← Library

The Message in the Bottle

The Question About Meeting

Isla's Letter

Dear Marco,

I'm writing this letter on Tuesday but I probably won't send it until Saturday so I have time to edit it like I always do. Grandfather says I edit too much but he also says the sea takes its time so maybe my letters should too.

I was sitting on the rocks today. The sea was grey-green, the kind of grey-green that makes you think the ocean is thinking about something very hard. The wind was strong and it kept messing up my hair and I kept pushing it back and then it would mess it up again.

I was thinking about something. Something I've never asked you before.

I know the sea is very big. I know the bottles take different amounts of time. I know there's a whole ocean between us and I've never seen your island and you've never seen my coast and we've sent so many letters that I've stopped counting because it feels like counting stars.

But here's the thing I've been wondering.

Do you think we will ever meet?

Not in a letter. Not in a drawing. Not in the way I can close my eyes and see your ocean even though I've never actually seen it.

I mean truly meet. Actually meet. Where you're real and I'm real and we're in the same place at the same time.

I've been thinking about it for a while now. I wasn't sure if I was allowed to ask. It felt like a big question. The kind of question that's too heavy for a bottle.

But I decided to ask anyway because you're my friend and I tell you true things.

Here is my one true thing for this letter: I don't know if meeting would be wonderful or strange or both, and that's what I'm wondering about.

Also, Grandfather taught me a new knot yesterday. It's called the fisherman's bend. It's for tying two ropes together. He said it's for when you need to make something longer.

I thought you might like to know that.

Write back when you can.

Your friend,

Isla

P.S. The sea is grey-green today and I think it's thinking very hard.


Marco's First Letter

Dear Isla,

Thank you for your letter! I got it on a Tuesday and it was a very good Tuesday.

I showed your letter to Grandmother and she read the part about the fisherman's bend twice. She said your grandfather sounds like a good fisherman. She also said the bread she put in this bottle is for your grandfather but I think she put extra in for you too so share it.

Here is the weather report: it is hot. The sun is very loud today. Not actually loud but you know what I mean. It's so bright I have to squint. My uncle says the sea looks like a mirror that's showing off.

Now I have to talk about what you asked.

You asked if we will ever meet.

I've been reading your letter every day since it came. I put it in my pocket and I read it on the beach and I read it at dinner and Grandmother said I was going to wear the paper out.

I don't have an answer yet.

That's not because I don't want to answer. It's because the question is big and I want to give it the right answer and I don't know what the right answer is yet.

I have a lot of questions about your question.

Like: would we meet on your coast or my island?

Like: would the sea look different if we were looking at it together?

Like: what would we do first?

Like: would we be nervous?

I'm not asking you to answer those questions. I'm just saying I have them.

I'm going to take some time to think about this. I'm sorry if that's a strange thing to do. You're my best friend and I've never taken time before but I think this is important so I want to get it right.

I'll write again soon.

Your friend,

Marco

P.S. The sea today is so blue it looks like it's showing off too.


Marco's Second Letter

Dear Isla,

I'm sending this bottle on a Thursday which is not our usual day but I couldn't wait any longer.

I've been thinking for two weeks. That's fourteen days. That's a lot of days to think about one thing.

I thought about it when I was helping Grandmother with the garden.

I thought about it when I was fixing my boat model.

I thought about it in the morning when the sea was quiet.

I thought about it at night when the sea was doing something I don't have a word for.

And here's what I figured out.

I've been wondering the same thing.

I've been wondering it for a long time. Maybe since we started writing. Maybe since you sent me that list of what the sea looks like at 4pm on your side. Maybe since you told me about your grandfather and I told you about my grandmother and we figured out that grandparents are the same on both sides of the ocean.

I didn't know how to ask. I kept thinking the question was too big for the sea to carry.

But you asked first.

And now I know it's okay to wonder.

So here is my one true thing: I think about meeting you like I think about the weather. It's just part of my days now. Wondering what it would be like. Wondering if you would recognize me from my letters. Wondering if I would recognize you from yours.

I don't know when or how or if it will happen.

But I've been wondering the same thing.

That's all I have to say. That's my whole answer. It's only one sentence but I think it's the truest sentence I've ever put in a bottle.

Your friend,

Marco

P.S. Grandmother sends bread. She says the sea carries things to the right place. This time she's not talking about bread.


Isla's Letter

Dear Marco,

Your letter arrived on a grey day. The sea was the colour of old silver.

I read your sentence four times.

Then I read it again.

I put the letter in my pocket and I walked down to the rocks and I sat where I always sit and I watched the sea for a long time.

The sea was grey-green and then it was silver and then it was grey again.

I think the sea was thinking very hard too.

I don't have a long answer like you did. I just have this:

I'm glad we're both wondering.

That's not a whole letter, I know. But I think it might be enough.

Here is my one true thing: the sea carried your question to me and I'm going to keep it somewhere safe.

Grandfather says hello. He liked the bread. He said it tasted like the sea and I said that's because it crossed the ocean and he said "That explains it then."

Your friend,

Isla

P.S. The sea is grey and silver and I'm still thinking about what it would be like to see it with you.