← Library

The Naughty Shelf

Kate Almost Knows

Part One: The Elf Side

The kitchen was quiet. Not the good kind of quiet—the listening kind. The kind where every floorboard held its breath.

“She’s doing it again,” whispered Snatch from behind the toaster.

Fidget pressed himself flat against the wall cavity’s edge, peering through the tiny gap between the skirting board and the cupboard. “She’s not doing anything. She’s making tea.”

“She’s thinking,” said Cobweb, who had appeared beside them without a sound. She always appeared without a sound. It was one of her gifts. “She’s been thinking for three days now.”

They watched as Kate Johnson filled the kettle. She moved slowly. Deliberately. The way humans moved when they were working something out.

“She found the camera,” Snatch whispered.

“She found the decoy camera,” Fidget corrected. “We planted it behind the bread bin. She’s supposed to find that one.”

“Then why is she looking at the cupboard?”

Fidget looked. Kate was looking at the cupboard. Not the cupboard where they kept the emergency supplies. The cupboard next to the cupboard where they kept the emergency supplies. Which meant she was either guessing, or—

“She knows,” said Thimble.

Everyone turned. Thimble was hanging upside down from the underside of the counter, his tiny fingers hooked over the edge. He was always hanging somewhere he shouldn’t be.

“She knows,” he repeated, swinging gently. “I saw her yesterday. She was looking at the Naughty Shelf. And she smiled.”

“She smiles at things,” said Snatch. “Humans do that.”

“She smiled at it. Like she was saying hello.”

The silence that followed was the loudest silence Fidget had ever heard.

Cobweb spoke first. “She’s been here eleven years. In that time, she has lost exactly three hundred and forty-seven socks. She has blamed the washing machine for all of them. She has never once looked at the shelf.”

“Until now,” said Thimble.

“Until now.”

Fidget’s mind was racing. He was good at racing. He was less good at stopping. “Okay. Plan. We relocate. We have the secondary nesting site behind the boiler, we have the emergency tunnel under the floorboards, we have the—“

“We’re not relocating,” said Cobweb. “She’s making tea.”

“She’s making tea and thinking,” said Snatch.

Kate filled her mug. She didn’t look at the cupboard. She didn’t look at the shelf. She looked at the mug, and then she looked at the chair, and then she sat down at the kitchen table and said, very quietly:

“I know someone’s there.”

That quiet was different. That quiet had teeth.

Thimble stopped swinging. Snatch stopped breathing. Cobweb closed her eyes. Fidget counted to six—his personal record, a hundred times over—and then he counted to six again.

Kate sat. She looked at the toaster. She looked at the cupboard. She looked at the wall.

Nobody moved. Nobody even existed.

And then Kate Johnson stood up, poured her tea down the sink, and went to bed.

Part Two: The Family Side

Phil found Kate in the kitchen the next morning, staring at the toaster.

“You’re up early,” he said.

“Couldn’t sleep,” she said.

“Elbows in the cereal?” he guessed. That was his theory from Tuesday. The cereal had been on the table, and elbows were, in his professional opinion, the only plausible culprit.

“No,” said Kate. “I just—I had a strange feeling.”

“What kind of feeling?”

She wanted to tell him. She wanted to say, I think there’s something living in our walls, and I think it’s been living there for years, and I think it knows me. She wanted to say, I almost caught it last night. I almost said something out loud. I almost made it real.

Instead she said, “The kitchen felt different.”

Phil nodded. He nodded the way he nodded when he was humouring her. “Well. Houses settle.”

“Yes,” said Kate. “I suppose they do.”

She looked at the cupboard one more time. The cupboard that wasn’t the emergency cupboard. The cupboard that was just next to the emergency cupboard.

There was a tiny scratch on the door. It hadn’t been there yesterday.

She looked at it for a long time.

Then she made tea, and she didn’t think about it at all. Or, at least, she tried her very hardest not to.

Part Three: The Elf Side

“The plan worked,” said Fidget. “She’s confused. She’s doubting herself. This is exactly where we want her.”

“She said she knew we were there,” said Snatch. “Those were her exact words.”

“She said it to the air,” said Fidget. “There was no one there. She was wrong.”

Cobweb made a small, noncommittal sound.

“What?” said Fidget.

“Nothing.”

“You’re doing the nothing sound.”

Cobweb smoothed her skirt. “She knew we were there because she knows we’re there. That’s not the same as knowing about us. That’s just—knowing.”

“That makes no sense,” said Snatch.

“Welcome to humans,” said Cobweb.

Thimble raised his hand.

“No questions,” said Fidget.

“But—“

“You’re going to ask why she didn’t look in the cupboard.”

Thimble’s mouth closed. It opened again.

“You’re going to ask whether she was scared.”

Thimble’s mouth closed.

“And you’re going to ask whether she’ll come back.”

Thimble nodded miserably.

Fidget looked at the ceiling. He thought about the kitchen, and the woman, and the quiet. He thought about how she’d said the words like she was confessing something.

“I don’t know why she didn’t look,” he said. “I don’t know if she was scared. And I don’t know if she’ll come back.”

He turned to face the colony.

“But I do know one thing,” he said.

“What?” asked Thimble.

“She gave us a warning,” said Fidget. “She told us she knew. And then she left us alone.”

He picked up the tiny gavel, the one that had once been a button on a particularly unfortunate cardigan.

“I think that means she wants us to stay.”

Cobweb said nothing at all. She only smiled.

It was, by elf standards, a very long smile.