← Library

Night Sky Navigators

Are We Alone

The Question Nobody Asked

The red lights along the roof edge blinked on, and Finn was already at the cabinet, bouncing on his heels. Anika sat cross-legged on the old wooden bench, hugging her knees.

Papa Jo unlatched the cabinet with his particular key. The brass telescope caught the last purple edge of dusk.

"Tonight," he said, "I thought we'd look at—"

"The sky," Finn said. "We always look at the sky."

"That's true," Papa Jo said, setting the mount into place with a soft click. "That's the whole job."

Anika was quiet. Finn noticed. Anika was never quiet.

"You okay?" he asked.

She didn't answer right away. She watched Papa Jo fit the eyepiece, watched him check the finder scope against the brightest star rising in the east.

"Papa Jo," she said finally, "is there anyone else out there?"

The rooftop got very still. A neighbor's dog barked somewhere down the street.

Finn felt something open inside him. Anika had said the thing he'd been carrying around for weeks without knowing how to put it into words. All those stars. All those worlds they'd looked at—Jupiter and its moons, the red planet, the distant suns that were really other suns with who knew what circling them. He'd been circling this question too, like a comet around a sun he couldn't quite see.

Papa Jo finished aligning the finder scope. He straightened up and looked at Anika for a long moment.

"Did I ever tell you about—" he started.

"Yes," Finn said automatically. Then he stopped. His mouth hung open.

Wait.

He hadn't heard this one. Whatever was coming next, Papa Jo had never told it before.

Papa Jo smiled—a small, strange smile that Finn had never seen on him. "I thought not," he said. "Come sit down. This one takes a while."

The Equation on the Page

Papa Jo went to the instrument cabinet and took out his blue sky journal. It fell open to a page near the back. Finn had read most of that journal, but he'd never seen this page before.

It was covered in handwriting, and in the middle of all the words was an equation—not math like Finn had seen in school, but symbols and parentheses arranged in a long, careful line.

"What is that?" Anika asked.

Papa Jo sat down on the bench between them. The journal glowed blue in the red roof light.

"In 1961," he said, "a scientist named Frank Drake wanted to think about exactly the question you just asked. So he wrote down everything you'd need to know to answer it. And he put it together into an equation."

Finn squinted at the symbols. "That's the answer?"

"No," Papa Jo said. "That's the question, organized."

He pointed at the journal with a weathered finger.

"To figure out how many intelligent civilizations might be out there in our galaxy, you have to multiply together a bunch of guesses. How many stars are born every year. How many of those stars have planets. How many of those planets could possibly support life. How many of those actually develop life. How many develop intelligent life. How many develop technology that sends signals into space."

"So many steps," Anika said.

"So many steps," Papa Jo agreed. "And every single one of them is a guess. That's what Drake wanted to show. Not that we know the answer—but that we can break the question into pieces small enough to work on."

Papa Jo looked up at the sky. The first stars were showing now, faint and steady.

"The problem," he said, "is that most of the pieces are still empty boxes. We're filling them in slowly, one discovery at a time."

Listening for Whispers

"How do you even start looking for something like that?" Finn asked.

Papa Jo's eyes crinkled. "You start by listening."

He told them about SETI—the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence. Astronomers pointing huge radio telescopes at the sky, not to look at stars, but to listen. To hear if anyone was transmitting.

"They're listening for something natural that can't be natural," Papa Jo said. "A signal with a pattern that no star or gas cloud could make. A hello."

"Like hearing a voice in a forest that should only have wind," Anika said.

"Exactly like that," Papa Jo said.

Finn thought about it. "But the forest is really big."

"The forest is enormous," Papa Jo said. "And we've only been listening for about sixty years, to a tiny patch of the sky at a time. It's like standing at the edge of an ocean with one ear cocked, hoping to hear a single specific fish."

"And we still do it?" Finn asked.

"We still do it," Papa Jo said. "Because a person on the edge of an ocean with one ear cocked—that person is still a person who believes the ocean might be full of things they haven't met yet."

He pulled an eyepiece from his pocket and set it on the mount. "But listening for radio signals is only one way to look. There's another way, and it's newer. It's about finding other worlds entirely."

A Planet Between Stars

"The telescope comes out tonight," Papa Jo said, "because there's something I want you to see. Not a planet with a name. A star with a number."

He swung the telescope toward the east. "About 40 light-years away, there's a star called TRAPPIST-1. It's small and cool and red. And it has seven planets."

"Seven!" Anika leaned forward.

"Seven," Papa Jo said. "And three of them are in what we call the habitable zone—not too close to the star, not too far. The place where water could stay liquid on a planet's surface."

Finn pressed his eye to the eyepiece. "Where is it? I just see a red dot."

"That's the star," Papa Jo said gently. "You won't see the planets through this telescope, Finn. They're too small and too far. We only know they exist because of the way the star wobbles and dims as the planets pass in front of it. We've never seen them directly. But we know they're there."

"The same way you know someone's in the next room," Anika said, "even when you can't see them, because you hear their footsteps."

Papa Jo nodded. "Astronomers have found thousands of planets around other stars. We call them exoplanets. And some of them, like the ones around TRAPPIST-1, are rocky worlds in the habitable zone. The next step is looking at the air around those planets."

"The air?" Finn asked.

"The atmosphere," Papa Jo said. "When a planet passes in front of its star, a tiny bit of starlight filters through the planet's atmosphere. And in that light, there are fingerprints."

He held up his hand. "Every kind of molecule leaves its mark in light. When scientists look at the light that passed through an exoplanet's air, they're looking for biosignatures—chemicals that life would make. Oxygen where there shouldn't be oxygen. Methane that keeps appearing when it should disappear."

"Like finding a campfire that's still warm," Anika said, "in a forest where no one should be."

"That's poetic," Papa Jo said, "and exactly right."

The Honest Answer

Finn pulled back from the eyepiece. The red dot of TRAPPIST-1 glowed patiently, impossibly far away, impossibly small.

"So," he said slowly, "what's the actual answer? Are we alone or not?"

Papa Jo was quiet for a moment. Then he opened his journal to a different page.

"This is what I wrote two nights ago," he said. "After Anika told me she wanted to ask me something tonight."

He read aloud:

"Hundreds of billions of stars in our galaxy. More galaxies than stars we once thought—now we think there are more galaxies than there are grains of sand on every beach on Earth. And around those stars, we've now found thousands of worlds. We've barely begun to look. We've been searching for other life for sixty years with our ears and our instruments and our careful, hopeful mathematics."

Papa Jo looked up.

"That night, I thought about the question all my students used to ask, and the question I asked myself as a boy standing on this roof before I ever dreamed I'd grow old here. And I wrote: We don't know. We honestly, truly, completely don't know. And that is the most beautiful answer there is, because it means the universe is still full of possibility. The end of searching is when the answer is known. We are still at the beginning."

Nobody said anything for a long moment.

The stars came out more fully. The red dot of TRAPPIST-1 hung in the eyepiece, a small red sun with seven hidden worlds, any one of which might hold an ocean, or a whisper, or a campfire still warm.

Anika finally spoke. "So it's okay that we don't know?"

"Anika," Papa Jo said, "for my entire career, I studied stars—their birth and their death. I know what happens when a star like our sun runs out of fuel. I could tell you to the year when Betelgeuse will explode and what it will look like. But the question of whether someone else is looking back at us from somewhere out there? That's the question that keeps a person looking up."

He closed the journal gently.

"Every Friday night, we come up here and we look. And every time we look, we get a little better at seeing. The answer might come tomorrow. It might come in a hundred years. It might come in a thousand. But the looking—the looking is the joy."

Finn thought about all the Friday nights behind him. The moon in its phases. The rings of Saturn. The Andromeda galaxy, faint and ghostly.

All that looking, and the sky still wasn't empty. It was fuller than he'd ever understood.

"Papa Jo," he said.

"Yes, Finn?"

"Did I ever tell you about—"

And for the first time in thirty-eight books, Papa Jo laughed—a real, full laugh—because Finn had turned the ritual around.

"No," Papa Jo said. "I don't think you have."

"I think the answer's yes," Finn said. "There's someone out there. Because look at all this. Look at how much room there is. It'd be a waste to have all this room and be the only ones in it."

"Maybe," Papa Jo said. "Or maybe we're rare beyond measure, and that's exactly why the sky matters so much."

Anika said nothing. She was looking up at the stars, a small smile on her face, and Papa Jo's journal entry for that night would read:

She looked at the sky the way scientists look—not to find an answer quickly, but to stay with the question. Whatever is out there, we will be ready to meet it. Whatever is out there, we will have practiced looking.