The Naughty Shelf
The Rosie Incident
PART ONE — ELF SIDE
The Naughty Shelf Parliament was in emergency session. Fidget stood on the biscuit tin podium, gavel in hand, trying very hard to look calm.
"Here is what we know," he announced. "Rosie almost saw Snatch."
The chamber erupted. Forty elves began talking at once.
Thimble raised his hand. "What does 'almost saw' mean exactly?"
"It means Snatch was in the hallway," Fidget explained, "and Rosie turned the corner, and if Snatch had been in the hallway at that moment, Rosie would have seen her."
"But she wasn't," said Thimble.
"She WAS," said Fidget. "That's the problem."
Sixteen minutes earlier, Snatch had been on a routine Borrowing Operation: retrieve the blue button that had fallen behind the radiator. The button was needed for the museum's new display. Everything was going perfectly.
Then Rosie appeared.
Snatch froze. One hand on the button, one foot on the skirting board, heart hammering. Rosie was seven steps away. Rosie was looking directly at her.
And then Snatch held completely still.
The elf record for stillness was six minutes, held by Fidget. Snatch had never managed more than two. Standing still made her twitch. But now—now her life depended on it.
Rosie blinked.
In the hallway, the light was dim. There was a shadow near the radiator, a shape that could have been a toy or a shoe or something else entirely. Rosie tilted her head.
Snatch did not breathe.
Rosie took a step closer.
In the parliament chamber, Thimble was vibrating with anxiety. "What if she sees—"
"She won't," said Cobweb, from her comfortable chair. "Snatch is small. The shadows are long. Children believe what they expect to see."
"Four minutes," Fidget reported. "She's still looking."
Four minutes and fifteen seconds. Rosie frowned at the shadow. It looked like a toy, but she didn't remember leaving a toy there. It looked like a shoe, but the wrong color. It looked like—
Her brain, being seven years old and full of homework, supplied the answer: It's nothing. Move on.
But she didn't move on. She stared.
Four minutes and thirty seconds. Snatch's leg was cramping. Her fingers ached around the button. Her lungs were burning from the effort of not breathing.
Four minutes and thirty-five seconds.
Rosie squinted. There was something weird about that shadow, something that didn't quite make sense, something her eyes kept sliding off—
Four minutes and forty seconds.
Rosie shrugged. "Probably a sock," she said, and walked away.
PART TWO — FAMILY SIDE
That evening, Rosie mentioned it at dinner.
"There's a weird shadow in the hallway," she said.
Phil perked up. "A shadow? Interesting. That could be evidence of a draft coming through the skirting boards, causing a temperature differential that—"
"It looked like a toy," Rosie said. "But I didn't recognize it."
Phil nodded sagely. "The light in that hallway is notoriously unreliable. The angle of the sun through the window, combined with the reflective surface of the radiator, creates what we in scientific circles call 'a shadow that looks like something.'"
Kate raised an eyebrow. "We in scientific circles?"
"I'm taking a course," said Phil.
Leo, aged four, looked up from his peas. "It was an elf."
Everyone ignored him.
"An elf?" Phil chuckled. "Now that's a hypothesis. Can you test it, Rosie? Can you find evidence?"
"I guess not," said Rosie. "It was probably just a shadow."
"Exactly!" Phil beamed. "Science works."
Later that night, Rosie lay in bed, staring at the ceiling. The shadow had looked like a toy. But toys didn't move. And she was almost sure—almost—that she'd seen the shadow breathe.
Of course, shadows couldn't breathe. That was silly.
Probably.
She reached for her nightlight and turned it on.
Just in case.
PART THREE — ELF SIDE
Back on the Naughty Shelf, Snatch was debriefing. Actually, she was pacing, which was her version of debriefing.
"I was this close," she said. "This close. She looked at me. She LOOKED at me."
"Through a shadow," said Fidget. "And she saw nothing."
"I held still for four minutes and forty seconds." Snatch stopped pacing. "I didn't know I could do that."
Fidget nodded seriously. "You beat my record by thirty seconds. I'm not sure how I feel about that."
"Proud," said Cobweb. "The correct feeling is proud."
Thimble raised his hand. "Why did she walk away?"
Cobweb smiled—a rare event. "Because, child, humans see what they expect to see. Rosie expected to see a shadow. So she saw a shadow."
"And the button?" asked Fidget.
Snatch opened her hand. The blue button gleamed in the lamplight. "I never dropped it."
Thimble looked at the button, then at Snatch, then at the hallway beyond. "What if she starts expecting to see an elf?"
The chamber went silent.
Cobweb's ancient eyes narrowed. "Then," she said slowly, "we will have a problem."
Fidget squared his shoulders. "Then we will adapt. We always adapt."
But that night, as the colony settled into sleep, Snatch stayed awake, staring at the hallway.
Four minutes and forty seconds.
A new record.
And also, perhaps, a countdown.
To be continued in Book 21: The Curious Case of Leo's Drawings.