed the iron boat in the water with great ceremony. Plunk held one side. Otto held the other. Gloriana stood back with her tool belt, watching calmly.

"On three," Plunk said. "One... two... THREE!"

They lowered the boat into the tank. Water sloshed up over the sides, then settled. The boat sat on the surface, bobbing gently.

It floated.

"IT FLOATS!" Otto shouted.

"OF COURSE IT FLOATS!" Plunk shouted back. "The boat is heavy, but its SHAPE makes it push aside a huge amount of water — way more than the weight of the iron! The displaced water pushes back with enough force to hold the whole boat up!"

Otto drew the boat in his notebook, with little arrows pointing up from the water. Next to it he wrote:

Upward push = weight of displaced water. Boat floats! The shape is the secret.

"Now for the REAL demonstration!" Plunk climbed onto a stool. "I shall sit in the boat and show that it can carry weight!"

"Professor, I don't think—"

But Plunk was already lowering herself into the iron boat. It sank a little deeper, pushing aside more water, but kept floating.

"I WEIGH THE BOAT DOWN! MORE DISPLACEMENT!" Plunk crowed. "The water pushes back even harder! THIS IS MAGNIFICENT!"

Otto had to admit: it was magnificent. The boat sat low in the water, but it floated. The physics worked exactly as Plunk had explained.

"So the boat floats because of its shape," he said, writing it down. "Even though iron is denser than water."

"EXACTLY!" Plunk said. "And now for the final test — I shall demonstrate that NOTHING in this lab can resist the principles of buoyancy. I'll step out, grab the iron weight, and place it in the boat. Together, they will—"

She stepped out of the boat.

Her iron-soled boots hit the bottom of the tank.

CLUNK.

"Professor," Otto said.

Plunk looked down. Her boots were stuck to the iron floor of the tank. She lifted one foot — it came free with a sucking sound — but as she lifted it, she lost her balance.

In slow motion, Plunk fell backward.

She grabbed for the only thing within reach.

The iron demonstration weight.

She toppled off the stool, right into the tank.

SPLASH!

The tank erupted. Water went everywhere — across the chalkboard, across the workbench, across Otto's notebook, which he saved at the last second by diving under the table.

And at the bottom of the tank, two iron-soled boots and one iron demonstration weight lay side by side with the iron sheet, all of them sunk.

Otto surfaced from under the table, holding his notebook high above his head. He wrote:

THIS WAS NOT IN THE PLAN. The boots sink because they are solid. The weight sinks because it is solid. The BOAT floats because it is HOLLOW. The professor is at the bottom of the tank.

Plunk stood up in the tank. Water poured off her lab coat. Her goggles had somehow stayed on her forehead. She looked at the boat, still bobbing gently at the surface.

Then she looked at her boots.

Then she looked at the weight.

"WELL!" she said, water streaming from her hair. "That demonstrated buoyancy rather more vividly than I intended!"


  1. Why Things Float

Gloriana arrived with a long-handled net. She fished out Plunk's boots, the demonstration weight, and the iron sheet, setting each on the floor with a heavy clang.

"Need these?" she asked, pulling a towel from her tool belt.

"Thank you, Gloriana!" Plunk wrapped the towel around her shoulders. "Now then, Otto! This is the PERFECT lesson! What did we just learn?"

Otto looked at his soggy notebook. "The boat floats because its shape pushes aside enough water to match its weight. The boots and the weight sank because they're solid — they don't push aside enough water, so the water pushes back with less force than they weigh."

"EXACTLY!" Plunk beamed. "Density tells us whether a material can float in water. Iron is denser than water, so iron alone sinks. But shape changes everything! A hollow iron boat pushes aside water that weighs MORE than the boat — so the water's upward push holds the boat up!"

Otto wrote:

Rule 1: Objects float when they displace water equal to their weight.

Rule 2: Density determines whether something sinks or floats.

Rule 3: Shape can make a dense material float! (The boat!) Or sink. (The boots.)

"Wait," Otto said suddenly. "If I make a hollow iron ball — big enough — would it float?"

"YES!" Plunk said. "Try it! The bigger the hollow space, the more water the ball pushes aside, the more upward push it gets!"

Otto ran to the supply shelf and grabbed a small iron ball with a hollow centre. He dropped it in the tank. It floated.

"If I put a tiny hole in it—"

He poked the ball with a nail. Water bubbled inside. Slowly, the ball sank.

"THE WATER GOT INTO THE HOLLOW SPACE!" Otto shouted. "Now the ball pushes aside the same amount of water, but it WEIGHS MORE because it's full of water! So it sinks!"

"You are a natural physicist!" Plunk said proudly.

Otto stared at the boat, still bobbing on the surface. "So the boat floats because it pushes aside water that weighs more than the boat. And the water pushes back with that much force."

"Perfectly said, my careful colleague."

Otto looked at the iron-soled boots. They were solid, except for the small hole where a foot went in — but once underwater, the hole filled with water, making the boot weigh more than the water it displaced.

"They look like boats," Otto said. "But they're not shaped like boats."

"THEY'RE SHAPED LIKE BOOTS!" Plunk laughed. "And boots are very bad at being boats!"


  1. The Wonder of Water

The sun came through the lab windows, making the water in the tank sparkle. Otto stood on his toes, looking at the iron boat floating at the surface.

"Professor?"

"Yes?"

"The boat floats because of the water, right? The water is what pushes it up?"

"Exactly right."

Otto thought about this. "So the water is really strong. Strong enough to hold up iron."

"Water can hold up a SHIP, Otto. A ship made of steel, with thousands of tons of cargo, floating across the ocean. Because of exactly what you just learned — displacement and density and shape."

Otto wrote in his notebook, very carefully:

Water is amazing. It holds up iron boats because of shape. It holds up me when I swim. It holds up everything that can learn the trick of pushing it aside.

He looked at the boat again.

"I want to build one," he said.

"BUILD ONE!" Plunk shouted. "We'll build a FLEET!"

"Maybe one boat first," Otto said.

"ONE BOAT! AND THEN A FLEET!"

Gloriana appeared at Otto's elbow with a stack of towels. She handed him one without a word.

"Thanks, Gloriana," Otto said.

Gloriana looked at the tank. She looked at the boat. She looked at Otto, still dripping water, but grinning from ear to ear.

"Good lesson," she said.

Then she went back to mopping.

Otto turned to a clean page in his notebook and began sketching his own boat design. At the top, he wrote:

MY FIRST BOAT. I will make it hollow. I will make it float. I will not test it with my boots on.