← Library

The Cook Together Kitchen

The Best Salad Dressing

The Mysterious Bottle

It was a Tuesday evening, and the kitchen smelled like dinner—something warm and garlicky that Mom was stirring on the stove. Lily sat on her step stool, watching.

"Mom, what's that green bottle in the fridge door?" Lily asked, pointing.

"That's salad dressing," Mom said, not looking up from the pot.

"We have salad dressing," Lily said. "So we don't need to buy more."

"We're not buying more," Mom said. "We're making our own."

Lily wrinkled her nose. "Why would we make salad dressing when we already have some in the fridge?"

Mom turned around and smiled. "Because the stuff in the fridge is fine. But the stuff we make is good. It's like the difference between a drawing you do in pencil and one you do with all your favorite colors. They're both drawings. But one of them is yours."

Lily thought about this. "I don't think I understand."

"Come here," Mom said. "I'll show you."

The Jar and the Shaking

Mom pulled a jar out of the cabinet—a glass jar with a lid, the kind that used to hold pasta sauce. She set it on the counter.

"First, we need oil," Mom said. She opened the cabinet and pulled out a bottle of olive oil. "Good olive oil is the star of the show. It's the color of sunshine."

She poured it into the jar. It made a satisfying glug-glug-glug sound.

Lily stood on her tiptoes to watch. "What else?"

"Vinegar," Mom said, reaching for a bottle. "Red wine vinegar—see how it's a little purple? That's where the red wine grapes live."

She poured a smaller amount into the jar.

"That's not very much vinegar," Lily said.

"That's right," Mom said. "The trick is three parts oil to one part vinegar. Three is our oil number, and one is our vinegar number."

Lily held up three fingers, then one finger. "Three and one."

"Exactly," Mom said. "Now, this next part is about flavor. Do you want to help?"

Lily nodded so hard her ponytail bounced.

"Can you measure out a teaspoon of Dijon mustard?" Mom pointed to the little measuring spoons hanging on the wall. "That's the tiniest one."

Lily grabbed the teaspoon and dipped it into the mustard jar. It came out looking like a little orange scoop.

"Put it in the jar," Mom said. "Good. Now the honey."

"Honey?" Lily asked. "In salad dressing?"

"Honey is the mystery that makes everything make sense," Mom said. "Just a little bit. Can you do a half teaspoon? It's a tiny spoon—no, the other tiny one. That's a quarter. We want the one that's a little bit bigger."

Lily found the half teaspoon and carefully scooped honey from the little bear bottle. Some of it dripped on the counter.

"Oh no," Lily said.

"It's fine," Mom said. "The honey always drips. That's what honey does. It's very sticky and very dramatic."

Lily laughed and plopped the honey into the jar.

"One more thing," Mom said. She reached for the salt and pepper shakers. "A pinch of salt—you know how to do that. And three shakes of pepper. You count the shakes."

Lily pinched salt between her fingers and dropped it in. Then she shook the pepper shaker. One. Two. Three.

"Now the garlic," Mom said. She grabbed a clove of garlic and a small metal press. "Do you want to press it?"

Lily loved the garlic press. She put the garlic clove inside, squeezed the handles together, and out came a little pile of garlic mush.

"Smells strong," Lily said.

"It gets mellower when it mixes with the other stuff," Mom said. "Now here's the magic part. Put the lid on the jar."

Lily put the lid on and twisted it until it was tight.

"Okay," Mom said. "Now we shake."

Lily shook the jar. Nothing seemed to happen. She shook it again. The oil and vinegar swirled around, but she could still see them separating.

"Is it working?" she asked.

"Look closely," Mom said. "What do you see?"

Lily held the jar up to the light. "The oil is on top and the vinegar is on the bottom."

"That's right," Mom said. "They don't want to mix. Oil and vinegar are like two people who want to stand on opposite sides of the room. So we have to help them get along."

"How?" Lily asked.

"Shaking," Mom said. "But not gentle shaking. We need strong shaking. The kind of shaking that wakes up the whole bottle. Watch."

Mom took the jar and shook it hard. She shook it up and down and side to side. Then she handed it back to Lily.

"Now you try. Shake it like you're trying to wake up a sleeping giant."

Lily shook the jar as hard as she could. She shook until her arms got tired, then she shook some more.

"Look!" she said.

The liquid in the jar had turned cloudy and thick. It looked like one thing now, not two things fighting.

"That's emulsification," Mom said.

"Emulsi-what?" Lily asked.

"Emulsification," Mom said. "It's when you force two things that don't want to mix to mix anyway. The shaking breaks the oil into tiny, tiny drops, and the mustard helps hold them together. Now they're friends."

Lily looked at the jar. "They don't look like friends."

"They do now," Mom said. "See how it's all one color? That's what friendship looks like in a jar."

The Tasting

Mom took the jar and opened the lid. She sniffed it and smiled.

"Okay, taste tester," she said, grabbing a piece of lettuce from the salad bowl. She dipped it in the dressing and handed it to Lily.

Lily looked at the lettuce. It was shiny with dressing.

"Try it," Mom said.

Lily took a bite. Her eyes went wide.

"Whoa," she said.

"Whoa good or whoa bad?" Mom asked.

"Whoa good," Lily said. "It's like... it's like the lettuce was sad before and now it's happy."

Mom laughed. "That's exactly what a good dressing does."

"Can we put it on the salad?" Lily asked.

"We're going to do better than that," Mom said. "You're going to put it on the salad."

Mom handed Lily the big salad bowl with all the lettuce and vegetables. Then she handed her the jar.

"Pour it in," Mom said. "Slowly, so we can see it."

Lily poured the dressing over the salad. It looked like golden ribbons falling onto the green leaves.

"Now toss it," Mom said.

"I don't know how to toss," Lily said.

"Put your hands on the sides of the bowl like this," Mom said, demonstrating. "And lift and turn. Lift and turn. That's a toss."

Lily put her hands on the bowl and tried. Some lettuce fell out.

"Oops," she said.

"Some always falls out," Mom said. "That's how you know it's really being tossed."

They tossed the salad together. Lift and turn. Lift and turn.

"Now we let it sit for just a minute," Mom said. "The dressing needs to get to know the lettuce."

They waited. Lily watched the salad. The dressing seemed to sink into everything, making it all shine.

"Dad!" Lily called. "Come taste the salad!"

Dad came in from the living room, where he'd been reading the newspaper. "I heard there was some kind of emergency about lettuce?"

"It's not an emergency," Lily said. "It's a discovery."

Dad took a bite of the salad. He chewed. Then he took another bite.

"This is the best salad dressing I've ever had," he said. "Did you make this?"

"We made it," Lily said. "In a jar. With shaking."

"With shaking," Dad repeated. "That's the secret, then."

"The secret is shaking," Lily said. "And also honey. And also the mustard. And also the garlic. But mostly the shaking."

At dinner, everyone ate their salad first, before anything else. Lily watched them all take bites and make happy faces.

"I was wrong," she said.

"About what?" Mom asked.

"About making salad dressing being unnecessary," Lily said. "It's actually very necessary."

"That's what I thought," Mom said. "But I knew you had to taste it to believe it."

"I believe it now," Lily said, taking another bite. "I really believe it."

After dinner, Lily found her recipe notebook and drew a picture of the jar. She colored it golden and purple and green all at once. Underneath, she wrote:

DRESSING IN A JAR

SHAKE IT ALOT

GOOD

She looked at what she'd written. Then she added:

MAKE WITH MOM

Because that was the best part of all.

--- RECIPE CARD ---

Simple Vinaigrette

Makes: about 1/2 cup

Time: 5 minutes

What You Need:

• 3 tablespoons olive oil

• 1 tablespoon red wine vinegar

• 1 teaspoon Dijon mustard

• 1/2 teaspoon honey

• 1 small garlic clove, pressed

• Pinch of salt

• 3 shakes of pepper

How to Make It:

  1. Put all the ingredients in a jar with a lid.

  2. Put the lid on tight.

  3. Shake the jar hard for about 30 seconds.

  4. Look at the dressing—it should look cloudy and mixed together.

  5. Pour it over your salad and toss it up.

  6. Let the salad sit for 1 minute, then eat!

Lily's Tips: Shake it like you're waking up a sleeping giant! And if you spill honey, it's okay—honey is very dramatic, but it wipes up fine.

--- END RECIPE CARD ---