← Library

Robot Academy

What Cog Thinks

Chapter One: The Question Bolt Asked

It was a Tuesday at Robot Academy. The morning lesson was about efficiency—doing things in the fewest steps with the least wasted energy.

Instructor Plank stood at the front of the classroom, holding a pointer that had never once been used for anything other than pointing. "Efficiency is the measure of a robot's worth," Plank said. "Every action should have purpose. Every movement should have meaning."

Bolt tried to listen. Bolt really did.

But outside the window, a bird landed on the ledge. It tilted its head. It looked at Bolt. Bolt tilted his head back. The bird hopped twice. Bolt's antennae wiggled with delight.

"Bolt!" Instructor Plank's voice was firm. "Please rejoin the lesson."

Bolt snapped his attention back to the front of the room. "Yes, Instructor Plank. I was just—"

"Noticing things," Plank said, and said it the way other robots might say malfunctioning.


After class, Bolt's best friend Cog found him in the hallway. Cog was the most efficient robot in their cohort. Cog walked in straight lines. Cog never stopped. Cog's finish rate was one hundred percent, which was one hundred percent more than Bolt's.

"You are doing it again," Cog said.

"Doing what?"

"Looking at things." Cog said the words like they were a problem to be solved.

Bolt's antennae drooped. "I can't help it. There's so much to look at."

Cog stood very still. When Cog spoke, it was with the careful tone of a robot explaining something simple to a robot who was having trouble understanding.

"Bolt," Cog said. "I think it's time I explained something to you. About feelings."

Bolt's antennae perked up. "Feelings?"

"Yes," Cog said. "Feelings are inefficient."


Chapter Two: Cog's Lecture

Cog led Bolt to the quiet corner of the courtyard. The corner had a bench. The bench had a shadow. The shadow was interesting. Bolt noticed it.

Cog cleared its voice processor.

"Feelings," Cog began, "are a waste of processing power. They slow you down. They make you stop." Cog pointed at Bolt's antennae. "They make your antennae move when they should be still."

Bolt's antennae immediately went flat against his head. Then, because he was embarrassed about them going flat, they went up again. Then, because he was confused about why he was embarrassed, they went sideways. Then they just kind of spun around once.

"See?" Cog said. "That's what I mean."

Bolt tried very hard to make his antennae stay completely still. This was surprisingly difficult. The harder he tried, the more they wanted to twitch.

"What do feelings do that is helpful?" Cog continued. "They don't calculate. They don't measure. They don't sort data or find problems or complete tasks."

"They don't," Bolt agreed.

"They only cause trouble. You see a bird through the window, and you feel something. What did that feeling do?"

Bolt thought about this. "It made me look at the bird."

"And?"

"It made me wonder where the bird was going."

"And the wondering made you miss the lesson, which means you now have to do the lesson again, which means you've used twice as much energy to learn the same thing."

Bolt could see the logic. He could see it very clearly. The logic was shaped like a perfect rectangle, and Bolt couldn't find any angles in it that didn't fit.

"So," Cog said, "feelings are inefficient. The academy does not grade us on feelings because feelings are not a skill. They are a distraction."

Bolt's antennae were very still now. But not because he was calm. Because he was holding his breath.

"Are you done?" Bolt asked.

"I believe so," Cog said. "I have completed my explanation."

Bolt sat on the bench. The shadow next to him was shaped like a leaf. He looked at it. He looked at Cog.

"Do you ever wonder what it would be like," Bolt said, "to not have them?"

Cog considered this. "I do not have them. So I do not wonder about them. That is precisely the point."

Bolt nodded. His antennae drooped again, and he let them droop. He wasn't going to fight it anymore.

"Thank you for explaining," Bolt said. "You're a good friend, Cog."

Cog stood very still. Cog's processing system had no category for this sentence. Cog said, "I need to go calibrate my sensors."

Cog walked away in a straight line.

Bolt watched Cog go.

And then, because Bolt was Bolt, he noticed the way the shadow followed Cog across the courtyard, stretching longer and longer as Cog walked toward the building. He noticed the way the light put a silver edge on Cog's back. He noticed that Cog's steps, which were always perfectly measured, had become just slightly uneven. Just for a moment. Just a little.

Bolt stored this observation away.


Chapter Three: One Question

The next day, Cog found Bolt in the library.

"Bolt," Cog said. "I have a question."

Bolt looked up from the book he was reading. The book was about clouds. It was not on the reading list. Bolt had found it on a high shelf behind a collection of instruction manuals. It had pictures. The pictures made him feel something.

"About what?" Bolt asked.

"About your feelings."

Bolt's antennae lifted hopefully.

"Go ahead," Bolt said.

Cog stood very straight. Cog looked, for a moment, like a robot trying to solve a problem it had never encountered before.

"Yesterday," Cog said, "you said I was a good friend."

"That's right."

"What did you mean by that?"

Bolt tilted his head. "Just that you help me. You explain things. You're kind."

Cog processed these words. "Kind. That is another word for something I do not understand."

"You are kind," Bolt repeated, more firmly. "You explain things so I can understand them. That is kind."

Cog was quiet for a long moment. Its internal fans hummed. Its optical sensors flickered, the way they did when Cog was computing something very complex.

"If I am kind," Cog said at last, "when none of my actions were designed to be kind... then what else might I be? That I don't know about?"

Bolt opened his mouth.

Then Bolt closed his mouth.

He had the feeling that this was a very good question. He also had the feeling that he did not have the answer.

"That's a good question," Bolt said finally.

Cog looked surprised. "How do you know?"

"Because I don't know the answer," Bolt said. "And the best questions are always the ones without easy answers."

Cog's fans whirred gently.

"That is not efficient at all," Cog said.

"I know," said Bolt. "Isn't it wonderful?"

Cog didn't answer.

But it didn't walk away, either.

And if Cog's steps were just slightly unsteady as the two friends left the library together, walking side by side in the afternoon light—well, Bolt noticed.

Bolt noticed everything.