← Library

What Comes Out the End

Junes Experiment

June sat at Uncle Felix's workbench in the Westridge Bottling plant. In front of her sat the Unscrambler—not the whole big machine, but a small test version Felix had built just for her.

"Today," Felix said, "you get to run the experiment."

June flipped open her yellow notebook. She loved experiments.

"The Unscrambler has a speed dial," Felix said, pointing. "You can run it at 80% speed, 100% speed, or 120% speed. Your job is to count what comes out the end."

"Count the bottles?" June asked.

"Count the bottles that come out standing up, ready for the conveyor. Not the ones that fall over. Not the ones that jam. The kept count."

June wrote in her notebook:

THE KEPT COUNT

Machine: Tiny Unscrambler

My question: Which speed gives the most output?

"Start at 80%," Felix said. He set a timer. "Ten minutes. Count every bottle that comes out the end."

June watched. The little Unscrambler rumbled. Bottles tumbled in, spun around, and popped out upright. Some fell over. Some got stuck for a second. June counted.

1, 2, 3... she counted as bottles came out.

Sometimes she lost count and had to start her mental tally again.

"Six!" she called out. "Wait, seven!"

Felix chuckled. "Keep going."

The timer buzzed. Ten minutes.

"Eighty-seven bottles!" June said, writing it down.

"Good," Felix said. "Now let's try 100%."

June turned the dial to 100%. The machine sped up slightly. Bottles tumbled faster. They came out faster too. June watched carefully.

At 100%, the bottles seemed to come out in a nice rhythm. Not too fast, not too slow.

"When!" The timer buzzed.

"One hundred and four bottles!" June wrote. "That's more!"

"Now 120%," Felix said.

June turned the dial to 120%. The machine whirred loudly. Bottles flew around inside. Some bounced. Some jammed for a moment. A bottle fell over and blocked another one.

June counted. 1, 2, 3... a bottle jammed. 4, 5... another jam. A bottle flew out the side and landed on the floor.

The timer buzzed.

"Ninety-one bottles," June said, her voice quiet.

"Interesting," Felix said. "Can you show me the numbers?"

June showed her notebook:

80% — 87 bottles

100% — 104 bottles

120% — 91 bottles

"The output is highest at 100%," Felix said. "But look at how it drops."

June looked at her numbers. From 80% to 100%, the output went UP by 17 bottles. But from 100% to 120%, it went DOWN by 13 bottles.

"That's not even," she said.

"Right," Felix said. "From 80% to 100% it goes up sort of like a straight line. But from 100% to 120% it drops faster than a straight line. It drops harder."

June drew a little graph in her notebook:

104

87 91

|||

80% 100% 120%

"See that?" Felix said. "At slower speeds, the machine has time to catch every bottle. At 100%, it's just right. But past a certain point, faster makes it worse."

"Faster makes it worse?" June said. "That doesn't sound right."

"It's true," Felix said. "And that's the most important thing to learn about machines. When you speed something up too much, it starts throwing bottles away."

June looked at the little Unscrambler. "So the machine isn't better just because it's faster?"

"Exactly," Felix said. "The machine is better when more bottles come out the end. Speed is how fast the machine runs. Output is what comes out the end. Count what comes out."

June wrote in her notebook:

LEARNING: Speed is NOT output.

Past a certain point, faster makes it worse.

The best speed isn't the fastest speed.

The best speed is the speed that gives the most output.

Felix opened his Output Log and showed her an entry:

2015 — Unscrambler, Line 2. Petra wanted to speed it up. Tested speeds. 120% caused jams. Best output at 100%. Result: no speed change, but added a second ramp and air jets. Output went from 45 bottles per minute to 112.

"The manufacturer said the machine would never do more than 80 bottles per minute," Felix said.

"What happened when you told them it was doing 112?" June asked.

Felix smiled. "They asked how. I said I'd keep it to myself."

June laughed.

Felix pointed at her notebook. "Now you have your own entry. Welcome to the Output Log club."

June looked at her numbers one more time.

80% — 87 bottles

100% — 104 bottles

120% — 91 bottles

"Past a certain point, faster makes it worse," she said.

She drew a circle around 104.

"The kept count," she said. "I want to always know the kept count."

Felix nodded. "That's the secret, June. Ask any machine: what comes out the end? Not how fast. Not how hard. What actually comes out."

June closed her notebook. She had a new favorite number.