← Library

The Naughty Shelf

Leo Tells Dad

Part One — Elf Side: The Briefing

The Naughty Shelf Parliament was in emergency session. Fidget stood on the biscuit tin podium, waving a tiny gavel.

"Comrades," he announced, "we have a situation."

Snatch shifted nervously by the door. Cobweb sat in her armchair (a thimble), knitting something that looked like a sock and was probably a community hall.

"The child," Fidget continued.

"Which child?" asked Thimble, who was new and still didn't understand that there were only two.

"Leo," Snatch whispered. "He sees us."

"He's always seen us," Cobweb said without looking up. "That's not new."

"True," Fidget admitted. "But yesterday, he waved."

A silence fell over the parliament.

"At you?" asked Thimble.

"At me. Directly. While I was borrowing a battery from the TV remote."

"He's four," Cobweb said. "Four-year-olds wave at everything. They wave at trees."

"This was a knowing wave," Fidget insisted. "He knows something."

"We need a plan," Snatch said.

"We need cheese," Cobweb muttered. "But plans are fine too."


Part Two — Family Side: The Conversation

That evening, Leo found his father in the living room. Phil was on the sofa, examining the TV remote with a screwdriver.

"The remote has stopped working again," Phil explained. "I believe it's a connection issue. Possibly a loose wire."

"It's the elves," Leo said.

Phil nodded without looking up. "Interesting theory. What makes you say that?"

"Fidget needed the battery."

Phil paused. "Who's Fidget?"

"The elf who lives on the shelf in the utility room. He's the leader. He has a very important job."

Phil set down the screwdriver. He had been through this before. Rosie had an imaginary friend named Princess Sparklepony for six months. Kate said the best approach was patience.

"Leo," Phil said gently, "there are no elves in the house."

"Yes, there are."

"There really aren't," Phil said. "I've checked."

"Where did you check?"

"The kitchen. The living room. The hallway."

"They're behind the walls," Leo said. "And in the ceiling. And under the floor. And in the utility room. There's a whole city in the walls."

Phil smiled. He was very good at explaining things. He had a theory for everything.

"Do you know what imagination is?" he asked.

"Yes," Leo said. "It's when you make things up."

"That's right. And it's wonderful. You have a very good imagination. You're using it to explain things that seem strange. Like the missing socks, and the remote, and—"

"Dad," Leo said. "I'm not making them up."

Phil knelt down so he was at Leo's level. "Son, I promise you. There are no magical creatures living in this house."

"Not magical," Leo said. "Practical."

"Practical?"

"The elves don't do magic. They use tools. They have a system. They have a museum."

Phil blinked. "A museum?"

"For things they've borrowed. There's a sock in there with a plaque. It says 'The Great Borrowing of 2019.'"

Phil didn't know what to say to that. He decided to change tactics.

"Leo," he said, "do you trust me?"

Leo thought about it. "Mostly."

"Then trust me when I tell you that what you're seeing is your imagination. It's a beautiful thing. It means your brain is creative and clever. But the elves aren't real."

Leo went very quiet. Then his face changed.

It wasn't a sad face, exactly. It wasn't angry either. It was... resigned. He looked at his father the way Cobweb looked at Fidget when he was explaining a plan that was about to go wrong. Patient. Tolerant. Slightly apologetic.

"Okay, Dad," Leo said.

Phil felt a small victory. "Good. Now, can you hand me that screwdriver?"

Leo handed it over. "The elves will probably take the new battery too," he said. "Snatch is very fast."


Part Three — Elf Side: The Debrief

"That went well," Fidget said.

"He told his father," Snatch said. "The father said nobody's here. Classic."

"The father believes in theories," Cobweb said, appearing from behind the biscuit tin. "Theories are comfortable. They explain everything and nothing."

Thimble raised his hand. "Why doesn't the father believe Leo?"

"Because believing is scarier than not believing," Cobweb said. "If Leo is right, then the father has been wrong for years. About everything. About the socks. About the cookies. About the remote."

"He's been wrong about twelve things this month alone," Snatch muttered.

"Now, the important question," Fidget said. "Did we get the battery?"

Snatch held it up.

"And the remote will work again once we've used it for the grid?"

"Of course," Snatch said. "I always return things."

"She's never dropped anything," Thimble said proudly.

Cobweb looked toward the living room, where Phil was now trying to put the screwdriver back. "The child sees us," she said. "One day, the father might too. And then what?"

Nobody answered.

Fidget cleared his throat. "I believe," he said, "that's a problem for another day. Right now, we have power to restore and a community hall roof to finish."

The elves went back to work. Above them, in the world of humans, Leo sat at the kitchen table, drawing. When his mother asked what he was drawing, he said, "The museum."

"What museum, sweetheart?"

"The one in the walls. I'm trying to get the roof right."

Kate smiled. "That's lovely, honey."

Leo didn't argue. He just drew.

He knew what he knew.