Clancys Cove
The Cold Side
The cove woke up different one morning.
Clancy felt it first, as he always did. He was sitting at the edge of the Big Pool, letting the water wash over his shell, when he noticed something strange.
The water on his left felt warm.
The water on his right felt cold.
He lifted one claw and tested the current. Warm on the south side. Cold on the north side. It was like the cove had split itself in two.
"What changed?" Clancy said to himself.
Pepper came skittering across the rocks, her new shell—the one from the tide pool beyond the Channel, the one she'd said was "definitely the one"—bumping against everything in her path.
"Clancy! Clancy! Did you feel it?"
"I feel it," Clancy said.
"The north side is FREEZING," Pepper said. "Five degrees colder than the south! I measured it with my eyestalks!"
"That's not how you measure temperature," Clancy said.
"It's how I measure it," said Pepper. "And it's COLD."
She was right about that much. The fish in the Big Pool had started drifting toward the warm side. The little shrimp were gathered near the Kelp Curtain. The barnacles on the south rocks seemed happier, their feeding fans waving faster.
"The creatures are moving," Pepper said. "They know the good side when they feel it."
She hurried down to the Big Pool and began calling out to everyone.
"Attention! ATTENTION! The north side is cold! You know what that means? MOVE! Everybody move to the south side! That's where the good water is!"
The fish looked at each other.
The shrimp looked at the fish.
The barnacles kept waving their fans.
A small crab near Nori's rock said, "Move where?"
"To the WARM side!" Pepper said. "The south side! It's better there!"
The small crab thought about it. Then it scuttled across the pool to the south side. Other creatures followed. The fish swam over in a shimmering group. The shrimp bounced along behind them.
Soon the south side of the cove was crowded. The north side was empty.
Pepper puffed up with pride.
"See, Clancy? Problem solved. I told everyone to move, and they moved. It's warm over here. Everything is better."
Clancy didn't say anything. He was watching the north side.
"There are still a few who didn't move," he said.
Pepper spun around. Three creatures were still on the north side: a small purple starfish, clinging to the north wall. A lumpy sculpin fish, sitting perfectly still on the cold rocks. And the old rock crab, the one with the missing claw, tucked under the north ledge.
"They're not moving!" Pepper said. "Didn't they hear me?"
"I think they heard you," Clancy said.
Pepper raced over to them. "DIDN'T YOU HEAR ME? IT'S COLD! COLD! You have to move to the south side!"
The starfish didn't move.
The sculpin blinked.
The rock crab looked at Pepper with one slow eye.
"Hello, Pepper," said the rock crab.
"Hello! YES! HELLO! Now MOVE!"
"Why?" asked the rock crab.
"Because it's COLD here!" Pepper said. "The water temperature changed! The south is five degrees warmer!"
The rock crab shifted his legs.
"I like this side," he said.
"You—you WHAT?"
"I like the cold water," the rock crab said. "Always have. This side is better now."
The sculpin blinked again. That was his way of agreeing.
The starfish didn't do anything, but that was her way of agreeing too.
Pepper stared at them. Then she scurried back to Clancy.
"They won't move! Clancy, make them move!"
Clancy looked at Pepper with his very still eyes.
"Why should they?" he said.
"Because it's COLD!"
"For you," Clancy said. "Not for them."
Pepper's mouth opened. Then closed. Then opened again.
"But— but— the temperature changed—"
"Did the water change?" Clancy asked.
"Yes!"
"Or did the temperature change, and now different creatures feel different about it?"
Pepper thought about that.
"I... I don't know," she said.
Clancy walked slowly to the north side of the cove. He settled beside the rock crab.
"This side has always been your spot," Clancy said.
"Best spot in the cove," said the rock crab. "Cold water makes me feel strong. Fast. The warm side makes me sleepy."
Clancy nodded. He looked at the sculpin.
"Cold water has more air in it," the sculpin said. "I breathe better here."
And the starfish? Well, starfish don't talk much. But she had pressed herself flat against the north wall, and she looked very content.
Pepper had followed Clancy. She stood at the edge of the cold water, shivering.
"I thought I was helping," she said quietly. "I thought everyone would want the warm side."
Clancy looked at her.
"You wanted to help," he said. "That's good. But helping means understanding what each creature needs."
Pepper looked at the starfish. The sculpin. The rock crab.
"You all look happy," she said.
"We are," said the rock crab.
"But it's cold," Pepper said.
"For you," said the rock crab. "For us, it's just right."
Pepper was quiet for a long moment.
Then she said, "Oh."
That night, Clancy went under the overhang. He thought for a long time.
The cove waited.
When he came out, he carved a new entry into the Cove Log:
"DIFFERENT CREATURES NEED DIFFERENT CONDITIONS. GOOD FOR YOU IS NOT GOOD FOR EVERYONE."
And somewhere on the north side of the cove, in the cold dark water, three creatures slept very well indeed.