← Library

The Naughty Shelf

The Negotiation

Book 32 of The Naughty Shelf


PART ONE — ELF SIDE

The emergency parliament session had been called for three in the morning, which was, as Cobweb noted, the only sensible time for emergencies.

Fidget stood before the assembled colony on the Naughty Shelf, his tiny hands clasped behind his back. Behind him, the biscuit-tin parliament chamber gleamed in the moonlight.

"Here is what we know," Fidget announced. "The blue button. The one from Dad's favourite shirt. The one we borrowed for the community hall's lighting system."

A murmur rippled through the crowd.

"It has been discovered missing."

The murmur became a gasp.

"Not missing," Snatch corrected from her position by the shelf edge, watching the door to the utility room. "Misplaced. I put it in the safe place."

"The safe place," Fidget repeated slowly, "was the pocket of the jacket hanging in the hallway."

Snatch's eye twitched. "That was the safe place at the time."

"And then," Fidget continued, "the jacket was given to the charity shop."

Silence.

Thimble raised his hand. "What's a charity shop?"

"A place where humans send things they no longer want," Cobweb said, "which is how we lost the entire Whittaker-era button collection, and also how we gained Thimble, so the universe balances."

"So the button is gone forever?" Thimble asked.

"Not forever," Fidget said. "Because the jacket is currently sitting in a donation bin outside the community centre. And we are going to get it back."

"We're going to leave the house?" Snatch's voice dropped to a whisper. "Outside? The outside outside?"

"The outside is where the jacket is. And the jacket is where the button is. And the button controls the lighting for the entire community hall, and the community hall is where we hold the Annual Borrowing Ceremony, and the Annual Borrowing Ceremony is in three days."

Fidget let this sink in.

"Therefore," he said, "we are going outside."

The parliament erupted.


PART TWO — FAMILY SIDE

"That's odd," said Dad, staring at the hallway.

"What's odd?" asked Mum, walking past with a basket of laundry.

"The donation bin at the community centre. Someone's put a sign on it."

Mum stopped. "What kind of sign?"

"Tiny. Like, really tiny. It says: 'Please return one blue button. No questions asked. Penny for your trouble.'"

Mum peered at the bin. The sign was indeed very small, written on what appeared to be a piece of leaf with startlingly neat handwriting.

"A prank," Dad decided. "Kids these days."

"Kids these days don't write that small," Mum said.

"Kids these days," Dad repeated, with the confidence of a man who had been wrong about everything for seven books, "have too much time on their hands."

Rosie came to look. She squinted at the sign. Then she squinted at the donation bin.

"Dad," she said slowly, "didn't you donate that old jacket today? The blue one?"

"Yes. It had a weird stain on the sleeve."

"What colour was the button?"

Dad blinked. "I don't— I didn't notice."

"Dad." Rosie crossed her arms. "You're telling me you donated a jacket and you don't know if it had a button?"

"I'm telling you I donated a jacket," Dad said, slightly defensive. "Buttons weren't part of the assessment."

Mum sighed. "Phil, buttons are always part of the assessment."

"They are not—"

"A jacket without buttons is a cardigan, Phil. You donated a cardigan."

"I donated a jacket that happened to be missing buttons."

"One button," Rosie corrected. "Probably."

They all looked at the donation bin.

"I'll call the charity shop," Mum said. "See if they can check."


PART THREE — ELF SIDE

The mission was called Operation Button Return. It involved: one coat hook (borrowed), one paperclip (bent into a grappling hook), three metres of dental floss (requisitioned from Leo's bathroom cabinet), and an unprecedented amount of courage.

Snatch volunteered immediately, as she always did. But Fidget shook his head.

"This one's mine," he said.

"You?" Snatch blinked. "You haven't gone outside in five years."

"Which is why I'm going now. The humans are watching the bin. They're confused. They've called the charity shop. The charity shop doesn't know anything. The bin will be opened in the morning, and when it is, the jacket will be inside the shop, and the button will be lost to us forever."

"So how do you—"

Fidget held up the sign he'd written. "We negotiate."


The negotiation took place at dawn.

Fidget stood on the pavement beside the donation bin, dressed in his most formal leaf-cloak, holding a tiny white flag.

Rosie was walking to school. She saw the tiny figure. She stopped.

For a long moment, neither of them moved.

Fidget held up the sign again. 'Please return one blue button. No questions asked. Penny for your trouble.'

Rosie read it. Then she looked at the donation bin. Then she looked at Fidget.

Fidget remained completely still. It was, after all, his special skill. Six minutes. He could hold completely still for six minutes.

Rosie crouched down.

"You want the button," she said.

Fidget didn't move.

"The jacket's in there. The button's probably still on it." Rosie tilted her head. "You can't get in, can you?"

Fidget didn't blink.

"Tell you what," Rosie said. "I'll get it for you. But you have to tell me what you need it for."

Fidget considered this. He had been trained to never negotiate with humans. But he was also a pragmatist, and the Annual Borrowing Ceremony was in three days.

He nodded. Once.

Rosie smiled. She opened the bin, reached in, and pulled out the jacket. The blue button gleamed on the cuff.

She unpicked it. Held it out. Fidget stepped forward, accepted it, and bowed.

"It's for the lighting," he said quietly. "Community hall."

"Right," Rosie said, as if she understood completely. "Community hall."

She turned and walked to school. Fidget returned to the colony, the button warm in his hands.

Neither of them mentioned it to anyone.

But both of them knew.


In the colony that evening, Cobweb watched Fidget carefully place the button into the lighting socket with surgeon's precision.

"You spoke to the girl," she said.

"I negotiated," Fidget corrected.

Cobweb snorted. "In my day, we called that 'talking to a human' and we didn't do it."

"In your day," Fidget said, "what did you do when a button was trapped in a bin?"

Cobweb paused. "We waited."

"For what?"

"For someone to leave it open."

"And if no one did?"

Cobweb was quiet for a long moment. "We found another button," she said finally.

Fidget smiled. "We found the same button."

Thimble, watching from the corner, raised his hand.

"Fidget?"

"Yes?"

"Do you think she'll tell anyone? Rosie? About us?"

Fidget looked out the window. The house was quiet. Rosie's light was on in her bedroom. He watched her shadow move across the curtain, settling into bed.

"No," he said. "I don't think she will."

"How do you know?"

Fidget touched the button. It glowed softly in the light.

"Because she didn't ask for the penny," he said. "She just asked for the truth."