Shell by Shell
The Shell Swap
Scout the hermit crab woke up with a familiar feeling. His shell felt tight. Not just a little snug, tight. The kind of tight that made his legs poke out funny and his eyes bulge extra wide.
“Good morning, Scout!” chirped Pip, his best friend, from inside the shell. “Lovely cozy morning! Lovely cozy... wait. Why is it less cozy than yesterday?”
Scout wiggled. “I think… I think I’ve outgrown this shell. Again.”
“Nope nope nope,” said Pip. “We just moved three weeks ago!”
“Three weeks is a long time for a growing crab,” Scout said.
Just then, a hermit crab named Barnaby scuttled past. Barnaby was carrying a shell that made Scout gasp. It was smooth and speckled, with a perfect curve and not one crack.
“Barnaby! That shell is beautiful!” Scout said.
“It should be,” said Barnaby, puffing out his chest. “It’s the finest shell on the reef. It took me seven days to find it.”
Scout sighed. “I wish I had a shell like that.”
Barnaby looked at Scout’s shell. Then he looked at his own. Then he looked at Scout’s shell again. “Hmm,” he said. “Your shell is smaller. But it’s sturdy. And honestly? My shell is a little roomy. I keep sliding around inside it.”
“My shell is a little tight,” Scout admitted.
“What if… we traded?” Barnaby asked.
Pip poked his head out. “OH NO. A trade? We don’t know that shell. What if it has barnacles? What if it’s haunted?”
“Shells aren’t haunted,” said Scout.
“You don’t know that,” said Pip.
Before Scout could answer, a third hermit crab appeared. Her name was Zelda, and she was carrying a shell that was round and polished and the exact colour of sunset.
“That’s my dream shell,” Barnaby whispered.
“This old thing?” Zelda said. “It’s lovely, but it’s too big for me. I keep tipping over.” She pointed at Barnaby’s shell. “Now THAT shell looks nice and snug. I bet I’d fit in there perfectly.”
Barnaby looked at Scout’s shell. Scout looked at Barnaby’s shell. Zelda looked at both shells and then at Scout.
“Wait,” Scout said slowly. “You want Barnaby’s shell. Barnaby wants my shell. And I want Barnaby’s shell.”
“So do I,” said Zelda, pointing at Barnaby’s shell.
“But you just said you wanted Barnaby’s shell,” said Scout. “And I want Barnaby’s shell. We can’t both have Barnaby’s shell.”
“Then we need a plan,” said Zelda.
“I love plans!” said Pip. “What’s the plan?”
“The plan,” said Scout, “is a shell swap. A three-way trade.”
“A what now?” said Pip.
“It’s simple,” said Scout. “Zelda gives her shell to Barnaby. Barnaby gives his shell to me. And I give my shell to Zelda.”
There was a long silence.
“Wait,” said Pip. “Who gives what to who?”
“Zelda gives to Barnaby,” said Scout. “Barnaby gives to me. I give to Zelda.”
“But I wanted Barnaby’s shell!” said Zelda.
“You’re getting his shell,” said Scout.
“No, I’m getting YOUR shell,” said Zelda.
“Which Barnaby was going to give me,” said Scout.
“But I wanted Barnaby’s shell,” said Zelda.
“You ARE getting Barnaby’s shell!” said Scout, feeling a headache coming on.
Pip whispered, “I think we need a diagram. Or a map. Or a miracle.”
So Scout drew a diagram in the sand with his claw. Three circles. Three arrows. Three names.
“Okay,” he said. “See? Zelda goes here. Barnaby goes here. I go here. Easy.”
Pip stared at the diagram. “I still don’t get it.”
“Let’s just do it,” said Barnaby.
“Fine,” said Zelda.
“Wait,” said Scout. “We have to time it perfectly. We all take off our own shells at the same time. Then we all put on the new shells at the same time. No one is ever without a shell. Understood?”
“Understood!” said Barnaby.
“Understood!” said Zelda.
“I do NOT understand,” said Pip.
“On three,” said Scout. “One… two… THREE!”
And that’s when everything went wrong.
Barnaby panicked and grabbed Zelda’s shell too early. Zelda panicked and grabbed Barnaby’s shell at the same time. And Scout, trying to grab his own shell back, ended up with his claw stuck in Barnaby’s shell with Zelda’s claw stuck in Scout’s shell, and somehow Pip ended up sitting on top of it all, squeaking.
“WHAT IS HAPPENING... oh no. OH NO!”
“Everyone STOP!” yelled Scout. “Stop moving!”
They all froze. There were claws everywhere. Shells were overlapping. Nothing was where it belonged.
Scout took a deep breath. “New plan.”
“There’s a new plan?” said Pip weakly.
“Yes,” said Scout. “Everyone let go. Then everyone steps back. Then we start over... one at a time.”
One at a time was harder. It meant being without a shell for a whole second. For a hermit crab, that’s like standing in the rain without a coat. But they did it. Zelda went first. Then Barnaby. Then Scout.
And when they were done, everyone had a shell that fit.
Zelda got Scout’s shell, perfect and snug.
Barnaby got Zelda’s shell, round and polished.
And Scout got Barnaby’s shell, smooth and speckled with a perfect curve.
Scout wiggled. He turned. He tested his legs. It was just right.
“It fits,” he whispered.
“Of course it fits,” said Barnaby. “It was my shell.”
“It was worth the chaos,” said Zelda.
Pip popped out of the new shell’s front entrance. “I have ONE question. Where do I sleep?”
Scout tapped the shell. “There’s a second chamber in the back. I saved it for you.”
Pip crawled in and immediately fell asleep. “Much better than haunted. Ten out of ten.”
Scout smiled. The shell was new, but his friend was the same. And that, he decided, was the best part of any home.
“It’ll be fine,” he said to himself. “Probably. Maybe. Actually... yes. Let’s go.”