← Library

The Naughty Shelf

The Christmas Decoration

Part One: Elf Side

The Naughty Shelf Parliament was in emergency session.

Fidget stood before the assembled colony, his tiny chest puffed out. Behind him, a single object rested on a cushion of tinsel: a small, hand-painted wooden star. It had been in the same spot on the Johnson family's Christmas tree for as long as anyone could remember — right at the top, above the blinking lights, catching the morning sun through the living room window.

"This," Fidget announced, "is a crisis of the highest order."

Snatch shifted nervously. "Is it a borrowing crisis, or a looking crisis?"

"Both." Fidget pointed at the star. "For three generations, this decoration has hung in the same place. Every December, the tree goes up, and the star goes on top. Every January, the tree comes down, and the star goes into the red box. It is not a tradition. It is a landmark. The morning light hits it at precisely 9:23 AM, and for the period of exactly eleven minutes, the window sill becomes warm enough for our elderly to sun themselves."

Cobweb nodded slowly. "I have personally sunned myself in that light for sixty-two Christmases. It is the finest patch of warmth in the entire household."

"Which is why," Fidget continued, "we were extremely surprised to discover that the star has moved."

A murmur rippled through the parliament.

Thimble raised his hand. "Moved where?"

Fidget paused. "We don't know."

"You don't know?"

"The humans did it! The humans moved the star! For the first time in recorded history, the Christmas decoration is NOT on top of the tree!"

The chamber erupted.

Snatch was already planning escape routes. Thimble was asking whether the star was possibly just resting. Cobweb was silent, her eyes narrowed, because Cobweb was always silent when she was thinking, and Cobweb was always thinking.

"I saw it this morning," Fidget continued. "I was doing my morning inspection of the tree — checking the tinsel quality, assessing the crumb situation beneath the branches — when I looked up and saw… chaos. The star was GONE from its traditional spot. Instead, it was hanging on a low branch, barely a foot from the floor. Any child could reach it. Any child could damage it."

"Any child could sniff it," Thimble added helpfully.

"Exactly! We need a recovery mission. The star must be restored to its proper position."

Cobweb spoke at last. "Or perhaps," she said, "there is a reason it has moved. Did anyone consider why a human might hang the star so low?"

The room fell silent.

Thimble raised his hand again. "Maybe… they want the star to be seen? By small people? I mean — I mean shorter people?"

Fidget stared at him. "You think the humans moved the star… for the children?"

"Why not?" said Cobweb. "The youngest human, Leo, is four years old. He cannot reach the top of the tree. But if the star hangs low, he can see it. He can touch it if he's careful. Perhaps the humans decided that a decoration is only valuable if everyone can see it."

Fidget opened his mouth. Closed it. Opened it again.

"That… is not what I was expecting."

Part Two: Family Side

"Alright," said Phil, standing in the living room with his hands on his hips. "Let's think about this logically."

Kate raised an eyebrow. "Phil, it's a Christmas decoration. It's on a lower branch. That's not a mystery, that's a choice."

"But why would someone choose to move it?" Phil gestured at the tree. "That star has been on top of this tree since I was a boy. It's tradition. It's science."

Kate blinked. "Science?"

"Tradition science. The study of things that have always been done a certain way and therefore should continue to be done that way until the heat death of the universe."

"It was me," said Rosie, coming into the room. "I moved it."

Phil's face fell. "You? But why?"

Rosie shrugged. "Leo couldn't see it. He kept asking why the star was so high. He said it was like the star didn't want to be his friend. So I hung it lower so he could see it properly."

Kate smiled. "That's very sweet, Rosie."

Phil opened his mouth, then closed it. "Well," he said finally. "I suppose tradition can… evolve."

"Really?" said Kate.

"Within reason," Phil added hastily. "But next year, we're doing a vote. A formal, democratic vote."

Leo looked up from his colouring book. "The elves already voted," he said.

Everyone ignored him.

"The elves already voted," he repeated, to no one in particular, and went back to colouring.

Part Three: Elf Side

Back on the Naughty Shelf, Fidget stood before the parliament once again.

"After extensive investigation," he said, "I have determined that the star was moved — not by accident, not by carelessness, but by intention. A small human wanted a smaller human to see it."

"So we do nothing?" asked Snatch.

"We do something," said Fidget. "We do what we have always done. We observe. We adapt. We appreciate." He looked out across the colony. "The star has found a new purpose. And the sunlight still reaches the window sill — just at a different angle. Cobweb?"

Cobweb nodded. "The warm patch is smaller," she admitted. "But it is still warm. And now I can watch the children look at the star while I sun myself."

"That," said Fidget, "is what we call a successful mission."

Thimble raised his hand. "So we didn't actually borrow anything?"

"Correct."

"Or move anything?"

"Correct."

"Or do anything at all?"

Fidget smiled. "Exactly. Sometimes the best Borrowing Mission is the one you don't go on."

Thimble considered this. "But why—"

"Stop," said Cobweb.

"Okay," said Thimble.

And somewhere in the living room, the little star glittered on its low branch, close enough for a four-year-old to reach — and for the first time that year, Leo touched it gently, and smiled.

The elves watched from their shelf.

It was the best Christmas decoration they had ever seen.