Robot Academy
Teaching
The New Module
Instructor Plank stood at the front of the classroom with a very serious expression. That was normal. Instructor Plank always had a very serious expression.
"Bolt," said Instructor Plank, "you have been selected to teach the new observational module to the younger cohort."
Bolt's antennae shot up. "Teach? Me?"
"That is what I said."
"But I'm not done with my own learning yet." Bolt paused. "Am I?"
Instructor Plank made a sound that might have been a throat-clearing, if robots had throats. "You have observed things. You have recorded them. You have written them down. We have made a module about it. You will teach it."
"But I don't know how to teach."
"That," said Instructor Plank, "is exactly what you will learn."
Bolt's antennae wilted slightly. Learning by doing was very well, but what if Bolt did it wrong?
Instructor Plank tilted its head. "Bolt. You know things that the rest of us did not know we did not know. This is valuable. This is teachable. Do you understand?"
Bolt thought about this.
"I understand," said Bolt. "I think."
"Excellent. The cohort begins in ten minutes."
Bolt's antennae went very stiff. "Ten minutes?"
"Nine and a half now," said Instructor Plank.
The Cohort
The younger robots sat in a perfect row. There were six of them. They were small and shiny and very new.
Bolt stood at the front of the room and felt very large and very small at the same time.
"Hello," said Bolt. "I am Bolt. I am going to teach you about observation."
One of the robots raised a hand. "What is observation?"
"Observation is noticing things," said Bolt.
The robot lowered its hand. Then raised it again. "What is noticing?"
Good question, thought Bolt. Bolt had never had to explain noticing before. Bolt had just... done it. Like the way rain falls, or the way light finds the edge of a shadow.
"Noticing is when you see something that isn't part of the task," said Bolt. "But then you see it anyway, and it becomes part of the day."
The robots looked at Bolt. Then they looked at each other. Then they looked at Bolt again.
"That sounds like a distraction," said one of them.
Bolt's antennae drooped. "Yes," said Bolt. "It does sound like that. But sometimes distractions are actually the real lesson."
The robots did not look convinced.
Bolt took a deep breath, which was strange because robots do not need to breathe. But Bolt did it anyway.
"Let me show you," said Bolt. "Look at the window."
Six heads turned toward the window.
"What do you see?" asked Bolt.
"The window," said the smallest robot.
"The square glass area with the light coming through it," said another robot.
"An exit point," said a third robot.
Bolt nodded. "Good. Now look again. What else do you see?"
The robots looked. And looked. And then the smallest robot said, "There's a crack in the glass. At the bottom corner. It makes a pattern like a river."
Bolt's antennae lifted. "Yes! That's it! What else?"
"The light is making a circle on the floor," said another robot. "Only it's not a perfect circle. It's wobbly."
"Because the crack bends the light!" said a third.
"Wait," said the smallest robot. "If we'd just seen 'window,' we would have missed all that?"
"Exactly," said Bolt. "And that's what observation is. Seeing more than what you were told to see."
The robots were quiet. Bolt could hear their processors clicking.
Then the smallest robot said, "Can we observe more things?"
Bolt's antennae were doing a little dance.
"Yes," said Bolt. "We absolutely can."
The Trouble
The trouble started during the second exercise.
Bolt had taken the cohort to the courtyard to observe the sky. The instructions were simple: look at the sky and write down three things you notice.
The robots were doing well. They noticed clouds. They noticed colors. They noticed that the sky was changing.
And then Bolt noticed something else.
There was a bird on the academy wall. It was very small and very brown and it was tilting its head exactly the same way Bolt tilted its antennae when Bolt was curious.
Bolt forgot, for a moment, that Bolt was teaching.
Bolt walked toward the bird. The bird hopped along the wall. Bolt followed. The bird flew a little way. Bolt followed again.
Behind Bolt, the cohort was watching.
"Is this part of the lesson?" asked one of them.
"I think it's part of something," said the smallest robot.
Bolt reached the end of the courtyard. The bird hopped onto the fence and then–whoosh–it was gone.
Bolt stood very still, looking at the place where the bird had been.
"Sorry," said Bolt, turning back to the cohort. "I was... observing."
The robots looked at each other.
"You forgot where you were," said one of them. "Didn't you?"
Bolt's antennae drooped. "Yes. I did."
"Is that... allowed?" asked another robot.
Bolt thought about this. "It's not what the curriculum says. But sometimes the lesson and the curriculum are different things."
The smallest robot raised a hand. "Why do you teach us this if it makes you forget things?"
Bolt's antennae went very still. It was a good question. A really good question.
"Because forgetting the lesson," said Bolt slowly, "is not the same as forgetting the point."
The robots looked at Bolt. Bolt looked at the place where the bird had been.
"The point," said Bolt, "is that there are always more things to notice than you planned to notice. And some of them are wonderful."
The smallest robot walked over to the wall. It looked up at the place where the bird had been. Then it looked at Bolt.
"There will be another bird," said the smallest robot. "Probably. If we wait."
Bolt's antennae lifted.
"Probably," said Bolt. "But even if there isn't, we'll notice something else. That's the thing about noticing. It never runs out."
The smallest robot smiled. Robots do not smile very often, but when they do, it's worth seeing.
"Can we wait?" it asked.
Bolt looked at the schedule. The schedule said: Return to classroom for data processing.
Bolt looked at the sky. The sky said: there might be another bird.
"The curriculum," said Bolt, "is flexible."
What We Actually Learned
The next morning, Instructor Plank stood at the back of the classroom while Bolt taught the final session.
"Today," said Bolt, "let me ask you something. What did we learn yesterday?"
The robots thought.
"We learned that windows have cracks," said one.
"We learned that the sky changes colors," said another.
"We learned that birds are fast," said the smallest robot, "and that if you watch a bird leave, you might feel something in your chest, even if you don't have a chest."
Bolt's antennae went very still. "Yes," said Bolt. "That's it. That's the most important thing we learned."
"Feelings?" asked a robot. "But we're robots."
"Sometimes robots have feelings," said Bolt. "Even when we're not supposed to. And sometimes, they're the best part of the day."
The room was quiet.
"Feelings aren't in the module," said one of the robots, very carefully.
"No," said Bolt. "The module is about observation. But if you observe long enough, feelings arrive on their own. They're part of the data."
The robots processed this.
The smallest robot raised a hand. "Will you teach us about feelings?"
Bolt's antennae did a very slight spin. "I think," said Bolt, "you're already learning. You're just not on paper yet."
At the back of the room, Instructor Plank made a note in a file. And if the note said, "Module exceeded. Feelings documented. Continuing," nobody was supposed to know about it.
After
The cohort left, buzzing with observations. They were already pointing at things. Already asking questions.
Instructor Plank approached Bolt.
"How did it go?" asked Instructor Plank.
"I don't know," said Bolt honestly. "I think I taught them something. But I'm not sure what it was."
Instructor Plank was quiet for a moment. Then it said, "That is what teaching feels like."
Bolt's antennae lifted. "It is?"
"The first time," said Instructor Plank, "and the hundredth time."
Bolt looked at the door where the cohort had left.
"They called a bird a feeling in the chest," said Bolt. "They said it even though they're robots."
Instructor Plank made that throat-clearing sound again. "Did you correct them?"
"No," said Bolt. "Because they were right."
The classroom was quiet.
"Dismissed," said Instructor Plank. And then, very quietly, "Well done."
Bolt walked back through the courtyard, past the wall where the bird had been, past the window with the crack that made patterns.
And then something small and brown landed on the wall.
Bolt stopped.