Fix It or Replace It
The Broken Bike
Book 35 of the Fix It or Replace It? Series
Leo woke up to the sound of rain tapping against his window. He groaned and pulled the covers over his head. Today was the last day of school before spring break, and he had promised Ms. Chen he would bring the class pet hamster home for the holiday.
But more importantly, today was the day Uncle Magnus was coming to pick him up. They were going to the mountain work site together. Leo had been waiting for this all month.
He jumped out of bed and ran to the window. The rain had stopped, leaving everything fresh and clean. Perfect day for a ride to school.
Leo pulled on his clothes, grabbed his backpack, and ran downstairs.
"Morning, Leo!" his mom called from the kitchen. "Eggs?"
"Just toast!" Leo said, sliding into his chair. "I want to get an early start."
His mom raised an eyebrow. "You're excited about school?"
"About after school," Leo said, grinning. "Uncle Magnus is coming!"
"Ah, right. The great adventure." She smiled and slid a plate of toast across the table. "Don't forget your Fix Log."
Leo patted his backpack. "Already in there."
After breakfast, Leo ran out to the garage to get his bike. It was his favorite way to get to school — the ride through the neighborhood, past the park, down the hill to the school gates. He'd done it a hundred times.
He swung his leg over the seat and pushed off.
The bike felt different. Clunky. The pedals didn't spin freely. He looked down. The chain was hanging loose against the frame.
Leo stopped and hopped off. He examined the chain. It wasn't broken — just off the gears. He knelt down, grabbed the chain with both hands, and re-seated it on the front gear. Then he carefully pulled it up onto the rear gear.
He gave the pedal a test spin. The chain caught and moved with it.
"Easy fix," he said to himself, getting back on.
He rode another block. Then he heard it — a grinding sound from the rear derailleur. He stopped again.
The chain had come off again.
Leo looked closer. The derailleur cable was hanging loose, snapped at the clamp. That was the real problem. The cable controlled the derailleur, which guided the chain between gears. Without the cable, the derailleur couldn't hold the chain properly. The chain would keep slipping no matter how many times he put it back.
"Great," Leo muttered. "Just great."
He thought about turning around and going home. He could ask his mom for a ride to school. That would be easy. But Uncle Magnus would be at the house in a few hours, and Leo didn't want to miss any time with him. And besides, he was Leo. He didn't give up on broken things that easily.
He wanted to fix this.
"Same question," he said out loud. "What does the job need?"
The job needed to get to school. He was halfway there. He could see the school roof from where he stood.
"The job needs a working bike," he said. "Or at least a bike that can get me the rest of the way."
He knelt down and examined the derailleur more carefully. The cable was snapped clean at the bolt. But the bolt was still there. And the cable that was still attached to the derailleur — it was long enough to re-clamp, but only if he could thread it through properly.
Leo checked his bike basket. Inside, he had his water bottle, his Fix Log, and a small toolkit that Uncle Magnus had given him for his birthday. It wasn't much — a multi-tool, some zip ties, a roll of electrical tape, and a few spare parts.
He checked the toolkit. No spare derailleur cable. Of course not.
But wait.
In the side pocket of his backpack, Leo had a spare shoelace. He always kept one there — his mom said it was a good habit, "in case of emergencies."
Leo held up the shoelace and looked at the broken cable. A shoelace was stiff, but it could still bend. Could it replace a derailleur cable? It would be stretchy. It wouldn't shift as well. The derailleur might not move precisely between gears.
But he didn't need precise gears. He needed to get to school. That was it. He could use the middle gear and just stay there for the rest of the ride.
Leo pulled out his Fix Log and opened it to a fresh page. He wrote:
Broken: Derailleur cable snapped
Needed: Get to school (half mile)
Tried: Re-seated chain — worked temporarily, failed again
Using: Spare shoelace as temporary cable
Temporary: Yes — know it's temporary
Permanent fix: New derailleur cable at home
He closed the book, tucked it away, and got to work.
First, he released the old cable from the clamp. He used the multi-tool to loosen the small bolt. The broken end slipped out.
Next, he looked at the cable housing. The shoelace would need to go through it. He pushed the shoelace into one end of the housing, twisting it slightly, guiding it through. It was tight, but it worked.
He emerged from the other end.
Leo threaded the shoelace through the derailleur, around the pulley, and up to the clamp. He pulled it tight, then tightened the bolt.
The shoelace was now the derailleur cable.
He tested it by pushing on the derailleur. It moved. Not as smoothly as before, but it moved.
Leo picked the chain up and placed it back on the gears. Then he checked the rear derailleur position. He was on the middle gear — the one he used most often anyway.
He gave the pedal a careful turn. The chain moved. The derailleur held its position. No slip.
Leo grinned. He got back on the bike and pushed off.
The bike felt different. There was a slight flex when he pedaled, a little more resistance than usual. But the chain stayed on. The bike moved forward.
He rode the rest of the way to school, staying on flat ground, taking it easy on the gears.
When he rolled up to the bike rack at school, he locked his bike and leaned down to look at the derailleur one more time. The shoelace was holding. Not perfectly — it had already started to fray a little from the friction. But it had done its job. It had gotten him to school.
Leo pulled out his Fix Log and added a note:
Shoelace working — did what it needed to do. Not permanent. Will replace with real cable today.
He tucked the book back into his backpack and walked into school.
That afternoon, when school let out, Uncle Magnus was waiting at the bike rack. He was leaning against his truck, a thermos of coffee in his hand.
"Hey there, Leo!" he called. "Ready to head to the mountains?"
Leo ran over and gave him a hug. "Ready! But first — I've got something to show you."
He led Uncle Magnus to his bike and pointed at the derailleur.
Uncle Magnus's eyes went wide. He knelt down and examined the shoelace. Slowly, a grin spread across his face.
"A shoelace, huh?"
"Derailleur cable snapped this morning," Leo explained. "I read the problem. The job needed to get to school. I didn't have a cable, but I had a shoelace. It's temporary — I know it needs replacing. But it got me to school and back."
Uncle Magnus tugged gently on the shoelace. "And how did it ride?"
"Better than walking," Leo said.
"That's the truth." Uncle Magnus stood up. "Fit for purpose, Leo. That's what you did. You asked what the job actually needed, and you used what you had that could do the job for the time you needed it."
He put a hand on Leo's shoulder. "Let me show you something."
Uncle Magnus walked to his truck and opened the tool chest in the back. He pulled out a long, narrow metal object with a crank on one side and a hook on the other.
"This is a come-along," he said. "It's a hand-cranked winch. I use it to pull heavy things — machinery, parts, sometimes even trucks."
Leo looked at it. "That's for pulling, right?"
"That's right. But a few years ago, I was on a job in the mountains. A heavy truck broke down. It needed a part — a specific component that couldn't be ordered for several days. The truck couldn't move on its own. We had to get it down the mountain."
Leo looked at the come-along, then at his bike. "How does the come-along fix a truck?"
"It didn't fix the truck," Uncle Magnus said. "Not permanently. But I attached the come-along to a part of the truck's drivetrain, and I used it to do what the broken component was supposed to do. The truck could move enough to drive out under its own power. We got it to the shop, ordered the right part, and fixed it properly."
He held up the come-along. "The come-along wasn't the right long-term fix. But it was the right fix for that job, at that moment, in those conditions. It got the truck where it needed to go."
Leo looked at his bike, then at the come-along. "So it's like my shoelace."
"Exactly like your shoelace," Uncle Magnus said. "Same question, same framework. Different scale."
He put the come-along back in the tool chest and closed it. "A temporary fix that knows it's temporary is honest. It's a bridge. It gets you to the real fix. But a temporary fix that pretends it's permanent? That's a problem waiting to happen."
Leo nodded. "So I need to replace the cable today."
"Yep. We'll swing by the bike shop on the way to the mountain." Uncle Magnus smiled. "I've got a good derailleur cable at the shop. We'll install it together. Permanent fix for a permanent job."
Leo walked to the truck and climbed in. He looked at his bike in the bed of the truck, the shoelace still holding everything together.
"Same question," he said softly.
"Same framework," Uncle Magnus said.
"Different scale," they said together.
As they drove to the bike shop, Leo pulled out his Fix Log and wrote the final entry:
Permanent fix: New derailleur cable installed with Uncle Magnus. Shoelace did its job. It knew it was temporary. That's what fit for purpose means.
He smiled and closed the book.
Tomorrow, the bike would have a real cable. But today, a shoelace had done exactly what was needed.
And sometimes, that's the best tool of all.