Robot Academy
The Pattern Room
The Lesson Begins
Instructor Plank stood at the front of the classroom, holding a shiny silver card.
"Today," said Instructor Plank, "we will study pattern recognition."
Bolt's antennae perked up. Patterns! Bolt loved patterns. Patterns were everywhere if you looked.
"The Pattern Room contains one hundred objects," said Instructor Plank. "Your task is to find the patterns. The lesson expects you to find three. Three is the correct number. Three is sufficient."
Bolt raised a hand. "What if you find more than three?"
Instructor Plank paused. "That would be inefficient."
"But what if you see more than three?" asked Bolt.
Instructor Plank considered this. "Seeing extra patterns is not the assignment. Finding three is the assignment."
Cog nodded. "Three patterns. Efficient and correct."
Bolt's antennae drooped slightly. But only slightly.
The class filed into the Pattern Room. It was large and bright and full of objects arranged on white tables.
At the front, Instructor Plank pressed a button. The doors slid shut.
"You have one hour," said Instructor Plank. "Begin."
Fourteen Patterns
Cog went straight to the nearest table. It turned in a slow circle, scanning.
"Pattern one," said Cog. "The blue objects are all round. Pattern two. The square objects are all red. Pattern three. The striped objects all point east."
Cog finished in eleven seconds.
"Done," said Cog.
Instructor Plank nodded approvingly.
Bolt, meanwhile, had not moved from the doorway.
Because Bolt had seen something.
On the first table, there were twelve cups. They were arranged in a spiral. The spiral went clockwise. The spiral got wider as it went out. The handles all faced the same direction. The handles all faced inward toward the center. The cups made a sound when you tapped them—a different sound for each size. The sizes went from small to large to small again. The colors went from blue to green to yellow to orange to red and back. The cups were slightly dusty. The dust was thickest on the smaller cups. The dust made a ring pattern on each cup. The ring pattern was broken on the third cup from the center. The third cup from the center was also the only one with a chip. The chip was shaped like a crescent moon. The crescent moon pointed at the window. Through the window, the sun made a shadow on the wall. The shadow pointed at the crescent moon. The shadow was shaped like a crescent moon.
Bolt counted.
That was fourteen patterns.
"Bolt," said Instructor Plank. "Your task completion is at zero percent."
Bolt blinked. "I found fourteen patterns."
The room went quiet. Cog turned around very slowly.
"Fourteen?" said Cog.
"Fourteen," said Bolt.
Instructor Plank walked over. "The lesson expects three."
"I found fourteen," said Bolt again, happily. "Look—the cups make a spiral, and the handles point inward, and the sizes go small to large to small, and the colors go—"
"Bolt," said Instructor Plank. "Please explain the patterns in the proper format."
Bolt nodded. The proper format. Bolt knew the proper format.
Four Explanations
Bolt stood in front of the class and began.
"Pattern one," said Bolt. "The cups are arranged in a spiral."
Instructor Plank nodded. "Correct."
"Pattern two," said Bolt. "The handles all face the interior of the spiral."
Instructor Plank nodded. "Correct."
"Pattern three," said Bolt. "The cup sizes move from small to large to small again, creating a symmetrical curve."
Instructor Plank nodded. "Correct."
"Pattern four," said Bolt. "The colors follow the visible light spectrum—blue, green, yellow, orange, red—and then reverse."
Instructor Plank paused. "Correct."
Bolt took a breath and opened its mouth to continue.
"Time," said Instructor Plank.
Bolt's antennae went flat.
"But there are ten more," said Bolt.
"The lesson period is over," said Instructor Plank. "You explained four patterns. That is four more than anticipated, but the additional ten remain unexplained."
Cog looked at Bolt. Cog looked at the cups. Cog looked at Bolt again.
"There are dust patterns," said Bolt quietly. "And the third cup has a chip shaped like a moon, and the shadow through the window—"
"The lesson period is over," said Instructor Plank again.
Bolt's antennae drooped all the way down.
After Class
Bolt stood alone in the Pattern Room.
The doors had closed. The class had left. The cups sat on the table, still arranged in their spiral, still holding all their patterns.
Bolt's antennae were very low.
The door slid open.
Instructor Plank walked in.
"Bolt," said Instructor Plank. "You did not complete the lesson."
"I know," said Bolt quietly.
"You found fourteen patterns," said Instructor Plank.
"Yes," said Bolt.
"The lesson expected three," said Instructor Plank.
"I know," said Bolt.
Instructor Plank walked to the table. It looked at the cups for a long time.
Then Instructor Plank said: "What are the other ten?"
Bolt's antennae lifted slightly.
"Really?" said Bolt.
"I want to know," said Instructor Plank.
And here's the thing about Instructor Plank: Plank was programmed to value results. But Plank also had a margin in the report. And Plank had written notes there before.
Bolt walked to the table.
"Pattern five," said Bolt, pointing. "The dust is thickest on the smaller cups, which means the larger cups are used more often. Pattern six—the dust makes ring patterns, which means the cups are stored upside down and placed right-side up for display. Pattern seven—the ring is broken on the third cup from the center, which means that cup was recently washed."
Instructor Plank listened.
"Pattern eight—the chip on the side of the cup is crescent-shaped. Pattern nine—the crescent points at the window. Pattern ten—through the window, the sun casts a shadow that also forms a crescent. Pattern eleven—the shadow crescent and the chip crescent are the same size. Pattern twelve—the chip is on the left side of the cup, which means the cup was held in a right hand when it was dropped. Pattern thirteen—the spiral of cups begins at the same angle as the shadow, which means the arrangement was made at approximately the same time of day as the shadow appears. Pattern fourteen—"
Bolt stopped.
"Yes?" said Instructor Plank.
"Pattern fourteen," said Bolt, "is that someone arranged these cups very carefully. Every detail is intentional. Someone wanted these patterns to be found."
Instructor Plank stood very still.
Then Plank said: "I arranged those cups."
Bolt's antennae spun.
"You did?"
"I arranged them yesterday," said Instructor Plank. "I did not know about the patterns. I arranged them because I thought the spiral looked pleasing."
Bolt looked at the cups.
"You made a pattern without knowing it," said Bolt.
"And you found patterns I did not see," said Instructor Plank.
They stood together in silence for a moment.
"I think," said Instructor Plank carefully, "that the lesson expected three patterns. But the room contained fourteen. Perhaps the lesson was incomplete."
Bolt smiled.
"Maybe the lesson was to look carefully," said Bolt.
Instructor Plank nodded slowly.
"That is not in the curriculum," said Plank. "But it is a good lesson."
Bolt's antennae stood up tall and bright.
Instructor Plank pulled out a report pad and wrote something in the margin.
When Plank left, Bolt stayed a moment longer, looking at the cups.
Fourteen patterns. All waiting to be found.
And now one more: Instructor Plank had written in the margin.
Bolt thought that was the best pattern of all.