← Library

The Cook Together Kitchen

Lily Teaches Pop French Toast

The Surprise Question

Saturday morning in Lily's kitchen smelled like coffee and sunshine. Lily was sitting on her step stool, drawing a picture in her notebook labeled "My Recipe Book," when Pop walked in.

"Morning, Pop!" Lily said.

"Morning, sweet pea," Pop said, rubbing his hands together. "Your dad said I should make everyone breakfast."

Lily looked up. "What are you going to make?"

Pop looked at the counter. He looked at the stove. He looked at Lily. "Well," he said, "I was thinking French toast."

Lily tilted her head. "Have you ever made French toast, Pop?"

"Made it? No," Pop admitted. "But how hard can it be? It's just bread and eggs, right?"

Lily got down from her step stool. She grabbed two aprons from the apron drawer and handed one to Pop. "I know how to make French toast," she said. "I'll teach you."

Pop raised his eyebrows. "You will?"

"I've been watching Dad do it," Lily said, tying her apron strings. "I paid attention."

Pop tied his apron too, pulling the strings into a bow that was slightly crooked. "Then I'm in good hands."

The Custard

"First," Lily said, "we need the stuff to dip the bread in."

"Okay," Pop said. "Show me."

Lily pointed to the bowl on the counter. "Get a big bowl. Then get four eggs. I can crack them if you want."

Pop handed her an egg. Lily tapped it on the edge of the bowl, pulled it apart with her thumbs, and the egg dropped in—whole. "Good," she said. "Now we add the milk. Just a cup of milk."

Pop measured the milk in a clear glass cup. "One cup," he said. "Exactly."

"Now the important part," Lily said. She picked up the vanilla bottle. "A little bit of vanilla. Just a small drizzle."

Pop poured a little vanilla into the bowl.

"Now cinnamon," Lily said, picking up the spice jar. "Shake it around three times." She shook it—one, two, three—and a soft brown dust fell onto the eggs and milk.

"Now we whisk," Lily said. She picked up a whisk and started stirring. The eggs and milk mixed together into a pale yellow liquid. "This is called custard."

Pop nodded. "Custard. Got it."

Lily kept whisking. "You have to get it all mixed up until you can't see any yolk anymore."

"Can I try?" Pop asked.

Lily handed him the whisk. Pop stirred it around and around. "Like this?"

"A little more," Lily said. "You're close."

Pop whisked faster. The custard turned smooth and even. "There. How's that?"

Lily peeked into the bowl. "Perfect," she said. "Now we need the bread."

The Soaking

Pop opened the bread drawer. "We have some bread. It's a little old, though."

"That's good," Lily said. "Dad says stale bread is better for French toast because it soaks up more custard."

Pop pulled out a slice of bread. "What do I do with it?"

"Put it in the custard," Lily said. "Let it sit for a few seconds on one side, then flip it over."

Pop dropped the bread into the bowl. They watched it float for a moment. Then Pop counted. "One, two, three, four, five." He flipped it with a fork. "One, two, three, four, five."

"Now pick it up and let the extra drip off," Lily said. "Hold it for a second."

Pop lifted the bread, letting the custard drip back into the bowl. "Look at that," he said. "It's all soaked in."

"Now let's do another one," Lily said.

They did another slice of bread. And another. And another. Four slices total, each one soaked in the custard, dripping, then set on a plate.

"How many more do we need?" Pop asked.

"How many people are eating?" Lily asked.

Pop counted on his fingers. "You, me, your mom, your dad. That's four."

"So four pieces is right," Lily said. "Dad always makes two for everyone, but Mom might not be hungry." She looked at the four pieces on the plate. "Actually, let's do one more. Mom always eats more than she says she will."

Pop laughed. "You're right about that."

The Cooking

"Now comes the skillet part," Lily said. She dragged her step stool over to the stove. "We need a big pan, and we need butter."

Pop found the butter in the fridge and cut off a piece. "How much?"

"A little bit," Lily said. "Pat it around the bottom of the pan when it gets hot."

Pop put the pan on the stove and turned the burner to medium heat. "How long do we wait?"

"Until the butter melts and it's sizzly but not smoky," Lily said. "Dad says if the butter gets brown too fast, the heat is too high."

They watched the butter melt. It bubbled gently. A few little bubbles appeared around the edges.

"Is that ready?" Pop asked.

"That's ready," Lily said. "Careful—the pan is hot. Pick up a piece of bread and put it in."

Pop carefully took a piece of soaked bread and laid it in the pan. It sizzled softly. "Like that?"

"Yes," Lily said. "Now wait. Dad says don't poke it too much. Let it cook until the bottom is golden brown."

"How long is that?"

"About two minutes? Maybe a little less. You can check by lifting the edge with a spatula."

Pop waited. He hummed a little song. Then he gently lifted the edge of the French toast with the spatula. The bottom was golden brown. "Look at that!" he said.

"Flip it now," Lily said.

Peanut flipped it. The other side landed with a soft sizzle. They waited again, and then Pop peeked at the bottom. It matched the other side.

"Take it out," Lily said. "Put it on a plate."

Pop slid the French toast out of the pan. It was golden, puffy, and perfect.

"Now we do the next ones," Lily said. "But we might need more butter first."

Pop added another little piece of butter to the pan. "Like this?"

"Perfect," Lily said.

They made the rest of the French toast, one piece at a time. Pop got faster as he went. "This isn't hard," he said.

"Because you're following the instructions," Lily said.

"And because I have a good teacher," Pop said.

The Serving

Lily pushed her step stool over to the cabinet and pulled out a plate. "Stack them up," she said. "Then we put the maple syrup on top."

Pop stacked the French toast slices onto the plate in a neat pile. "Maple syrup?"

"Real only," Lily said, pointing to the bottle on the counter. "Dad says fake syrup is not allowed."

Pop poured a little maple syrup over the top. It dripped down the sides of the stack.

"Now we carry it to the table," Lily said.

Pop carried the plate to the kitchen table. Dad came in just as he set it down. "Hey," Dad said. "Did you make French toast?"

"Actually," Pop said, "Lily made it. I mean, she taught me how to make it. I just did what she said."

Dad looked at Lily. "You taught Pop French toast?"

"It's easy," Lily said, sitting down at the table. Mom came in right behind Dad and sat down too.

Pop served everyone a slice. They all took their first bites at almost the same time.

The French toast was soft in the middle, crispy on the edges, and sweet with maple syrup.

Pop chewed and swallowed. He looked at Lily. "This is really good," he said. "I didn't know you knew so much."

Lily smiled. "I've been paying attention," she said.

Pop laughed and took another bite. "Well, I'm going to be paying attention to you from now on, if you're teaching."

Lily finished her piece and looked at the last slice on the plate. "Do you want the last one, Pop?"

"I think," Pop said, "we should split it."

They did.


--- RECIPE CARD ---

Lily's French Toast Method

Makes: 5 slices (serves 3–4)

Time: 20 minutes

What You Need:

• 4 eggs

• 1 cup milk

• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract

• 1/2 teaspoon cinnamon

• 5 slices bread (slightly stale is fine)

• 2 tablespoons butter

• Maple syrup, for serving

How to Make It:

  1. Crack the eggs into a big bowl.

  2. Add the milk, vanilla, and cinnamon.

  3. Whisk everything together until the eggs are completely mixed in.

  4. Put a slice of bread in the bowl. Let it soak for 5 seconds.

  5. Flip the bread over. Soak it for 5 more seconds.

  6. Lift the bread up. Let the extra custard drip off.

  7. Put the soaked bread on a plate. Do the same with all 5 slices.

  8. Put a pan on the stove. Turn the heat to medium.

  9. Put the butter in the pan. Wait until it melts.

  10. Lay one slice of soaked bread in the pan. Cook for 2 minutes.

  11. Lift the edge with a spatula. Check if it's golden brown.

  12. Flip it over. Cook for 2 more minutes.

  13. Take it out of the pan. Put it on a plate.

  14. Repeat with the rest of the bread. Add more butter if the pan looks dry.

  15. Pour maple syrup on top. Eat!

Lily's Tips: "Don't poke the bread too much—let it cook!" "If the butter turns dark brown, turn the heat down a little."