← Library

The Cook Together Kitchen

Grilled Cheese with Pop

The Serious Business of Grilled Cheese

Pop arrived on Saturday with a grocery bag and a very serious look on his face.

"Lily," he said, setting the bag on the counter. "Today we are making the most important sandwich in the world."

Lily climbed onto her step stool. "Is it peanut butter and jelly?"

Pop shook his head slowly. "No, Lily. It is grilled cheese. And I have a method."

"A method?" Lily had never heard Pop say the word "method" before. Mostly Pop said things like "I think that's enough salt" and "where did I put my glasses."

"Yes." Pop pulled things out of the bag one by one. "Bread. Cheddar cheese. Butter." He lined them up like soldiers. "And that's it. The simplest sandwich in the world. But everyone makes it wrong."

"How do you make it right?"

Pop held up one finger. "Rule number one: butter goes on the outside of the bread. Not the inside. Never the inside."

Lily frowned. "But then the butter is on the pan side."

"Exactly." Pop nodded proudly. "That's the secret."

He handed her a butter knife. "Your job is to butter four slices of bread. One side only. The outside."

Lily took a slice of bread and spread butter across it. The bread was soft and warm under her fingers.

"Like this?" she asked.

"Perfect," Pop said. "You're a natural."

She buttered the second slice, then the third. On the fourth slice, she got distracted by the way the butter made a little swirly pattern and pressed too hard. The bread squished flat.

"Oops," she said.

Pop looked at the squished bread. "Squished is fine. Squished melts just as well. That's the good thing about bread."

"But it looks funny."

"We'll put it on the bottom. Nobody sees the bottom."

Lily put it on the bottom.

The Rule About Peeking

Pop placed a big skillet on the stove. "Now," he said, "the heat."

He turned the dial to medium. "Not high. Medium. If you use high heat, the bread burns before the cheese melts. And we want—"

"Melted cheese," Lily finished.

"Exactly. You're learning." Pop smiled. "Now. We put two slices of bread in the pan, butter side down. Then we put the cheese on top. Then the other bread on top, butter side up."

Lily watched the bread land in the pan with a soft sizzle. Pop laid down three slices of cheddar cheese on each sandwich.

"That's a lot of cheese," Lily said.

"Pop's rule: there is no such thing as too much cheese."

"Is that one of your official rules?"

"It's my favorite rule." Pop winked.

The sandwiches sat in the pan. Lily could hear the butter sizzling, a soft, quiet sound. The kitchen started to smell warm and toasty.

"How long do we wait?" Lily asked.

"Until the bottom is golden brown," Pop said. "Maybe three minutes. Maybe four. And here's the important part, Lily." He looked at her very seriously. "We do not peek."

Lily gasped. "We don't?"

"We do not. If you peek, you open the sandwich too early. The cheese doesn't melt right. The bread doesn't get even. Everything is ruined."

"Ruined?"

"Completely ruined." Pop crossed his arms. "The whole thing."

Lily stared at the pan. The sandwiches sat there, toasting. She could smell them. She could hear them. She could almost taste them.

She really, really wanted to peek.

She peeked.

Just one little peek. She lifted the edge of the top slice of bread with her finger and looked inside. The cheese was still solid, a little soft in the middle but definitely not melted.

"I peeked," she said quietly.

"I know," said Pop.

"How did you know?"

"Because I peeked too." Pop shrugged. "Everyone peeks. It's the rule, but it's also a little bit of a joke, because everyone peeks. The trick is you peek and then you put it back together and you wait a little longer anyway."

"So it's not ruined?"

"It's not ruined." Pop handed her a spatula. "Now we flip. Ready?"

Lily took the spatula. She slid it under the sandwich carefully, the way Pop showed her. The bottom was golden brown, perfectly toasted, with little darker spots like freckles.

"Look at that," Pop said. "Beautiful."

She flipped the sandwich over. The new side landed in the pan with a fresh sizzle.

The Melting Part

"Now we wait again," Pop said.

"How long?"

"Same amount. Three or four minutes."

"And we don't peek?"

"Definitely don't peek." Pop looked at the ceiling. "I'm not looking. Are you looking?"

"I'm not looking." Lily looked at her shoes. "Pop, can we peek a tiny bit?"

"No," Pop said.

"Okay," Lily said.

They stood there for a whole minute without looking. Lily counted to sixty in her head. She got to forty-three and lost track.

"Pop," she said.

"Yes, Lily?"

"Why does butter go on the outside?"

Pop thought about it. "Because the butter helps the bread get crispy. It cooks the bread in the butter, kind of like frying. And it gives it that nice flavor. If you put butter on the inside, the cheese slides around and the bread gets soggy."

"So the butter is doing a job," Lily said.

"The butter is doing an important job." Pop nodded. "And the medium heat is doing a job too. If it's too hot, the butter burns. If it's too cold, the cheese doesn't melt. Medium heat is the perfect temperature for cheese to get sleepy and turn into itself."

Lily liked that idea. Cheese getting sleepy and turning into itself.

"I think it's time," Pop said.

Lily flipped the sandwiches again. The second side was golden brown, and this time, when she peeked through the crack in the bread—just a little peek, no one could blame her—the cheese was melted.

It was gooey and stretchy and dripping out the sides a little bit.

"Pop!" she said. "The cheese melted!"

"Of course it melted," Pop said. "That's what cheese does when you give it time."

He slid the sandwiches onto a plate and cut them in half. The cheese pulled apart in long, stretchy strands, then settled back down.

"Look at that," Pop said quietly.

"It looks so good," Lily whispered.

"It's just bread and cheese and butter," Pop said. "But somehow it's the best thing in the world."

They sat down at the table. Lily picked up her half. The bread was crispy and shiny with butter. The cheese was warm and melted. She took a bite.

It made a crunch sound. Then the cheese went soft and warm in her mouth.

"Pop," she said with her mouth full.

"Don't talk with your mouth full," Pop said, with his mouth full.

She swallowed. "This is the best grilled cheese I've ever had."

"That's because you helped make it," Pop said. "Food always tastes better when you make it yourself."

"Or when you make it with someone," Lily said.

Pop smiled. "That too."

And they ate their sandwiches, crispy and golden, with the cheese melted all the way through, in the warm Saturday kitchen, together.


RECIPE CARD

Perfect Grilled Cheese

Makes: 2 sandwiches

Time: 15 minutes

What You Need:

• 4 slices of bread

• 4 tablespoons butter, softened

• 4–6 slices of cheddar cheese

• A big skillet

How to Make It:

  1. Butter one side of each slice of bread. Only butter ONE side. The butter goes on the outside of the sandwich.

  2. Put the skillet on the stove at MEDIUM heat. Not high, not low. Medium.

  3. Put 2 slices of bread in the pan, butter side down.

  4. Put the cheese on top of the bread in the pan. Use 2–3 slices of cheese for each sandwich.

  5. Put the other 2 slices of bread on top, butter side up.

  6. Cook for 3–4 minutes, until the bottom is golden brown.

  7. Flip with a spatula. Cook for another 3–4 minutes.

  8. The cheese should be melted and the bread should be golden brown on both sides.

  9. Take it out of the pan. Cut it in half. Let it cool for a minute. Then eat it!

Lily's Tips: Everyone peeks. Just put the bread back down and wait a little longer. Also, squished bread is fine. Nobody sees the bottom.