← Library

Clancys Cove

The Smell

The first thing Clancy noticed was the smell.

It wasn't the clean salt smell of the tide. It wasn't the briny smell of the kelp. It was something else. Something underneath.

Clancy sat at the edge of the Big Pool and let the water move over his shell. He tasted the water with his small claws, the way he always did when something felt wrong.

The water tasted a little bit wrong too.

Pepper came skittering across the bottom, her new shell—the one she had picked for optimum style—clattering against the rocks.

"Clancy! Clancy! Can you smell that?"

"I can," said Clancy.

"What is it?" Pepper asked. She turned in a quick circle, which was not easy in a slightly-too-large shell. "Is it something bad? Is it dangerous? Should I get a different shell? I can get a different shell quickly, I'm very good at that."

"I don't know yet," Clancy said.

Pepper was already moving. "I'll find it! I'll check everywhere!"

She went to the Shell Garden first, because she was already near it. She crawled through her collection, sniffing. Nothing smelled unusual except the shells themselves, which smelled like shells.

She checked the Channel. The water moved fast there, and the smell was harder to catch. She checked the Kelp Curtain. She checked the rocks along the north face.

Everywhere she checked, the smell was there.

It was in the water. It was in the rocks. It was everywhere and nowhere.

"I've checked everywhere!" Pepper announced, returning to the Big Pool where Clancy was still sitting. "It's not anywhere. But it's everywhere. I don't understand."

Splash chose that moment to tumble through the Kelp Curtain. She rolled twice, wrapped herself in a strand of kelp, and came to a stop near the Big Pool.

"Whoa," she said. "Something smells like a dead sea pickle."

Clancy blinked. "What does a dead sea pickle smell like?"

"Kind of like that," Splash said. "Only it's not a pickle. It's something that used to be alive and isn't anymore."

Nori, on her rock, said nothing. But her tentacles swayed.

"I checked everywhere," Pepper repeated.

"Not everywhere," Clancy said.

Pepper stopped. "What do you mean? I went to everything. To everywhere."

Clancy didn't answer. He turned and walked slowly toward the Overhang.

"But Clancy—" Pepper started.

"Wait," said Splash. "He's thinking."

Pepper made a small sound of impatience. She clicked her claws together. She turned a circle in her Too-Big-Shell.

"How do you find something you can't smell directly?" Pepper asked.

Clancy stopped at the entrance to the Overhang. He turned around, his eyes still.

"You can't smell directly," he said. "So you eliminate."

"Eliminate what?" Pepper asked.

"Eliminate what it isn't," Clancy said. "What's left is where it is."

He went under the Overhang.

The cove waited.

The water moved in and out with the tide. Splash floated on her back, sniffing the air. Pepper paced. Nori swayed.

Then Clancy came out.

He didn't look different. He never looked different. Movement was movement. He walked to the east end of the cove, where the rocks were deepest and the shadows fell long.

"Eliminate," he said. "It isn't the Channel. The water moves there. It would carry the smell away."

He moved south.

"It isn't the Shell Garden. There's no dead thing there."

He moved west.

"It isn't the Kelp Curtain. The open water would wash it clear."

He stopped at a large rock, deep in the shadows. He reached under it with one big claw.

"It is here."

He pried the rock up. Wedged beneath it was a sea urchin. It had lost its spines and turned soft. Something had happened to it—a sudden shift, a tumble, a rock falling in a storm—and it had gotten trapped. It had been decaying under the rock, hidden from sight, for days.

Pepper looked at it. Then she looked at Clancy. Then she looked at the rock.

"How did you know?" she asked.

"I didn't know," Clancy said. "I eliminated. The smell wasn't in the Channel. It wasn't in the Shell Garden. It wasn't in the open water. Nothing else in the cove smells like that. So it had to be where I hadn't looked."

He lifted the dead urchin carefully and carried it out toward the Channel, where the current would take it away.

When he came back, Pepper was standing in the middle of the cove.

"So I didn't check everywhere," she said.

"Not quite everywhere," Clancy said.

"Can you teach me to eliminate?" Pepper asked.

"I just did," Clancy said.

Splash clapped her flippers. "That's so smart! I would have just floated around and gotten hungry."

Nori spoke. Her voice was low and slow, like water pouring into a deep pool.

"Most things hide in the places we assume are already known," she said.

The cove went back to its business. The tide came in. The tide went out.

Clancy went under the Overhang and carved into the Cove Log. The slate was getting full, but this entry could fit in the last space.

He carved:

"ELIMINATE WHERE IT ISN'T. WHAT IS LEFT IS WHERE IT IS."

Then he came out, and the smell was gone, and the cove smelled like the sea again.