← Library

The Dig

BRINGING IT HOME

ONE: THE CITY OF MUSEUMS

Petra had never been to a museum for so long without touching anything.

Usually, museums were where her parents went to look at things. But this trip was different. This trip, they were going to talk about things. And Petra was learning that talking about things—especially things that sat in glass cases—was much harder than digging them up.

They were in London, in a tall building with marble floors that echoed when you walked. Dr. Elena Saleh was pacing in a small room with thick carpet and a long table. Her mother's fingers were doing the thing they did when she was thinking hard—tapping against her thumb, one-two-three, one-two-three.

"Okay," Dr. Elena said. "Okay. Petra, what do you know about the Benin Bronzes?"

Petra sat on a chair that was too big for her. She'd been reading about them in the hotel room. "They're not actually all bronze," she said. "Some of them are brass, and some are ivory. They're from the Kingdom of Benin, which is in modern-day Nigeria. They were made starting in the thirteenth century. They decorated the royal palace."

"Good. And how did they end up here?"

"That's the complicated part," Petra said carefully.

"It is," her mother agreed. "That's why I'm testifying today."

The door opened and Dr. Yusuf Saleh came in, holding two cups of tea. He handed one to his wife. "The hearing starts in twenty minutes. Are you ready?"

"I'm ready," Dr. Elena said. "I'm not sure I'm settled. But I'm ready."

Petra looked at the papers spread across the table. Photographs of beautiful bronze plaques—warriors, kings, animals, scenes from a royal court. Each one had been made by a skilled artist. Each one had a story. And each one had a different story about how it had traveled from the Kingdom of Benin to a museum case in London.

"What are you going to say?" Petra asked.

Her mother sat down. "I'm going to say what I think. And I'm going to try to be honest about the fact that I don't know the whole answer."

"That's what you always say about archaeology."

"That's what archaeology is," her father said quietly. "And repatriation is archaeology's hardest question."


TWO: THE SAME STONE, TWO STORIES

The hearing room was bigger than Petra expected. Rows of chairs faced a long table where officials sat with notebooks. There were cameras in the back, and people from newspapers, and other people who looked like they might be museum directors or lawyers or professors.

Petra sat in the back row with her father. Her mother was at the front, at a microphone, with her papers spread out in front of her.

"The object in question," Dr. Elena began, "is a plaque from the palace of the Oba of Benin. It is one of several thousand objects—carved tusks, bronze plaques, ivory masks—that were taken from Benin City in 1897."

Petra had read about this. A British military expedition had attacked Benin City, and the palace had been burned. The objects that were taken had been sold to museums all over Europe and America. Now there were more than nine hundred of them in the British Museum alone.

"My position," Dr. Elena continued, "is not simple. I am an archaeologist. I believe museums have value. I believe that objects can teach people about cultures they might never encounter otherwise. I have spent my career studying objects that came from somewhere else—and I have benefited from that."

She paused.

"But I have also spent my career learning from the people whose ancestors made those objects. And they are telling me something I need to hear. They are telling me that these objects are not just evidence. They are heirs to a living tradition. The descendants of the people who made these bronzes are still in Benin City. They still have ceremonies. They still have a king—the Oba. And the Oba is asking for his ancestors' art to come home."

A woman at the front table raised her hand. "Dr. Saleh, do you believe that museums should be emptied?"

"No," Dr. Elena said. "I believe that some objects should return. I believe that each case is different. I believe that we need to ask hard questions about how objects were acquired, what they mean to the people who made them, and what they can teach where they are."

She looked at her papers, then back at the room.

"Here is what I cannot tell you: I cannot tell you that there is one right answer. I can tell you what I know. I know that the British Museum has held the Benin Bronzes for over a century, and people from all over the world have seen them there. I know that those same bronzes were made to be seen in a specific place, by a specific people, in a specific context. When you take an object out of its context, you lose part of its meaning—archaeologists know this better than anyone. But you also gain the ability to share it with the world."

She leaned forward.

"Who gets to decide? That's the question. Who gets to define cultural heritage? The people who made it? The people who kept it safe for a hundred years? The people who study it? The people who visit it? All of them? None of them?"

The room was quiet.

"I don't have an answer," Dr. Elena said. "I'm here to tell you what I know about the history, and what I believe about the ethics, and to ask you to think carefully before you decide."


THREE: LUNCH WITH A REPATRIATION SCHOLAR

After the hearing, Petra's family met a man named Dr. Chidi Okonkwo in the museum café. He was a professor from Lagos, and he wore a bright blue shirt with traditional patterns around the collar.

"So," he said to Petra, "what did you think?"

Petra stirred her hot chocolate. "I think it's complicated."

"That's a very smart thing to think," Dr. Okonkwo said. "A lot of adults don't get that far."

"Can I ask you something?"

"Of course."

"If the Benin Bronzes go back to Nigeria," Petra said slowly, "won't people in London not be able to see them anymore? Won't they lose something?"

Dr. Okonkwo nodded. "That's a real question. Let me ask you one back. Have you ever been to Nigeria?"

"No."

"Would you like to go someday?"

"Yes." Petra thought about it. "Yes, I would. I want to see the places I study."

"Me too," Dr. Okonkwo said. "That's part of why I study history. I want to see the places. And when I go to Benin City now, I can see the palace where the bronzes were made—but I can't see the bronzes. They're here, in your museum. Thousands of miles away from the people who made them and the people who still remember them being made."

He took a sip of his coffee.

"There's something else," he said. "Many of the objects in European and American museums came from colonial contexts. They weren't bought fairly. They weren't given freely. They were taken during military conquest, or by colonists who had more power than the people they took from. That doesn't mean the museums are evil—it means the history is complicated. And when the people whose ancestors those objects belonged to say, 'We want them back,' we need to listen."

"But what if the museums keep them safe?" Petra asked. "What if they're in better condition there?"

Dr. Okonkwo smiled. "That's what people said about the Elgin Marbles too. Have you heard of those?"

"Yes," Petra said. "The Parthenon sculptures. Lord Elgin took them from Greece in the early 1800s. Greece wants them back. The British Museum says they're better preserved here, and that they can be seen by more people."

"Right. And there's a real argument there. The British Museum has cared for those marbles for two hundred years. They've been studied, conserved, displayed. Millions of people have seen them. But the Parthenon is their home. And the people of Greece—the descendants of the people who built it—believe they should be there. Who's right?"

Petra was quiet for a moment. "I don't know," she said.

"That's okay," Dr. Okonkwo said. "But here's something to think about. Museums are holding thousands of objects that came from somewhere else. Some were bought fairly. Some were taken. Some were given. And every single one has a story. The question isn't just 'should things go back?' The question is 'how did they get here in the first place?' And 'who should decide what happens next?'"


FOUR: THE BRONZE HEAD

That afternoon, Dr. Okafor—a curator at the museum—led Petra's family through the galleries. He was a kind man with round glasses, and he loved his job. Petra could tell.

"These are some of my favorite objects in the entire collection," he said, stopping in front of a case.

Inside was a bronze head. It was a woman's face, cast in metal, with a high collar made of coral beads. It was beautiful. Petra stood very close to the glass.

"This is from the court of the Oba of Benin," Dr. Okafor said. "It was probably made in the sixteenth century. The artist who made it was one of the most skilled metalworkers in the world at that time."

"How did it get here?" Petra asked.

Dr. Okafor was quiet for a moment. "It was taken in 1897," he said. "I don't know the exact circumstances of this particular piece. But many objects like it were sold to collectors, and eventually made their way to museums."

"Do you think it should go back?"

"I think..." Dr. Okafor paused. "I think I love this object. I've cared for it for twenty-three years. I know the chemistry of its metal, the history of its restoration, the way the light hits its surface. It would hurt to see it go."

He looked at the bronze head.

"But that doesn't mean it shouldn't. The question is whether my attachment is more important than the attachment of the people whose ancestors made it. And I'm not sure I'm the one who should make that call."

Petra pressed her nose to the glass. The bronze head stared back at her, serene and unknowable.

"Someone made this," she said softly. "Someone made it to honor someone they cared about. And now it's here, and the people who made it are gone, but the people who remember them are still there."

"That's exactly right," Dr. Okafor said. "And that's why this is so hard. The object is a physical thing. But it's also a heartstring connecting people across centuries. No matter where it sits, someone is attached to it."


FIVE: THE QUESTION WITHOUT AN ANSWER

That night, Petra sat on her hotel bed with her field notebook.

Her parents were at the little table, working on her mother's testimony. Dr. Elena was writing notes, and Dr. Yusuf was reading something on his small laptop. The lamp made a pool of yellow light.

Petra opened her notebook to a fresh page.

Day 2 in London, she wrote.

Today I saw a bronze head from Benin. It's beautiful. It's been in this museum for over a hundred years. The woman who made it is probably dead. The people she made it for are probably dead too. But their descendants are alive. And they want it back.

My mom says there's no easy answer. I thought there would be one. I thought maybe I would listen and know what I think. But I don't.

She tapped her pen against her chin.

Here's what I know:

  1. Objects have contexts. When you move them, you lose something. (Dad's lesson.)

  2. Objects can teach things to people who would never see them otherwise. (Museum lesson.)

  3. The people who made the objects are not the people who own them now. (History lesson.)

  4. There are good people on every side of this question. (Today's lesson.)

She stared at the page.

Here's what I don't know:

  1. Who should decide?

Underneath, she wrote:

Maybe that's the real question. Maybe the answer isn't "return everything" or "keep everything." Maybe the answer is "figure out each case fairly."

But what does "fairly" mean?

She looked at the word. She crossed it out.

I think "fairly" means letting the people whose ancestors made the object have a real say. Not just being asked for their opinion, but being part of the decision. Maybe even the biggest part.

But also... if I spend my whole life studying ancient things, shouldn't I get to see them?

She wrote that down, then looked at it. Then she drew a circle around it.

I don't know, she wrote. But I'm going to keep asking.


In the morning, before they left for the airport, Petra asked her mother one more question.

"Mom? If you could wave a magic wand and solve the whole thing, what would you do?"

Dr. Elena smiled. She took a long time to answer.

"I would make everyone sit down together," she said. "I would make them all tell each other what the objects mean to them. And then I would make them all listen."

"To each other?"

"To each other. And to the objects themselves. The objects can't speak, but they were made by human hands, for human purposes. The people who made them knew what they wanted them to do. Maybe the best we can do is try to honor that."

Petra thought about the bronze head, serene in its glass case.

"Do you think it would be happier in Benin City?" she asked.

"I don't know," her mother said. "But I think we should ask the people of Benin City what they think. And then we should take what they say seriously."


FIELD NOTEBOOK EXCERPT


Final notes, London trip:

I saw the Parthenon Marbles today. They're enormous. I saw the Benin Bronzes. They're beautiful. I saw a bronze head that someone made 400 years ago and it sat in its case like it was waiting.

Waiting for what?

Maybe I'm wrong. Maybe it's not waiting for anything. Maybe it's just an object. That's what some people say—that ancient things don't have feelings, that cultures change, that it doesn't matter where they sit.

But I don't believe that.

I think it matters.

I think the fact that we care about where things are means it matters.

Open question I'm going to keep thinking about: If I had made this, if my great-grandchildren were alive and I wasn't, would I want them to decide what happened to it?

Or would I want everyone to see it?

Maybe both.

Maybe that's the real answer: BOTH. And it's on us to figure out how.


— P.S.


THE END