← Library

Fix It or Replace It

Leo Picks Repair or Replace

Leo walked along the fence line with Uncle Magnus. The morning sun was warm, and the grass was wet with dew. They were checking the pasture fence before the summer storm season began.

"Here it is," Uncle Magnus said, stopping.

Leo looked at the fence. It was a long line of wooden posts with wire strung between them. He looked closer at the post Uncle Magnus was pointing to.

The post was cracked. It started at the top and went halfway down. It was like someone had taken a big knife and sliced it partway through. But the post was still standing. It wasn't wiggling or leaning.

"What do you think?" Uncle Magnus asked. "Repair or replace?"

Leo knelt down and looked at the crack. He touched the wood. It was dry and a little rough. He pushed on the post. It didn't move.

"We could fix it," Leo said. "We could put a metal brace on it, or wrap wire around it. Or we could dig it up and put in a new post."

"Which one?" Uncle Magnus asked.

Leo thought. He liked fixing things. It felt good to make something work again. He wanted to say fix it. But he remembered what Uncle Magnus always said.

"What does the job actually need?" Leo said out loud.

"Good question," Uncle Magnus said. "So what does this job need?"

Leo looked at the fence again. He looked at the post. He looked at the field beyond it.

"What's this fence for?" Leo asked.

"Good question too," Uncle Magnus said. "This fence is holding the sheep. The pasture on this side. The road on the other side. We need them to stay in the pasture for the rest of the season. About three more months, until the snow comes."

Leo thought about that. The post was cracked. But it was still standing. It wasn't wiggling.

"If we brace it, would it hold for three months?" Leo asked.

Uncle Magnus nodded. "Probably. The crack doesn't go all the way through. The post is still solid at the bottom. A brace would give it extra support."

"But a new post would be better, right?" Leo said.

"Yes," Uncle Magnus said. "A new post would be stronger. It would last for years. But we'd have to drive to town to get one. That's a two-hour drive each way. Then we'd have to dig up the old post, dig a new hole, set the new post, tamp the dirt, and reattach the wire. That would take most of the day."

Leo looked at the fence again. He thought about the sheep. They were grazing on the other side of the field, not paying any attention to the fence.

"Does this fence need to hold heavy animals?" Leo asked. "Like, do the sheep push against it?"

"Sometimes," Uncle Magnus said. "Especially when the grass is short on this side and looks greener on the other side."

Leo thought about that. The sheep were small. They weren't like cows or horses. They couldn't push very hard.

"I think we should fix it," Leo said. "Just for now. We can put a brace on it. Then, next spring, before the new season, we can replace it with a new post."

"Why?" Uncle Magnus asked.

"Because the job only needs to hold the sheep for three more months," Leo said. "The cracked post is still strong enough for that. A brace will make it strong enough. And a new post would take too long today. We'd spend the whole day on one post instead of checking the rest of the fence."

Uncle Magnus smiled. "You asked the right question. The answer depends on what the job needs."

Leo felt proud. He got his toolbox from the truck. Uncle Magnus handed him a metal brace and some screws.

"I'll get the drill," Uncle Magnus said.

Leo fit the brace against the post. It was a long piece of metal with holes in it. Uncle Magnus came back with the drill.

"Hold it steady," Uncle Magnus said.

Leo held the brace while Uncle Magnus drilled screws into the wood. The screws went in deep, pulling the brace tight against the post. The cracked wood held together.

When they were done, Uncle Magnus pushed on the post. It didn't move. He pushed harder. Still didn't move.

"That'll hold," he said.

Leo pulled out his Fix Log. It was a small notebook he kept in his pocket. He wrote:

Fence post, cracked halfway through. Still standing. Job: hold sheep in pasture, rest of season (3 months). Fix: metal brace on cracked post. Temporary: yes. Noted: replace with new post next spring. Why: better for long term, but job doesn't need it right now. Best tool: brace that works well enough for now.

He showed Uncle Magnus. Uncle Magnus nodded.

"You wrote 'best tool,'" he said. "But you also wrote 'temporary.' That's important. The brace is good enough for now. But it's not a forever fix. We know that. So we'll keep an eye on it and replace it when the job needs it."

"So it's kind of like the come-along on the truck?" Leo asked. "The one you used to get it off the mountain?"

"Exactly," Uncle Magnus said. "The come-along wasn't the right long-term fix. But it was exactly what the job needed at that moment. Same with this brace. It's fit for purpose, right now, for this job."

Leo looked at the fence post with its new brace. It looked a little funny — a metal band on a wooden post. But it was strong. It would hold the sheep.

"Sometimes a temporary fix that knows it's temporary is the right answer," Leo said.

"And sometimes it's not," Uncle Magnus said. "That's why we always ask the question."

"What question?" Leo asked.

Uncle Magnus put his hand on Leo's shoulder. "What does this job actually need right now?"

Leo smiled. He closed his Fix Log and put it back in his pocket. They walked to the next post, and Leo looked at it carefully.

"This one looks good," he said.

"Check the top," Uncle Magnus said.

Leo reached up and touched the top of the post. It was firm. No cracks.

"Good," Leo said.

They kept walking, checking each post. The fence line was long, and the sun was getting higher. But Leo didn't mind. He was asking the right questions. And that was the best fix of all.