Clancys Cove
The Starfish That Wouldnt Move
The morning tide came in pink and gold, and Clancy the crab felt it before he saw it.
Something was different.
He stepped out from under the overhang, his big claws clicking against the rock. The water was warmer than usual. The light was brighter. And the path through the cove was gone.
Not gone, exactly. Blocked.
A large purple starfish sat right in the middle of the main path. It was the size of a dinner plate, with five thick arms and a pattern of orange bumps running down each one. It did not look like it was going anywhere.
"What is THAT?" Pepper the hermit crab skittered up beside Clancy, her shell wobbling. She had found a new one last week, and it was still a little too big for her.
"That," said Clancy slowly, "is a starfish."
"Well, I can see that," said Pepper. "But why is it THERE?"
She pointed a claw at the path. The path was the fastest way from the Big Pool to the Shell Garden. Everyone used it. It was the main road of the cove.
Splash the sea otter floated in from the Kelp Curtain, rolling onto her back to look at them. She had a small crab in her paws and was nibbling it thoughtfully.
"Oh!" she said. "You have a purple one. There's a green one out past the rocks. It hasn't moved in three days."
"See?" said Pepper. "This is a problem. A big one. Right in the way."
She marched up to the starfish and pushed it with her shell.
The starfish did not move.
She pushed harder.
The starfish did not care.
"Come ON," said Pepper, bracing her legs against the rock. "MOVE."
"Pepper," said Clancy.
"Just a little! Just an inch! You can't be that heavy!"
The starfish lay there like a purple stone.
Pepper stepped back, panting. "Okay. That didn't work. But I have another idea."
She walked around the starfish, looking at it from every angle. Then she grabbed one of its arms with her claws and pulled.
The starfish stuck to the rock. It had hundreds of tiny tube feet, and each one was holding on.
"It's not moving!" Pepper shouted.
"It's a starfish," said Clancy. "They don't move when you tell them to."
"Well, maybe it'll move for you."
Clancy looked at the starfish. The starfish did not look back. It didn't have eyes. It just sat there, being a starfish, in the middle of the path.
Everyone in the cove had to go around it now. The small fish took the long way. The shrimp made a wide circle. Even the little crabs had to climb over the barnacle rock to get past.
"See?" said Pepper, watching them struggle. "It's in the way. We have to move it."
Splash floated closer, chewing on a piece of kelp. "It's in the old way," she said.
Pepper turned to look at her. "Same thing!"
"Not the same," said Clancy.
He sat down on a rock near the path and watched. He watched the fish going around. He watched the shrimp taking the long route. He watched the little crabs climbing over the barnacle rock, squeaking as the sharp edges scraped their shells.
"Ouch," said one of them. "These barnacles are sharp."
Clancy watched for a long time.
"I'm going to push it again," said Pepper. "With a stick this time."
Clancy didn't answer. He was thinking.
He walked over to the barnacle rock and examined it. The old path went straight through the middle of the cove, past the flat rocks and the smooth sand. The new path—the one everyone was using now—went around the big boulder, past the edge of the tidepool, and along the strip of fine gravel near the east end.
There were no barnacles on the new path. The gravel was soft. The water was warm there.
"I've got it!" said Pepper, dragging a piece of driftwood twice her size. "Stand back!"
"Pepper," said Clancy.
She swung the stick at the starfish. The starfish absorbed the blow like a couch absorbing a pillow.
"Okay," said Pepper. "That didn't work either."
"Try the new path," said Clancy.
"What?"
"The new path. The one everyone is using now. Try it."
Pepper looked at him like he was speaking fish. "But the path is RIGHT THERE."
"It was," said Clancy. "Now it's here."
He walked over to the new path—the gravel path, the soft path—and walked along it. It was smooth. It was quick. It didn't have any starfish on it.
"It's also warmer," he said. "The morning sun hits this side of the cove first. I never noticed."
Splash rolled over in the water, watching him. "I like the new path," she said. "There's more to see on the way."
Pepper stood in front of the starfish, her claws on her hips. "So we're just going to leave it there? Forever?"
"Not forever," said Clancy. "Starfish move. Just not when you push them."
He looked at the starfish one more time. It was a very beautiful starfish. The purple was deep and rich, like the sky right before it rains. The orange bumps glowed in the afternoon light.
"I think I'll paint it blue," said Pepper.
"Don't paint it blue," said Clancy.
"Fine. But I'm not going around it."
"Then you'll be stuck," said Splash. "And the starfish will still be here."
Pepper huffed. She walked to the edge of the new path. She stepped on the gravel. She took a few steps. Then she stopped.
"It is kind of nice," she said.
"It's soft," said Clancy.
"It's warm," said Splash.
"It's better," said Clancy.
Nori the sea anemone spoke from her rock in the Big Pool.
"The path was never the path," she said. "The path was the way through. They are different things."
Pepper looked at Nori. Then she looked at the starfish. Then she walked the new path all the way to the Shell Garden, and the gravel felt good on her feet, and the sun felt good on her shell.
That night, Clancy carved a new line in the Cove Log under his overhang. He carved slowly, one claw at a time.
TRY THE OTHER WAY BEFORE YOU DECIDE THE OBSTACLE IS THE PROBLEM.
"Done," he said.
The starfish never moved. The next day, it was gone. But the new path stayed, because everyone liked it better.
And when a green starfish appeared out past the kelp, blocking Splash's favorite spot, she just slid over a few feet and floated there instead.
"There's always another way," she said, eating a clam.
There always was.