← Library

The Cook Together Kitchen

Nanas Pierogi

The Special Day

The kitchen smelled like Sunday. Lily stood on her step stool, wearing the apron with the pocket that was exactly the right size for a spoon.

"Today," Nana said, tying her own apron strings, "we're making pierogi. My grandmother's recipe."

"Your grandmother?" Lily's eyes went wide. "That's a great-grandma."

"Two greats, actually." Nana laughed. "But she taught my mother, and my mother taught me, and now I'm teaching you."

Nana set a big bowl on the counter. "First, we need flour. Can you scoop it for me?"

"All of it?" Lily asked.

"Three cups," Nana said.

Lily scooped carefully, leveling each cup with a knife the way Dad always did. "That's three!" she announced.

"And one egg," Nana said.

Lily cracked it on the side of the bowl. The shell broke in half. She used her fingers to fish out the little crunchies, just like Dad had taught her with pancakes.

"Now a pinch of salt and some warm water," Nana said. "A little at a time."

Lily poured and Nana stirred with a fork until the dough started to gather into a ball.

"Now we knead," Nana said.

Lily pushed and folded the dough. It was soft and a little bit springy.

"Until it's smooth," Nana said. "You'll know when it's ready."

Lily pushed twenty times. "Ready?"

"Almost. Twenty more."

Lily pushed twenty more. "NOW?"

Nana squeezed the dough. "Now." She wrapped it in a towel. "It needs to rest for thirty minutes."

"THIRTY MINUTES?" Lily said.

"Rest is important," Nana said. "The dough gets calm. Then it rolls out easier."

"Like me before quiet time?" Lily asked.

"Yes," Nana said. "Exactly like that."


The Filling

"You want to start boiling these potatoes while the dough rests?" Nana asked.

Lily nodded. Potatoes she knew.

"The big pot," Nana said. "Then the potatoes, peeled and quartered."

Lily put the potato pieces in the pot while Nana filled it with water.

"What if Nana's grandmother made the filling differently?" Lily asked.

"She did," Nana said. "She used cottage cheese. But we're making potato and cheese with a different kind— what's your favorite melted cheese?"

"Sharp cheddar!" Lily shouted.

"Sharp cheddar it is," Nana said. "That was my mother's secret."

"Wait—" Lily said. "Great-grandma used cottage cheese but GREAT-grandma—"

She stopped. "How many greats is your grandma?"

"One great," Nana said. "My mother's mother. She always said the recipe should be passed on but it could change a little with each person who makes it. That's how recipes stay alive."

The potatoes boiled until they were soft. Lily pushed them through a strainer Nana called a ricer— it made the potatoes come out like fluffy snow.

"One cup of shredded cheddar," Nana said, and Lily sprinkled it in. It melted into the warm potatoes.

"Salt and pepper," she said, "but not too much. The cheese brings its own flavor."

Lily tasted the filling. "This is good. Can I eat it with a spoon?"

"You can have a bite," Nana laughed. "But save the rest for the pierogi."


The Folding

The dough was rested. Nana rolled it out flat and thin on the floured counter.

"Use a glass," Nana said. "Cut circles."

Lily pressed the glass down— around and around, making circles in the dough. "This is my favorite part," she said.

"Punching circles out of dough is a good skill," Nana agreed.

Nana scooped a small spoonful of filling onto each circle— not too much, not too little.

"Now the folding," Nana said.

She picked one up, folded it in half, and pressed the edges together. Then she pinched little pleats around the edge with her fingers— pinch, pinch, pinch. It looked like a tiny folded fan.

"Can I try?" Lily asked.

She picked up a circle with filling. She folded it. She pressed the edges.

It squished open in the middle.

"Oops," she said.

"Press harder," Nana said.

Lily pressed harder. One side stayed sealed. The other side flopped open.

Her first pierogi looked like a taco that gave up.

"Try again," Nana said.

The second one had a hole. The filling peeked out like a little potato eye.

"Try again," Nana said.

The third one was lumpy. The edges were crooked. It looked like it had been folded by a happy but very sleepy panda.

"These look terrible," Lily said honestly.

"Let's check the taste," Nana said with a smile.

She dropped the three lumpy pierogi into boiling water. They floated to the top. Nana scooped them out and put them on a plate with melted butter and a sprinkle of salt.

Lily blew on the first one. She bit it.

The outside was soft and chewy. The inside was warm and potato-y and cheese-y and wonderful.

She chewed. She swallowed.

"It tastes PERFECT," she said.

"Of course it does," Nana said. "The taste is the point. The shape is just practice."


The Rest of Them

With her first three pierogi in her belly, Lily's fingers got smarter.

She folded the fourth one. The edges stayed together.

"Look!" she said.

The fifth one had nice pinch marks.

The sixth one looked like it was supposed to look.

"There you go," Nana said. "Now you've got it."

They folded the rest together— circle, fill, fold, pinch, pinch, pinch. The pierogi lined up on a floured tray like a row of little half-moons.

"How many are there?" Lily asked.

"Twenty-six," Nana counted. "Enough for a whole family."

"Enough for the whole street," Lily said.

"Don't get greedy," Nana laughed.

After dinner— pierogi with sour cream and sautéed onions, which Lily was allowed to have on the side— Lily sat with Nana at the kitchen table.

"Can I write this recipe in my book?" Lily asked.

"Please do," Nana said. "That's what it's for."

Lily wrote in her bumpy six-year-old handwriting:

Pierogi. Taste is the point.


--- RECIPE CARD ---

Potato and Cheese Pierogi

Makes: About 26 pierogi

Time: 1 hour 30 minutes

What You Need:

For the Dough:

• 3 cups all-purpose flour

• 1 large egg

• 1 teaspoon salt

• About 1 cup warm water

For the Filling:

• 4 medium potatoes (about 1 ½ pounds)

• 1 cup shredded sharp cheddar cheese

• Salt and pepper, to taste

For Finishing:

• 3 tablespoons butter, melted

• Sour cream (for serving, if you like)

How to Make It:

  1. Put the flour and salt in a big bowl. Crack in the egg.

  2. Add warm water a little at a time, stirring with a fork, until the dough comes together.

  3. Knead the dough on a floured counter for about 10 minutes, until smooth.

  4. Wrap the dough in a towel and let it rest for 30 minutes.

  5. While the dough rests, peel and chop the potatoes. Boil in water until very soft (about 15 minutes).

  6. Mash the potatoes (a ricer makes them fluffy). Stir in the cheese, salt, and pepper.

  7. Roll the rested dough out thin. Cut circles with a glass (about 3 inches wide).

  8. Put a small spoonful of filling on each circle.

  9. Fold each circle in half. Press the edges with your fingers. Pinch small pleats around the edge.

  10. Drop pierogi into boiling water. When they float to the top, wait 2 more minutes, then scoop them out.

  11. Toss with melted butter and a little salt. Serve with sour cream if you want.

Lily's Tips: First ones might look weird— that's okay. They still taste good, because the taste is the point. Boil them in small batches so they don't get crowded!

--- END RECIPE CARD ---