The Substitute Planet
Ottos Plan
Otto Has a Plan
On Monday morning, Otto stood at the front of Room 4B. He had a clipboard, three charts, and a very serious face.
"I have a plan," he said.
Ms. Venn raised her eyebrows. "A plan for what?"
"For Friday," Otto said. "We're going to Ganymede. Ganymede is the largest moon in the solar system. It's bigger than Mercury. It has a saltwater ocean under its ice crust. It has a magnetic field. And I know something else."
Zara looked up from her journal. "What do you know?"
Otto held up his first chart. "I made a list. This is what I think will go wrong."
The class leaned in. Otto's lists were usually good.
"Number one," he said. "We'll land somewhere unexpected. Ganymede's surface is mostly ice with craters. The landing zone Ms. Venn picked might look different from space. We'll need to find a flat spot."
Ms. Venn nodded. "That's actually—"
"Number two," Otto continued. "Bex will touch something before we finish the safety briefing."
"Hey!" said Bex.
"You always do," said Otto. "It's not a bad thing. It's just a thing."
Bex considered this. "Okay, that's fair."
"Number three," Otto said. "The temperature will be wrong. Ganymede is about negative 160 degrees Celsius. Our suits keep us warm, but they have limits. We'll need to check our heaters first."
Zara was writing everything down. "That's smart."
"Number four," Otto said. "There will be radiation. Ganymede has a magnetic field, but Jupiter also has one. Jupiter's radiation is strong. We'll need to watch our exposure meters."
He held up his third chart. "And number five. The ice. Ganymede's surface is mostly water ice. It might look solid. But there are cracks. Tidal heating moves the ice. What looks safe might not be."
He put down his charts. "So that's my plan. We bring extra supplies. We check our heaters first. We pick a landing zone together. We watch the radiation meters. And Bex gets one minute to touch something safe before we start the lesson."
Bex grinned. "Deal."
Landing on Ganymede
Friday arrived. The Hopper flew past Jupiter's great red storm, around the planet's glowing bands, and toward the biggest moon in the solar system.
Ganymede looked like a ball of dirty snow. Long lines crossed its surface where ice had shifted and cracked. Craters dotted the ground. The sunlight was dim and pale.
"Ganymede is the only moon with its own magnetic field," Ms. Venn said. "Scientists think it has an ocean beneath the ice. It's one of the best places to look for—"
The Hopper beeped.
"What's that?" asked Bex.
Zara checked the screen. "We're being pulled off course."
Otto pointed at his first chart. "Number one. Landing zone different than planned."
Ms. Venn smiled. "You predicted that?"
"I predicted something like it," Otto said. "We'll need to find a new flat spot. The craters on the southern part look smoother."
Kwame looked out the window. "There," he said quietly point at where Ganymede's terminator met the horizon. "That area has fewer cracks. It looks flat."
They landed gently on the ice. The surface crunched beneath the Hopper's landing legs.
"Everyone check your heaters," Otto said.
The class checked. Bex's heater was low. She hadn't charged it after the Titan trip.
"That's on my list," Otto said. "Sort of."
Bex swapped her battery pack. "You're very prepared, Otto. It's a little weird, but I like it."
Walking on the Ice
The class stepped onto Ganymede. The ground was cold and hard. The sky was dark, with Jupiter huge in the distance—a big striped circle with its Great Red Spot staring at them like an eye.
"Wow," said Zara. "Jupiter is huge from here."
Ms. Venn checked her lesson plan. She wanted to talk about how water ice on Ganymede could preserve fossils from ancient life. She was very excited about it. But storms swirling around on the giant gas planet far beyond their view kept making her look up in wonder.
Bex walked toward a small ice ridge. She raised her hand. "Ms. Venn? Can I touch this?"
Ms. Venn blinked. "You're asking?"
"You gave me a minute," Bex said.
Ms. Venn laughed. "Yes. You may touch the ice. Carefully."
Bex touched the ridge. It was smooth and cold. "It's not slippery," she said. "It's more like… rubbery ice?"
Otto frowned. "That's odd. Ganymede's ice should be hard and brittle at this temperature."
Zara was reading her journal. "Wait, I have a note from Io. The volcanic moon. The ice there was warm in places because of tidal heating. Ganymede's ice might be similar—"
That was when the ground rumbled.
The ice ridge Bex had touched started to crack. A line of steam rose from the gap, not steam exactly but vapor from something colder than the ground around it.
"What's happening?" asked Ms. Venn.
Otto checked his charts. "Not on my list," he said. "The ice is moving. There's something under us."
"Under us?" said Bex.
Kwame pointed at the crack. Water was pooling there. Not liquid water, but something slushy and dark.
"Subsurface ocean," he said. "Tidal heating cracks the ice and brings water up. The water flashes into vapor in the low pressure. But the crack is expanding."
The ground shifted again. The crack grew wider.
"I think we should get back to the Hopper," said Zara.
"Wait!" Otto held up his hand. "My plan said check the ice before walking across it. We didn't check."
"You were right," said Bex. "You were right about everything."
Otto looked at the crack, at the water vapor rising, at the class standing on a moon that was actively re-shaping itself around them.
"I wasn't right about this," he said. "The ice is changing. That's the part I didn't predict."
The Real Plan
The class stood very still. The crack was about ten meters away and growing. Cold vapor rolled across the ice.
"Okay," said Ms. Venn. "What do we do?"
Zara opened her journal. "We can jump across the crack. The Hopper is only twenty meters behind us."
"But the crack is wider than we can jump," said Bex.
"It's not going to reach us fast," said Otto, checking his radiation meter. "The crack is moving maybe one meter per minute. We have time to be careful."
"Otto," said Ms. Venn. "Your plan was about getting here. This is about getting back."
Otto looked at his charts, then at the crack, then at Kwame.
Kwame said one thing: "Follow the ridge. The ice at the ridge's edge is older and thicker. We can walk along it and cross where it meets the Hopper's landing legs."
The class looked at the ridge. Kwame was right. The ground near the Hopper was darker and older. The crack was going around it, not through it.
"Let's move," said Ms. Venn.
They walked carefully along the ridge. Otto checked pressure with every step. Zara counted their steps out loud. Bex did not touch anything.
They reached the Hopper and climbed inside. The ground rumbled one more time, then settled.
Through the window, they watched the crack fill with slushy water from the hidden ocean. The water Vapor froze into new ice almost immediately.
"It's making new surface," said Otto. "The crack filled in."
"That's not on your list either," said Bex.
Otto looked at his charts. He smiled a little. "No," he said. "It's not. But the temperature is right, the radiation is okay, and we're all safe."
"You predicted most of it," said Zara.
"I predicted 80 percent," said Otto. "The other 20 percent was Kwame's ridge, and Bex asking first, and all of us working together."
Ms. Venn turned back to the class. "So," she said, "let's talk about Ganymede's ocean. It's bigger than all the water on Earth. It might have more water than every ocean combined. And we just watched it touch the surface."
She looked at the dark cracked line outside. "That's a lesson I couldn't have planned."
Otto looked out at Jupiter, huge and striped and spinning in the dark sky. "Next time," he said, "I'll put 'moon builds new ground' on the list."
Bex laughed. "You should. That was the best part."